14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Family Law

Undue influence in a will: what a challenge must prove

Undue influence in a will is not the same as pressure, persuasion or disappointment. It is influence of such a kind that the will is not the testator's own expression, and the person challenging the will has to prove it. That is the difficulty: the testator is dead, the only witness to his state of mind cannot be cross-examined, and the propounder holds the document.

The law's answer is the doctrine of suspicious circumstances. Once the propounder has proved the signature and the attestation, the court looks at the will as a whole, and where the circumstances excite suspicion, the propounder must explain them. If he cannot, the will is not proved. An undue influence will challenge therefore begins with the testator's medical record and the circumstances of the signing, not with the terms of the document.

What counts as undue influence

The influence must be coercive: the testator's will must have been overborne, so that what he signed was someone else's intention. The persons who typically have the opportunity are those in a position of trust or dependency — a son with whom the testator lived, a daughter-in-law who managed the household, a caregiver, a lawyer who drafted the will, a spiritual adviser.

What the courts require is evidence of the exercise of that influence, not merely the opportunity. Isolation from the other children, control over the testator's medicines, control over his bank account, a change of residence shortly before the will, and a will that excludes everyone except the person in control — together those are a case. Any one of them alone usually is not.

Mere affection, or the fact that one child cared for the parent in his last years, is not undue influence. A will that rewards the child who looked after the testator is the ordinary case, and the courts uphold it.

Suspicious circumstances, and who explains them

The recognised circumstances include: the will being drafted by the principal beneficiary or his lawyer; the will being kept secret from the family; the exclusion of the natural heirs without reason; the testator being old, ill or under medication; the signature being shaky or in an unfamiliar hand; the will appearing after a family dispute had begun; the propounder taking the testator to the registrar and controlling the event; and a distribution so unequal that it is not the act of a free mind.

The propounder's explanation has to be evidence, not argument. A will that gives the house to the son who lived with the mother can be explained by twenty years of care, the neighbours' evidence and the mother's own statements. A will that gives everything to a caregiver of six months, excluding four children, requires the testator's instructions, the doctor's evidence of capacity, and an explanation of why the children were excluded.

The evidence that decides these cases

Medical records are the first. The prescriptions, the discharge summaries and the treating doctor's evidence show the testator's condition on and around the date of the will. Where the testator was on sedatives or had been diagnosed with a cognitive impairment, the propounder's task is difficult.

The scribe and the attesting witnesses come next. Who called them, where they signed, whether the will was read over, whether the testator spoke, and whether the beneficiaries were present in the room. A will signed in the presence of the sole beneficiary, with witnesses brought by him, carries less weight than one signed at the testator's own lawyer's office with independent witnesses.

The document itself is evidence. Its language, its typography, the spelling of names, the description of the properties, and the way the signature sits on the page can show who prepared it and how much the testator understood. A will that misdescribes the property is a will that someone else drafted.

Bank records and correspondence fill in the history. A testator whose account was operated by the propounder for the last two years, whose pension was drawn by him, and who was moved to the propounder's house a month before the will is a testator whose independence can be questioned.

The forum in Kolkata

Where probate is sought, the challenge is by a caveat in the probate proceeding on the original side of the Calcutta High Court, and the matter is tried as a suit with the propounder leading evidence first. In the districts, the District Judge at Alipore or Barasat hears it.

Where no probate is required, the challenge is raised in the partition or title suit in which the will is relied on, and the party propounding the will must prove it there. A separate suit for cancellation of the will is also possible, and it is usually filed by the heir who was excluded.

An interim step is often worth taking. Where the will is being used to transfer a flat or to operate an account before the probate is decided, the excluded heir can apply for an injunction restraining the transfer, and the injunction preserves the asset while the challenge is heard. A challenge that succeeds after the property has been sold to a bona fide purchaser produces a judgement and no money.

What goes wrong

The first failure is a challenge founded on the unfairness of the distribution. Unequal is not invalid, and a case pleaded only on unfairness is dismissed.

The second is an allegation of forgery without an expert's opinion. The court will not find forgery on suspicion, and the party alleging it should obtain the handwriting opinion and produce the comparison documents.

The third is a propounder who produces the will without the attesting witnesses and without the scribe, and then explains the absence inadequately. The will may still be proved by other evidence, but the risk is unnecessary.

Is a will that favours one child suspicious?

Not by itself. It becomes a suspicious circumstance when combined with others: secrecy, exclusion of all other heirs, the beneficiary's role in drafting, or the testator's dependence on him. The court looks at the whole picture.

What evidence proves undue influence?

Evidence of control and of the testator's dependence: the medical records, the bank operations, the isolation from other relatives, the timing of the will, and the identity of the person who arranged the signing. Direct evidence of coercion is rare, which is why the courts rely on surrounding circumstances.

Does a registered will defeat the challenge?

No. Registration proves the document's existence and date, not the testator's freedom or capacity. A registered will can be set aside for undue influence.

What if the testator was eighty-five and ill?

Age and illness do not by themselves invalidate a will. The question is whether the testator understood what he was signing at the time. The medical evidence, the reading over of the will, and the presence of an independent lawyer go a long way to answering it.

The challenge succeeds or fails on the medical record and the circumstances of the signing, and both should be gathered before the caveat is filed. Our family law practice runs contentious probate on the original side, and the title team handles the partition that follows a will being set aside. Begin at our contact page.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422