On admission of an insolvency application, a section 14 moratorium ibc order freezes the corporate debtor's assets: no suit or execution can be started or continued against it, no security interest can be enforced, no asset can be transferred, and no recovery can be made by a lessor or an owner of property in the debtor's possession. What it does not do is protect the directors, the guarantors or the debtor's criminal liability. Understanding the boundary matters in the first week after admission, because the boundary is where most claims are lost.
What the order covers
The provision applies from the date of admission and lasts until the resolution plan is approved or the liquidation order is passed. It prohibits the institution or continuation of suits and proceedings against the corporate debtor, the execution of any judgment or decree against it, the recovery of property by an owner or lessor where the property is in the debtor's possession, the enforcement of any security interest, and the transfer of any of the debtor's assets by it.
- Suits and arbitration: a pending suit stops, and a fresh arbitration cannot be commenced against the corporate debtor.
- Execution: a decree already obtained cannot be executed against the debtor's assets.
- Security enforcement: a bank cannot proceed under the recovery legislation or under the security interest rules against the debtor's assets.
- Recovery of goods: an owner or lessor cannot take back equipment or premises in the debtor's possession, though a landlord's right to evict for non-payment is affected in a more complicated way.
- Statutory and revenue recoveries: attachment and recovery by a revenue authority against the debtor's assets are within the freeze.
The supply of essential goods and services
The order also prevents the termination of supply of essential goods and services to the corporate debtor, and a supplier who cuts off electricity, water, information technology services or raw material during the moratorium acts contrary to the provision. The resolution professional is expected to pay for the supplies made during the process, and the supplier's remedy is to raise the invoice with the professional rather than to stop the supply.
This does not convert every supply into an essential one. A supplier of a specialised component that the plant cannot run without is in a different position from a supplier of an optional item, and the professional decides which supplies are essential in the circumstances. The distinction has been litigated, and the resolutions of the tribunal have depended heavily on the facts of the particular plant.
The exceptions that survive the freeze
The moratorium is wide, but it is not a wall around everything connected with the corporate debtor.
- Criminal proceedings: a prosecution against the company or its officers for an offence continues. The moratorium operates on civil recovery, not on the state's power to prosecute.
- Proceedings against the guarantor: a personal guarantor is a separate person, and the freeze on the corporate debtor does not protect him. The creditor can pursue the guarantor while the resolution process runs.
- Proceedings by a regulator: a statutory authority acting under a special statute — for a penalty, a licence, an environmental direction — is not barred, because it is not recovering a debt from the debtor's assets.
- The secured creditor's right outside the plan: the third proviso to the provision allows a secured creditor to enforce its security against the debtor's assets where the resolution plan does not provide for it, and where the creditor has opted out of the process in the manner the rules allow.
- Suits by the corporate debtor: the debtor, acting through the professional, may still sue to recover its own dues. The freeze protects it from claims; it does not disable its own recovery actions.
The effect on limitation
The period of the moratorium is excluded when computing the limitation for a suit or an application by or against the corporate debtor. A creditor whose limitation would have expired during the freeze therefore has time after it ends, and the exclusion is a statutory one that does not need to be applied for.
Where the boundary is litigated
The disputes that reach the tribunal are mostly about whether a particular proceeding is "against the corporate debtor". A suit against the guarantor is not. A suit against a co-obligor who is a company in its own right is not, unless the tribunal has consolidated the processes. An execution against the personal assets of a director who has given a personal guarantee is not, though the creditor must be able to show that the assets are the guarantor's and not the company's.
The other disputes concern the landlord. A lessor whose premises are occupied by the debtor cannot recover possession during the moratorium on the ground of the debtor's contractual default, but the position on a lease that has expired, or on a lease determined before admission, is different, and the tribunal has allowed possession where the lease had already come to an end. The papers that decide it are the lease, the termination notice and the date of admission.
What the professional must do
The resolution professional takes control of the debtor's assets and must publicise the admission, invite claims, and constitute the committee of creditors. The publication of the admission in the newspapers is also what brings the moratorium to the attention of creditors who have filed suits, and a creditor who continues a suit after publication is at risk of costs. A creditor who has not seen the publication is protected only to the extent that the tribunal accepts the explanation.
The professional also has to decide whether to continue a contract, to keep the establishment running, and to pay the costs of the process. The expenses of the process are treated as costs of the insolvency resolution, and they rank ahead of the creditors' claims in the waterfall.
Where the order is passed and challenged
The order is passed by the National Company Law Tribunal, Kolkata bench, on the application of the creditor or the company, and the moratorium takes effect from the date of that order. An appeal against the admission, and therefore against the moratorium, lies to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal within thirty days, and the appellate tribunal has been willing to stay the moratorium where the admission itself was unsustainable.
The insolvency practice handles the admission, the moratorium and the claims, the recovery practice advises creditors on what survives the freeze, and a creditor who wants to continue an arbitration is advised through the arbitration practice. The connected company law questions are handled under corporate law.
Does the moratorium stop a cheque bounce case?
No. A prosecution for the dishonour of a cheque is a criminal proceeding, and it continues. The creditor cannot, however, enforce a decree for the amount during the moratorium.
Can a bank sell the factory during the moratorium?
Not under its security interest, unless it has opted out under the rules and the resolution plan does not deal with the asset. The ordinary course is that the asset is dealt with in the resolution plan or in liquidation.
Can a landlord evict the company?
Not for a contractual default during the moratorium. Where the lease had already expired or been determined before admission, the position is different and the tribunal examines the dates.
Is the moratorium extended automatically if the process runs late?
It continues until the plan is approved or liquidation begins, and the statutory timeline for the process does not end the moratorium by itself. An extension of the process keeps the moratorium alive.
The order is short and the consequences are large. Before continuing any proceeding, check whether the party is the corporate debtor, the guarantor or a third party, and whether the relief sought touches the debtor's assets — that is the whole of the enquiry.