A bequest to a charity fails, or produces years of litigation, for one of three reasons: the object is not identified precisely enough for the executor to know whom to pay, the institution has ceased to exist or was never registered by the name used, or the gift is so framed that the interest never vests within the period the law allows. Each problem is avoidable at the drafting stage, and each is expensive to cure afterwards.
The dispute is usually not with the charity. It is with the family, which resists a bequest that takes property away from the natural heirs, and which attacks the will on capacity or undue influence at the very point where the charity cannot defend itself.
Identifying the object
"To the orphanage in Kolkata" is not an identification. There may be several, and the executor has no way of choosing between them without exposing himself to a claim from the others. "To the XYZ Trust, registered under the Societies Registration Act, having its office at [address] and registration number [number]" is an identification, and the executor can pay.
The description should include the legal name, the registration number, the address and, where the institution is a company or a society, the fact of its incorporation. Where the testator intends a specific project — a wing of a hospital, a scholarship — the project should be described, and the institution should be asked in advance whether it will accept the gift on those terms.
A bequest to "the poor" or "for charitable purposes" is a bequest to a purpose rather than to a person, and it is valid only if the will creates a trust with a trustee who can apply the property to the purpose. Without a trustee, the executor cannot give a discharge, and the gift is at risk.
The institution that no longer exists
A charity named in a will may have closed, merged or changed its name by the time the testator dies. The executor then has no payee, and the family argues that the gift has lapsed.
The drafting answer is an alternative clause: a gift to the named institution, and if it has ceased to exist or refuses the gift, to a named successor or to a described class of institutions to be selected by the executor or the trustees. A clause of that kind keeps the gift alive, and it is the single most useful addition to a charitable bequest.
Where the gift is to a trust that is to be formed after the testator's death, the position is more delicate. A bequest to an institution not in existence at the testator's death may fail, and the rules on bequests to persons not in existence apply. The will should either create the trust itself, with the trustees named and the property vested in them on the testator's death, or make the gift to an existing institution with a direction as to its use.
Perpetuity and vesting
The Indian Succession Act contains rules against perpetuity. A bequest that postpones the vesting of the interest beyond the period the law allows is void to that extent, and a bequest to an unborn person is subject to strict conditions.
A charitable bequest is treated more generously than a private one, because the purpose is public, but the drafting still has to ensure that the interest vests. A gift to trustees for a charitable purpose vests in the trustees at the testator's death, and the purpose is carried out by them. A gift that is to take effect only when some future event occurs, with no vesting in the meantime, invites the objection that it offends the rule.
The safest structure is a direct gift to an identified institution, or to named trustees for an identified purpose, with the property vesting on death and the purpose carried out from that date.
The trust structure
Where the testator wants a continuing charitable arrangement rather than a one-off gift, the will can create a trust. The trust deed, or the will itself, sets out the trustees, the purpose, the powers and the mode of administration. The trustees hold the property for the purpose, and the beneficiaries are the objects of the charity, not individuals.
The trust needs the registration and the tax compliance that any charitable institution needs: the income-tax registration for exemption, the audit, and the filings. A will that creates a trust without providing for its administration leaves the trustees with a duty and no machinery.
Where the trust receives foreign contributions, the foreign contribution law applies, and the registration under that law is a separate requirement. A bequest from a person abroad to an Indian trust raises the same question, and the trust's registration status should be checked before the will is drafted.
The family's challenge
The commonest attack is on capacity and undue influence. The testator was elderly, the charity's representatives visited regularly, and the will leaves a substantial part of the estate away from the children. The court will examine the instructions, the drafting, the witnesses and the medical position.
A will drafted by the charity's lawyer, witnessed by the charity's staff, and signed in the charity's office is a will that invites the suspicion. Independent drafting, independent witnesses and a medical certificate of capacity, obtained near the date of the will, are the protections.
A video recording of the instructions, made with the testator's consent and preserved, is also useful, though it is not a substitute for the statutory formalities.
The tax treatment
A bequest to a charitable institution is not a transfer for capital gains, and the estate's tax position on the assets is worked out in the administration. The institution's own exemption depends on its registration and on its compliance, and a gift to an institution that is not registered may produce a tax liability in its hands.
The donor's estate may claim a deduction in defined circumstances, and the executor should obtain advice on the estate's return rather than assume that the charitable character of the gift settles the tax question.
The Kolkata probate
Where the will falls within the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court, probate is required, and the charity's claim is established through the grant. The executor's authority to pay the legacy comes from the probate, and the charity should ask for a certified copy of the will and the grant.
Our trust and succession practice drafts the charitable clause and handles the probate, and the registration practice deals with the transfer of any immovable property to the institution. Where the bequest is challenged, the civil litigation practice conducts the defence.
Can I leave property to a charity in my will?
Yes, and the bequest is valid if the institution is identified with precision and exists at your death. The will should name the institution, give its registration number and address, and provide for an alternative if it has ceased to exist. A gift for a purpose rather than to an institution should create a trust with named trustees.
What happens if the charity has closed by the time I die?
The gift lapses unless the will provides an alternative. That is why the clause should name a successor institution or a class of institutions from which the executor may select, and should record the testator's intention that the gift be applied to a similar purpose. Without such a clause, the property returns to the residue and passes to the heirs.
Is a bequest to a trust taxable?
The bequest itself is not a transfer for capital gains, and it is not income in the hands of the institution if the institution is a registered charitable trust. If it is not registered, or if its registration has lapsed, the receipt can be taxable, and the institution's compliance should be checked before the will is signed.
A charitable bequest will is an act of trust in an institution, and it should record that trust in terms an executor can act on. Precision in the naming, an alternative in case of failure, and independence in the drafting are what make the gift survive the probate and the family.