A resolution professional has a duty to examine the transactions the company entered into before insolvency, and to apply to the tribunal to undo those that preferred one creditor over others or transferred assets for less than their value. An avoidance transaction ibc application can bring back cash, property or security into the pool, and it is the creditors' cheapest route to a larger recovery. The look-back periods are fixed, the burden shifts to the recipient once the professional makes out the transaction, and the defences are narrow.
The three categories
The Code deals with three main categories. A preferential transaction is a transfer to a creditor that puts him in a better position than he would have been in the distribution under the Code, made within the look-back period. An undervalued transaction is a transfer for consideration that is significantly less than the value of the asset, or a gift. A transaction defrauding creditors is one entered into with the intention of putting assets beyond their reach.
- Preference: a transfer to a creditor, a security created for an existing debt, or a payment made ahead of the process.
- Undervalue: a sale to a related party at a price below the market value, a transfer without consideration, or a transfer against a set-off that was never intended.
- Defrauding: a transfer made with the intent to defeat the creditors' claims, which can be challenged without the same time limit in the case of fraudulent conduct.
The look-back periods
The periods are counted backwards from the insolvency commencement date, which is the date the application was admitted. For a preferential transfer the period is two years. For an undervalued transaction with a person who is not a related party the period is one year, and with a related party two years. For a fraudulent transfer, the intention is the test rather than the period.
The dates are everything. A payment made three years before admission is outside the preference period even if it plainly preferred one creditor, while a payment made twenty months before admission is inside it. The professional's file, therefore, begins with the bank statements and the ledger, and the first question is always when the money moved.
Why preference matters commercially
A company in difficulty often pays its most pressing creditor first — the supplier who will stop supply, the director's relative, the lender who threatens to recall. Those payments are exactly what the provision catches, because the Code is built on pari passu distribution and a pre-insolvency payment defeats it. Recovering the payment increases the pool for everyone, and the recipient has to return the money.
The same logic applies to security. A charge created over the company's assets to secure an old loan, shortly before insolvency, gives that lender a priority it did not have, and the professional can ask the tribunal to treat the security as ineffective for the process.
The burden, and the defences
Once the professional shows that a transfer was made to a creditor within the period, the burden shifts to the recipient to show that the transfer was not preferential. The defences the Code itself permits are worth listing, because they are the ones that succeed.
- Ordinary course of business: the transfer was made in the ordinary course of the company's business or financial affairs, and not with a view to preferring the creditor.
- New value: the security was given for a fresh advance, and the lender would not have advanced without it.
- Substantially contemporaneous: the transfer was a contemporaneous exchange for new value given to the company.
- Good faith and value: for an undervalued transaction, the transferee took in good faith and for value, without notice of the insolvency application.
- No improvement in position: the creditor would have received the same in a liquidation, so the transfer did not prefer him at all.
The applications, and who files them
The resolution professional files the application before the National Company Law Tribunal during the corporate insolvency process, and the tribunal can order the transfer to be reversed, the asset to be restored, the recipient to pay the value, and any security to be released. A liquidator has the same power during liquidation, and the fraudulent trading provision allows the tribunal to order a person who knowingly carried on business to defraud creditors to contribute to the assets.
The committee of creditors sometimes resists these applications, because a plan may depend on the recipient's cooperation, and the professional's duty to pursue them has been the subject of litigation. The correct position is that the professional must place the finding before the committee and bring the application where the committee decides to pursue it, and the committee's assignment of the claim to a third party is a recognised route.
What the recipients should do
A recipient of a demand from a resolution professional should not ignore it. The application, once filed, is heard on affidavits, and the recipient who has not placed his documents on record loses. The documents that matter are the invoices, the delivery proof, the correspondence about the payment, the valuation of the asset transferred, and the evidence that the payment was part of a running account rather than a preference.
For a related party the position is worse. A transfer to a related party carries a longer look-back for undervalue, and the relationship itself supports an inference of intent. Directors and their relatives who received payments in the months before admission are the most frequent respondents.
Where it is litigated in Kolkata
The applications are heard by the National Company Law Tribunal, Kolkata bench, in the same proceedings in which the company is being resolved, and the orders are appealable to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal. The insolvency practice handles the applications for professionals and the defence for recipients, the corporate law team advises directors on the exposure, and a recovery of the restored amount that has to be enforced outside the process is pursued through recovery proceedings.
Can a payment to a supplier be recovered?
Yes, if it was made within two years of admission and it preferred that supplier over the general body of creditors. The supplier's defence is that the payment was in the ordinary course of a running account.
Does the professional have to challenge every transaction?
He has to investigate and report. The decision to litigate is taken with the committee, and the committee can assign the claim. A professional who ignores a plain preference is exposed to a complaint about his conduct.
What is the remedy against a director who took the money?
The preference application against the director as recipient, and a separate application for fraudulent trading where the conduct was deliberate. The director may also face disqualification and a prosecution under the companies law.
Is a sale at a low price always avoided?
No. The transferee's good faith and the payment of value matter, and a sale at a price supported by a valuation obtained at the time is difficult to undo. The professional must show that the consideration was significantly below the value.
The dates, the ledger and the valuation are the whole case. Reconstruct them before the application is drafted, and the burden argument follows.