A company acts through people, and the question in every dispute is whether the person who acted was authorised. The Companies Act, 2013, answers it through two documents: the board resolution, which confers the authority, and the minutes, which record that it was conferred. A file with the resolution but no minutes is weaker than it looks, and a file with neither leaves the company arguing about a transaction it has already performed.
What the Act requires to be decided by the board
Section 179 lists the powers exercised by the board on behalf of the company, and Rule 8 of the rules made under it lists the matters that must be decided at a board meeting rather than by circulation. These include making calls on shareholders for unpaid money on shares, issuing securities, borrowing money, investing the company's funds, granting loans or guarantees, approving financial statements, and authorising the company to buy or sell a business or undertaking. Others, such as borrowing beyond the limits in Section 180, need a special resolution of the shareholders as well.
The practical point is that a director signing a contract on the company's behalf needs authority from the board, and the board needs a quorum, a notice and a meeting or a valid resolution by circulation, except where the rules require a meeting. A resolution passed at a meeting with no quorum, or without notice to a director entitled to it, can be questioned.
Resolution by circulation
Section 175 allows a resolution to be circulated in draft to all directors entitled to vote, with the necessary papers, and passed if signed by a majority of those entitled to vote. Such a resolution is as valid as one passed at a meeting. The proviso excludes certain matters from this route, and a resolution that deals with one of those excluded matters is invalid however many directors sign it.
In practice, most small companies operate by circulation because their directors are in different cities. The file then needs a set of signed resolutions, with the date, the subject, and the signature of each director, and the minutes of the next board meeting should record that the circulated resolutions were noted. Without that recording, a certified copy is a loose sheet.
Minutes: the statutory record
Section 118 requires every company to keep minutes of board meetings and their resolutions, entered in a book within thirty days of the meeting. The minutes are not to be pasted or loose; the Act requires a bound book with pages, and the practice is to number each page. The minutes must record the names of directors present, the decisions, and, where a director asked for her dissent to be recorded, that dissent.
Minutes are the record of a meeting, not a transcript. They should state the resolution and the reason for it briefly. A minute that records "the board approved the loan" without the amount, the borrower and the terms is useless in litigation, because it does not identify the transaction.
Courts treat the minutes as strong evidence of what happened at the meeting, and the Act gives them a special status. A plaintiff who produces a certified copy of the minutes of the meeting that authorised a transaction is a long way towards proving the company's authority.
Who may sign and certify
A resolution copy used in a bank, a registry, a court or a counterparty is usually a certified true copy. The Act permits the company to authenticate documents by a director, the manager, the company secretary or another authorised person. The practice is a copy of the resolution bearing the words "certified true copy" and signed by a director or the company secretary, with the company seal where the articles require it.
The stamping of documents, the execution of deeds and the issue of share certificates follow the articles and the Act. A deed executed without the company's seal or the required authority is not automatically void, because the company can ratify, but a counterparty that has relied on an unauthorised signature will want the company to ratify in writing.
The indoor management rule
A person dealing with a company in good faith can assume that the internal requirements of the company have been complied with. This is the rule in Turquand's case, and it still explains why a bank can accept a resolution without inquiring whether the meeting was properly called, and why a buyer can complete a purchase on a board resolution without seeing the minutes.
The rule does not protect a person who knew, or had reason to know, of the irregularity. A director who signs an agreement knowing that the board never approved it cannot rely on the rule against the company. A counterparty who was told that the resolution was awaited cannot rely on it either.
Where the resolution is missing or wrong
A transaction that needed a board resolution and had none is not always void. The board can ratify it later, and a company that has taken the benefit cannot usually repudiate it. But ratification is a fresh resolution, and the file must show it.
The harder case is a resolution obtained by fraud, such as one signed by a director who had already resigned or by someone who was never a director. The MCA master data will show the date of appointment and cessation, and a certified copy of the resolution compared with the master data is the first check any careful counterparty makes. It takes minutes and prevents years of litigation.
For companies in Kolkata, the registered office filings are on the MCA portal, and the forms recording the appointment and cessation of directors are public. A creditor or a buyer should read them before relying on a signature. Our corporate compliance practice maintains the resolutions and minutes, and shareholder agreements set out which decisions need a board approval and which need the shareholders'.
Common questions
Is a board resolution needed for every contract?
No. A director or officer with authority under the articles or a board delegation can sign ordinary contracts. The resolution is needed where the Act or the articles require it, and where the contract is a specified matter such as borrowing, investing, or disposing of an undertaking.
Can a resolution be passed without a meeting?
Yes, by circulation, if it is signed by a majority of the directors entitled to vote and the subject is not one that the Act requires to be decided at a meeting.
How do I prove minutes in court?
Through a certified copy, and if the other side disputes it, by producing the minutes book. The person who signed the minutes, usually the chairman or the company secretary, may be examined, and the attendance register corroborates the record.
What if the minutes were never written up?
The resolution may still exist as a signed document, and the company can pass a confirmatory resolution. But a company that habitually fails to write minutes has a weak record, and its authority will be questioned in every dispute.
Authority is proved by two documents, not by an assertion of authority. Keep the resolution, write the minutes, and certify the copy that leaves the office. If you need a set reviewed, contact the office; our corporate law practice covers the rest.