A resolution plan is approved by the committee of creditors, not by the tribunal, and the threshold is sixty-six per cent of the voting share. The coc voting ibc framework decides who is on the committee, how a vote is weighted, and what the tribunal can review afterwards — which is very little, because the commercial wisdom of the creditors is treated as beyond review. Understanding the arithmetic and the exclusions explains why a plan with the support of the large lenders passes even where the operational creditors object.
Who is on the committee
The committee is constituted by the resolution professional and consists of the financial creditors. A financial creditor who is a related party of the corporate debtor is excluded from the committee, and cannot vote, though the debt remains in the pool for distribution. Where a class of creditors — homebuyers in a real estate project, for instance — is large, they vote through an authorised representative who casts the vote according to the instructions of the class.
The operational creditors are not on the committee. This is the structural feature that produces most of the complaints: a supplier owed a substantial sum has no vote, and its recovery depends on what the plan provides for it, which may be a fraction of the admitted claim.
- Voting share: the proportion of the financial debt owed to a creditor against the total financial debt owed to all the creditors in the committee.
- Related party exclusion: no seat, no vote, but the debt is counted in the total.
- Authorised representative: for a class of creditors, the representative votes as instructed.
- Chairperson: the resolution professional, who convenes the meetings and records the minutes.
The decisions and their thresholds
The plan requires sixty-six per cent of the voting share, and that figure replaced the earlier seventy-five per cent. Decisions on the ordinary conduct of the process — the appointment of professionals, the approval of the minutes, the extension of time — are taken by a majority of the voting share present. The decision to liquidate the corporate debtor requires the same sixty-six per cent, and a committee that decides to liquidate can direct the professional to apply for a liquidation order.
The committee may approve a plan with modifications, and it may reject a plan and ask for a revised one. A plan that is rejected is not necessarily the end of the process; the professional can invite fresh expressions of interest within the framework, and the tribunal has allowed a fresh round where the process had not run out of time.
What the committee must consider
The statute lists the matters the committee must satisfy itself about before approving a plan: the provision for the costs of the process, the feasibility of the plan and its implementation, the ability of the plan to keep the corporate debtor running, the adequacy of the management, and the source of funds. In practice the committee's commercial judgment on these matters is what the tribunal defers to.
The tribunal's role at the approval stage is to check that the plan complies with the statute — that it provides for the process costs, that the dissenting creditors within a class are treated equally, that it does not contravene any law, and that the resolution applicant is eligible. A plan that fails these tests is rejected, and a plan that passes them is approved even if the tribunal thinks the creditors could have done better.
The vote in practice
- Meeting and notice: the professional convenes the meeting with the agenda and the plan documents circulated in advance.
- E-voting: the vote is recorded electronically, and the result is entered in the minutes with the voting share of each creditor.
- The minutes: the decisions, the dissent and the reasons are recorded, and the minutes are the record the tribunal reads.
- Approval and filing: the plan, with the committee's approval, is filed before the tribunal for approval, with the compliance certificate.
- Approval by the tribunal: the tribunal hears the applicant, the committee, the operational creditors and the dissenting creditors, and then passes the order which binds all the stakeholders.
Why operational creditors lose, and what they can do
An operational creditor whose claim is admitted but who is not on the committee is entitled to be heard at the approval stage, and the tribunal will examine whether the plan treats similarly placed creditors equally. Beyond that, the creditor's remedies are limited to an appeal against the approval order, and the appellate tribunal has interfered where the plan provided nothing at all to operational creditors while the financial creditors took the whole value.
The practical point for a supplier is to participate in the process early — file the claim with proof, object to the admitted amount if it is understated, and appear at the approval hearing. A creditor who does not file a claim is not a stakeholder at that stage.
Where the process runs in Kolkata
The committee meetings are convened by the professional, and the tribunal that supervises is the National Company Law Tribunal, Kolkata bench, which hears the approval application and the connected applications. An order approving a plan is appealable to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal within thirty days, and the appellate tribunal can set aside a plan that violates the statute. The insolvency practice represents creditors before the committee and the tribunal, the corporate law team advises the resolution applicant on eligibility, and the recovery practice advises operational creditors on the civil route where the process gives them nothing.
Can a single large lender block a plan?
Only if its voting share is above thirty-four per cent. A lender with a smaller share cannot block a plan on its own, though a combination of dissenting creditors can.
Is the sixty-six per cent computed on the total debt or on the creditors present?
On the voting share of the committee, which is the proportion of the total financial debt. A creditor who does not attend and does not vote is treated as abstaining, and the threshold is applied to the votes cast in the manner the regulations provide.
Can the committee change the plan after approval?
Only through a fresh process with the tribunal's leave, and the tribunal has allowed minor modifications where they do not prejudice the creditors. A material change requires a fresh vote.
What if the committee approves no plan in time?
The process must be completed within the outer limit, and if no plan is approved the committee may decide to liquidate. The tribunal can also order liquidation where the timeline expires without a plan.
The vote is arithmetic and the minutes are evidence. Creditors who attend, vote and record their dissent keep their appeal; creditors who stay away have very little left.