14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Corporate & Insolvency

Company versus LLP: liability, compliance and tax

Both structures give limited liability, and that is where the similarity ends. In India a company is governed by the Companies Act, needs an audit and a board, and pays tax on its profits with a separate tax on distribution. An LLP is governed by the Limited Liability Partnership Act, has partners rather than shareholders, generally escapes audit, and taxes its partners on what they take out. Which is better depends on who is investing, how the profits are to be taken out, and what the business will look like in three years.

Liability

In a company, the shareholders' liability is limited to the amount unpaid on their shares. In an LLP, the partners' liability is limited to their agreed contribution, and a partner is not personally liable for the wrongful acts of another partner. Both therefore protect personal assets from business debts, which is the main reason either is chosen over a partnership firm.

There are differences at the edges. A company's creditors deal with the company and look to its capital. An LLP's creditors look to the LLP's assets, and the partners' contributions are a matter of the agreement rather than of a share capital account. Where a bank is lending, it will usually want personal guarantees from the promoters of either structure, and the limited liability then exists on paper only for that debt.

Audit and the annual compliance load

A private company must appoint an auditor and have its accounts audited every year, irrespective of turnover. It files AOC-4 and MGT-7, holds board meetings at the prescribed intervals, maintains statutory registers, and complies with the Act's rules on related party transactions and loans to directors.

An LLP must have its accounts audited only where its turnover or contribution crosses the thresholds prescribed in the rules. Below those thresholds, no audit is required, and the annual filings are two forms — Form 11 for the annual return and Form 8 for the statement of accounts and solvency, with different dates.

The difference in running cost is real. An LLP with modest turnover can be maintained for a fraction of what a company costs, and the saving continues every year.

Tax, and the point most people miss

A company pays corporate tax on its profits, and the shareholder pays again when the profit is distributed as a dividend. The dividend distribution tax was abolished and the tax moved to the shareholder's hands, but the double layer remains.

An LLP is taxed as a separate entity, at the rate applicable to firms, with surcharge and cess. The partners' remuneration and interest on capital are deductible, within the limits the Act prescribes, and the remaining profit is taxed in the LLP's hands. What the partners draw as profit share is not taxed again in their hands.

So the comparison is not simply the headline rate. A company at a lower rate with a dividend layer can cost more than an LLP at a higher rate with no second layer, depending on how much of the profit is taken out and how much is retained. Any comparison should be run on the actual numbers for the actual business.

There are also provisions a company can use that an LLP cannot: the concessional tax regimes for manufacturing and for certain domestic companies, and the favourable treatment available to eligible start-ups recognised under the start-up scheme. An LLP cannot access the company-specific concessional regime.

Investment and shareholding

This is where the choice is usually decided. A company has shares. Shares can be issued to an investor, transferred, pledged, and used to bring in employees through an ESOP scheme. A shareholders' agreement with tag-along, drag-along and anti-dilution provisions works on a share capital structure.

An LLP has partners and a contribution. Bringing in an investor means admitting a partner, which changes the governance and the tax character of the entity, and there is no equivalent of a share transfer. Institutional investors and venture funds generally invest in companies, not LLPs, for that reason.

An LLP is therefore well suited to a professional practice, a services business with a stable set of owners, a family holding entity, and a joint venture where the parties want a light structure. A company is the right structure where equity will be raised, where employees will be given stock, or where the business is intended to be sold.

Conversion

An LLP can be converted into a company, and a company into an LLP, under the procedures the respective statutes and rules provide. Both involve filings, a fresh set of constitutional documents, and a tax analysis of the conversion. The conversion of a company into an LLP has specific conditions about the assets and the liabilities, and the tax treatment of the conversion depends on whether the conditions are satisfied.

Conversion is not a formality and should not be planned at the last minute before an investment round. Where an investor is expected, the structure should be right from the beginning.

Choose the structure for the business you expect in three years, not the one you have in the first month. Converting later is possible and expensive.

The decision in practice

Four questions settle it for most promoters:

  1. Will outside equity be raised? If yes, a company.
  2. Will employees be given stock? If yes, a company.
  3. Is the business a professional practice with stable owners and modest turnover? If yes, an LLP.
  4. Will the profits be drawn out annually rather than retained? If yes, the LLP's single layer of tax is usually better.

Name, brand and goodwill belong to whichever entity holds them, and the choice of structure should be made before the trademark and the licences are taken in the entity's name.

Common questions

Can a single person form an LLP?

No. An LLP needs at least two partners. A single promoter who wants limited liability with a light structure uses a one person company instead.

Which is better for a family business?

An LLP is often the better fit, because the profit share can be agreed in the LLP agreement and the compliance burden is lighter. A company is better where the family intends to bring in professional management with stock.

Does an LLP need a board?

No. It has designated partners who are responsible for compliance, and the governance is set by the LLP agreement. That is a source of flexibility and also a risk, because the agreement is the only check on the partners' powers.

The structure should follow the plan, not the other way round. Whichever is chosen, the articles or the LLP agreement is the document that decides how it actually works. Our company formation practice incorporates both companies and LLPs, corporate compliance covers the annual load for each, and shareholder agreements covers the governance documents that make the structure work.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422