Statutory bonus is owed by an establishment covered by the Payment of Bonus Act to every employee who has worked for the minimum number of days in the accounting year and whose wages are within the eligibility ceiling. It is not a gift, and an employer cannot substitute a discretionary Diwali payment for it. The payment of bonus act sets both a floor and a ceiling on the rate, and it sets a separate ceiling for the wages used in the calculation, which is where most disputes begin.
Coverage: the establishment and the employee
The Act applies to factories and to establishments employing twenty or more persons, and it continues to apply once covered even if the strength later falls, unless the exemption provisions are invoked. Establishments in the public sector and those exempted by notification have their own schemes, usually at least as favourable.
An employee is eligible if he has worked in the establishment for not less than thirty working days in the accounting year. "Employee" includes a supervisor and a managerial person drawing wages within the ceiling, and excludes persons employed in a managerial or administrative capacity drawing more than the ceiling, apprentices, and persons employed through a contractor on the principal employer's premises are examined on the facts.
The eligibility ceiling is a monthly wage figure fixed by amendment and revised periodically; the last major revision put it in the low twenties of thousands of rupees. Because it moves by notification, the current figure should be verified for the accounting year in question, and an employer who applies an old ceiling is underpaying the very employees the amendment was meant to bring in.
The minimum, the maximum and the calculation ceiling
The minimum bonus is 8.33 per cent of the salary or wage earned in the accounting year, or one hundred rupees, whichever is higher, and it is payable even where the establishment has made no profit and has no allocable surplus. That is the Act's unusual feature: the minimum is a statutory liability independent of the balance sheet.
The maximum bonus is 20 per cent of salary or wage. Between the floor and the ceiling, the actual rate depends on the allocable surplus computed under the Act's formulae, with set-on and set-off carried forward across years.
Then there is the calculation ceiling. Where an employee's salary or wage exceeds the figure the Act prescribes, the bonus is computed on that figure, or on the minimum wage for the scheduled employment if that is higher. That rule is why two employees drawing very different salaries in the same establishment often receive similar bonus amounts, and why the demand for a bonus on the full salary fails as a statutory claim.
Where the establishment has a practice or an agreement giving a higher bonus, that is enforceable as a contractual right, and it is a different claim from the statutory one.
Disqualification and deductions
The Act permits an employee to be disqualified from bonus for the year in which he is dismissed for fraud, for violent behaviour in the establishment, for theft or misappropriation of the employer's property, or for the damage he has caused, to the extent of the damage. The disqualification has to rest on a finding, and an employer who withholds bonus on a suspicion rather than a proved finding is exposed.
Deductions from bonus are limited. The Act allows deduction of sums due to the employer, such as advances, and of sums the employee is liable to pay under a court order. A general set-off for "losses caused" without an enquiry is not a lawful deduction.
Where the employee has been absent without leave, the days of absence still count towards the thirty-day eligibility threshold if the total working days meet it, and the bonus is computed on the wages actually earned. Attendance-linked reductions in the rate, as distinct from the amount, are not permitted below the statutory minimum.
When it must be paid
Bonus must be paid within eight months of the close of the accounting year, and the government has power to extend that period for a class of establishments for reasons recorded. A company that pays in the following December for the year ended March has paid late by the Act's standard, and interest is payable on the delayed amount at the rate the Act prescribes.
The accounting year for a company is the year for which its accounts are laid before the shareholders, and for other establishments it is the year the rules prescribe. A change of accounting year needs care, because it can straddle two bonus years and produce a demand for two payments.
A common commercial practice is to pay part of the bonus before the statutory date, on the occasion of a festival, and the balance within the period. That is lawful, provided the total meets the statutory minimum and the deduction of tax at source is handled correctly.
Where the dispute goes in Kolkata
The first step is a written demand to the employer, computing the amount on the statutory formula and citing the accounting year. Most employers pay when the computation is put in front of them with the wage slips attached, because the arithmetic is not seriously disputable.
Where the demand is ignored, the employee can move the labour authority for conciliation, and the dispute can be referred to the Labour Court. A claim for money due under the Act can also be made under the Industrial Disputes Act's provision for recovery of money due from an employer, which allows the labour court to compute the amount and issue a recoverable order.
There is also a statutory inspector, the Inspector-cum-Controller, whose function is to examine registers and complaints. A complaint to the inspector is cheap and often effective, though the inspector's powers are inspection and prosecution rather than recovery of the individual's money.
For an establishment in Kolkata, the Labour Court and the Deputy Labour Commissioner's office for the area are the practical forums, and a bonus claim before the Labour Court is the usual route where the amount is disputed. An appeal from the award lies to the Calcutta High Court, and a writ petition is confined to jurisdictional errors.
The records that decide the claim
- Wage slips or the salary register for the accounting year, showing the components of wages.
- The appointment letter, to establish the date of joining and the nature of employment.
- Attendance records, for the thirty-day threshold and for the wages actually earned.
- The employer's bonus register, which the Act requires and which the inspector can demand.
- Evidence of the bonus paid in earlier years, since a consistent higher payment supports a contractual claim.
Where the employer refuses to give wage slips, the bank statement showing salary credits and the provident fund statement serve as substitutes, and the labour court can draw an adverse inference from the employer's failure to produce its registers. A statutory register review is what an establishment should do before the demand arrives, not after.
Common questions
Is bonus payable if the company made a loss?
Yes, the minimum bonus of 8.33 per cent or one hundred rupees, whichever is higher, is payable even in a loss year. The Act's scheme of set-on and set-off is designed to smooth the cycles, and the minimum is not displaced by the absence of allocable surplus, subject to the exemptions available to a new establishment in its first years.
Is bonus calculated on gross salary or basic salary?
On the salary or wage as defined in the Act, which includes basic pay and dearness allowance but excludes the items the Act excludes, and subject to the calculation ceiling. Computing on basic pay alone understates the amount; computing on the full gross without applying the ceiling overstates it.
Can an employee who joined mid-year claim bonus?
Yes, if he worked for at least thirty working days in the accounting year. The amount is proportionate to the salary or wage earned in that year. A full-year employee and a part-year employee receive different amounts on the same rate.
What can I do if the employer pays a token amount?
Demand the difference in writing with the computation, and if it is not paid, take the claim to the labour authority and then to the Labour Court. A token payment does not discharge the statutory liability, and accepting it without a written protest can be argued as a settlement, so record the protest at the time of receipt.
Bonus disputes are arithmetic disputes dressed as policy disputes. The employer says the establishment made no profit; the employee asks what the statutory minimum is. Get the wage slips, apply the two ceilings, compute the floor, and put it in writing. Most of these claims end at that letter, and the few that do not end in a forum that can add interest and costs.