14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Corporate & Insolvency

Concurrent insolvency against a company and its guarantor

A creditor owed money by a company that has defaulted, and secured by a guarantee, may pursue both the company and the guarantor at the same time. The concurrent insolvency guarantor position is settled: the corporate insolvency process against the company and the insolvency process against the guarantor are separate proceedings, before the same tribunal, with separate committees and separate estates. What the creditor cannot do is recover more than the debt, because the two processes are routes to one satisfaction and not two.

The statutory basis for running both

The Code provides that where a corporate insolvency process has been initiated against a corporate debtor, an application relating to the insolvency resolution of a corporate guarantor or a personal guarantor of that debtor is filed before the tribunal that has jurisdiction over the corporate debtor. That provision is what allows the two processes to sit in one forum, and it is the reason a bank does not have to file in the guarantor's own district.

The provision is procedural, not a bar. It does not require the creditor to wait for the company's process to end, and it does not stop the creditor from proceeding against the guarantor on the guarantee outside the Code — by a suit, or before the debt recovery tribunal — while the company's process runs.

Why the moratorium does not protect the guarantor

The moratorium freezes proceedings against the corporate debtor. A guarantor is a different person, with a different estate, and the freeze on the company's assets has no application to him. The practical consequences are worth spelling out, because creditors and guarantors both get this wrong.

  • A suit against the guarantor can continue while the company is in resolution, and a decree can be executed against his personal assets.
  • A separate insolvency application against the guarantor can be filed and admitted, and the guarantor's own assets then attract a moratorium in his own process.
  • The guarantor's property that was mortgaged to the creditor can be enforced, subject to the terms of the guarantee and the mortgage.
  • The guarantor cannot claim the benefit of the company's moratorium by arguing that the debt is the same debt.

The rule against double recovery

Two processes, one debt. The creditor must account for what it recovers from each, and a creditor that recovers the full amount from the guarantor cannot also take a distribution from the company's resolution for the same debt. In practice the creditor files its claim in both processes, votes in the company's committee, and adjusts the recovery against the guarantor as the distributions come in.

The tribunals police this through the claims process rather than through a separate rule. The resolution professional admits the claim for the full amount, and the creditor's recovery from the guarantor is set off when the distribution is made. A creditor that tries to keep both is exposed to an application by the professional or by another creditor.

What a resolution plan does to the guarantee

The approval of a resolution plan for the company does not discharge the guarantor. The plan extinguishes the company's liability to the extent provided, and it binds the company and its stakeholders, but the guarantee is a separate contract and the creditor's rights under it survive. That position has been upheld at the highest level, and it is the reason banks insist on personal guarantees from directors even where the company's assets are substantial.

The plan may itself deal with the guarantee — for instance by providing that the creditor will release the guarantor on receipt of its share. Where the plan says so and the creditor votes for it, the release binds the creditor. Where the plan is silent, the guarantee survives.

Group companies, which are not the same thing

Two companies in a group are two corporate debtors. Each has its own process, its own committee and its own moratorium, and the admission of one does not suspend proceedings against the other. The Code does not provide a group insolvency framework, and the tribunals have coordinated parallel processes through common professionals and joint hearings on a case-by-case basis rather than by consolidation.

A creditor with cross-guarantees within a group therefore has several processes to track. The practical discipline is a single schedule of claims, recoveries and voting positions, kept by one person, because the set-off has to be computed across all of them.

The order in which to proceed

  1. File the claim in the company's process within the time the professional allows, with the guarantee deed and the statement of account.
  2. Decide whether to proceed against the guarantor by suit, by the recovery tribunal, or by an insolvency application, and file before the limitation period expires against him.
  3. Track the distributions from the company and adjust the claim against the guarantor as they are received.
  4. Resist any attempt to treat the two estates as one, whether by the guarantor or by another creditor, because the separation is what protects the creditor's second route.
  5. Record the position in the committee, so that the resolution professional and the other creditors know what has been recovered elsewhere.

Where both are heard in Kolkata

Both applications are filed before the National Company Law Tribunal, Kolkata bench, which has jurisdiction over the corporate debtor and, by the statutory provision, over the guarantor's insolvency as well. The orders are appealable to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal. A suit on the guarantee that is not an insolvency application goes to the City Civil Court or, for a bank's claim above the threshold, to the Debts Recovery Tribunal at Kolkata.

The insolvency practice runs the two processes together and keeps the set-off account, the banking and finance practice advises on the guarantee and the security documents, and a claim that is pursued as a money suit is filed under recovery suits. The company law questions about the guarantor's own board and filings are handled under corporate law.

Can I file against the guarantor before the company's process is admitted?

Yes. The guarantee can be enforced independently, and the company's process is not a precondition. Once the company's process is admitted, the guarantor's insolvency application is filed before the same tribunal.

Does the guarantor's moratorium stop me recovering from the company?

No. Each moratorium operates on the estate of the person against whom the process runs. The guarantor's moratorium protects his assets, not the company's.

Can the guarantor argue that the plan reduced the debt?

The plan reduces the company's liability, and the guarantor's liability is co-extensive with the debt as it stands. A guarantor who has paid more than the reduced debt has a claim in the process for what he paid, but he cannot use the plan to escape the guarantee.

What if the company's plan pays the creditor in full?

Then the debt is satisfied pro tanto and the creditor cannot recover the same amount again from the guarantor. The guarantee is a security for the debt, not a second debt.

Two processes, one ledger. Keep the claims, the distributions and the guarantee in a single account, and the concurrent route works; run them separately and the creditor ends up litigating against itself.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422