14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Family Law

Attesting witnesses: how many, who can sign, if one dies

A will must be attested by two or more witnesses. Each of them must have seen the testator sign or affix his mark, and each must sign the will in the presence of the testator. Two is the statutory minimum, three or four is prudent, and a beneficiary should never be one of them. If a witness dies before the will is proved, the will does not fail: the proof can be given by the surviving witness or, where none survives, by other evidence of the testator's handwriting and the circumstances.

The requirements are in section 63 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, and they are formal requirements in the strict sense. A will that is signed by the testator but not properly attested is not a will, however clear the intention.

What section 63 requires

The testator must sign or affix his mark to the will, or it must be signed by some other person in his presence and by his direction. The signature or mark must be so placed that it appears to have been intended to give effect to the writing as a will.

Each attesting witness must see the testator sign or affix his mark, or see some other person sign in the testator's presence and by his direction. Each witness must then sign the will in the presence of the testator.

The witnesses do not have to sign in each other's presence under this section, though the practice is for both to sign together. What matters is that each saw the testator sign, and each signed in his presence.

Who can be a witness

Any person who is competent to give evidence can witness a will. A person who cannot read is not disqualified, provided he saw the testator sign. A person who is illiterate can sign by a mark, and the mark should be identified.

A beneficiary should not witness. Where a will gives a legacy to an attesting witness, the legacy is exposed to challenge, and the prudent rule is that no person who takes under the will should attest it. The same applies to the spouse of a beneficiary, and to a person who is a beneficiary under an earlier will.

The advocate who drafts the will may witness it, but the better practice is to use independent witnesses who are not connected with the drafting or with the beneficiaries. If the will is challenged for undue influence, the identity of the witnesses becomes part of the evidence.

What happens if a witness dies

The death of a witness does not invalidate the will. Where one witness survives, he is examined at the probate, and his evidence proves the attestation. Where both have died, the will can be proved by other evidence: the evidence of a person who saw the signatures, the comparison of handwriting, and the circumstances of the execution.

The court may also rely on the endorsement of a registrar where the will was registered, and on the affidavit of an attesting witness taken at the time of execution. That affidavit is the practical protection against the death of both witnesses, and it should be obtained when the will is signed, not later.

An affidavit of the attesting witness, recording that he saw the testator sign and that he signed in his presence, is admissible, and it saves the probate from the difficulty of a missing witness.

Defects that invalidate the attestation

  • A witness signs before the testator, so that he did not see the testator sign.
  • A witness is not present when the testator signs, and signs later without the testator's acknowledgement.
  • The testator's signature is a forgery, or was obtained by fraud.
  • The testator's mark is affixed without the required formality, or the person who signed for him did so without his direction.
  • The will is signed on a page that does not form part of the will, or pages are substituted after execution.
  • The witnesses sign a blank paper, and the will is written later.

Each of these is a defect of execution, and each is proved or disproved by the evidence of the witnesses and the appearance of the document.

Proof at the probate

At the probate, the propounder must prove the will as a document executed in accordance with section 63, and must satisfy the court that the testator had the capacity and that the will was not obtained by undue influence or fraud.

Where the will is registered, the registrar's endorsement is evidence, but it is not conclusive. Where the will is not registered, the attesting witnesses carry the proof, and their credibility is examined.

Where the will is surrounded by suspicious circumstances — it is drafted by a person who benefits, it is signed by a testator who was seriously ill, it departs from the previous will without explanation — the propounder must explain the circumstances, and the burden is heavier than in an ordinary case.

The practical formalities

  1. Draft the will, and read it over to the testator in the presence of the witnesses.
  2. The testator signs each page, and the witnesses sign after him, in his presence.
  3. Each witness signs, and the testator acknowledges his signature to them.
  4. Record the witnesses' names, addresses and identity numbers in the attestation clause.
  5. Obtain an affidavit from each witness, at the time of execution.
  6. Consider registering the will, which is optional but adds a record of the date and the execution.
  7. Keep the original in a safe place, and tell the executor where it is.

The Kolkata probate

Where the will falls within the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court, probate is required, and the attesting witnesses are examined in the probate proceeding. The court's practice on proof of execution follows the Act and the Evidence Act, and the affidavits of the witnesses are filed with the petition.

Our succession practice drafts the will and the attestation clause, and the civil litigation practice deals with the contentious probate where the execution is challenged. Where the will concerns immovable property, the registration practice handles the transfer that follows.

How many witnesses are needed?

Two, as a minimum. Each must see the testator sign and must sign in his presence. More witnesses are better, because the death or unavailability of one is then not a problem, and because the credibility of the execution is stronger where several independent persons attest.

Can a family member witness the will?

A family member who takes nothing under the will can witness it. A family member who is a beneficiary should not, because the bequest to him is exposed to challenge and the will's execution is more easily attacked. Independent witnesses are always preferable.

What if both witnesses die before probate?

The will can still be proved, by the evidence of the handwriting, the affidavit of the witnesses taken at the time of execution, the registrar's endorsement if the will was registered, and the circumstances of the execution. The absence of the witnesses makes the proof harder, not impossible, and the affidavit obtained at execution is what makes the difference.

An attesting witness will requirement is a small formality with a large consequence. Two independent witnesses, signing in the right order and in the right presence, and an affidavit from each, are the whole of the protection, and they cost nothing at the time and everything later.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422