14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Employment & Labour

ESI benefits and what the employer must do

Once an establishment is covered by the Employees' State Insurance Act, the employer must register it, register every employee, deduct the employee's share from wages, add its own share and deposit both within the prescribed time. The employee gets medical care, cash benefits during sickness and maternity, and a pension for permanent disablement or for dependants. The esi benefits employer obligations are therefore two sides of one scheme, and an employer who treats the contribution as another tax is the one who ends up paying damages.

Coverage is not a matter of choice. The Act applies in notified areas to factories and establishments of the prescribed size, and once it applies, the employer cannot contract out of it or agree with employees to take a cash allowance instead.

Who is covered

The Act applies to factories using power and employing ten or more persons, to factories without power employing twenty or more, and to establishments notified for the purpose, which in practice include shops, hotels, restaurants, transport undertakings and offices above a specified staff strength. West Bengal has notified the Act for establishments across its industrial areas and the city.

Employees whose wages are within the ceiling the government notifies are covered. The ceiling has been raised repeatedly and is now in the low twenties of thousands of rupees a month, with a higher ceiling for persons with disability. Because it moves by notification, the current figure should be checked against the corporation's own circulars rather than taken from an old return.

Two categories cause most disputes. Apprentices engaged under a training scheme are not employees for the Act, but a "trainee" who does the work of an employee and is paid for it usually is. And an employee whose wages rise above the ceiling after coverage does not drop out immediately; the Act and the corporation's practice govern when contribution stops, and it is not the day the increment is paid.

The contributions and the calendar

The employer's share is 3.25 per cent of wages and the employee's is 0.75 per cent, on wages as defined. Wages for this purpose include basic pay, dearness allowance and the allowances that count as remuneration, and exclude the items the Act excludes. Paying contributions on basic pay alone understates the liability and is one of the commonest findings in an inspection.

Contributions are deposited by the fifteenth day of the month following the wage period, and the return is filed with them. A new establishment must register within fifteen days of the Act becoming applicable, and every employee must be registered and given a card. Wages here means the gross wages, not the take-home after other deductions.

The consequence of delay is monetary. The corporation can recover contributions with interest, and it can levy damages for the period of default under the Act, at rates fixed by regulation. Those damages are not a fine on the director; they are a liability of the establishment, and they can exceed the contribution itself where the delay is long.

The six benefits

  • Sickness benefit. Cash at the rate the Act prescribes, which is around seventy per cent of average daily wages, for a certified spell of illness, subject to the contribution condition and the maximum days in a benefit period.
  • Maternity benefit. Full average daily wages for the period the Act allows, which is twenty-six weeks for the categories covered, with an additional period for complications and for a specified number of children.
  • Temporary disablement benefit. Cash at a higher rate for an employment injury, paid for the period of disablement certified by the corporation's doctor.
  • Permanent disablement benefit. A pension for life, at a rate assessed with reference to the loss of earning capacity.
  • Dependants' benefit. A pension to the family where death results from an employment injury, distributed among the dependants in the prescribed shares.
  • Medical benefit. Treatment at the corporation's dispensaries and hospitals, and reimbursement where treatment is taken elsewhere in the circumstances the scheme allows.

Funeral expenses and confinement expenses are also payable as lump sums. The benefits are available only where the contribution condition is met, which is why a single month's default by the employer can cost an employee his sickness benefit, and why the employer's default is treated as a wrong to the employee and not merely to the corporation.

Employment injury and the employer's own liability

Where the injury arises out of and in the course of employment, the corporation pays, and the employer's liability under the workmen's compensation framework is displaced for the covered employee. That is the scheme's bargain: the employer contributes and the corporation carries the risk.

The bargain has an edge. Where the accident is reported late, or the employee was not registered, the corporation may dispute coverage, and the employer is then exposed directly. The registration of every employee, and the prompt reporting of every accident, is therefore the employer's own protection as much as the employee's.

Where a contractor's workmen are engaged in the establishment's premises, the principal employer is liable for the contributions of the contractor's employees in the circumstances the Act provides, and cannot escape by pointing to the contract. That is a frequent finding in inspection reports on construction and housekeeping contracts.

Disputes and the forum

Questions about coverage, contribution, benefit and recovery go to the Employees' Insurance Court, which in West Bengal sits at Kolkata and has jurisdiction over the state. The court decides on evidence and its order binds the corporation.

An appeal from the court's decision lies to the Calcutta High Court, and only on a substantial question of law. That is a narrow door, which is why the factual record before the insurance court has to be built properly the first time.

For an employer facing a recovery notice, the sequence matters. A reply within the period the notice allows, with the wage registers and the challans, resolves a large number of demands, because many are based on a comparison of the returns with the provident fund record rather than on an inspection. Where the demand survives, a dispute before the Insurance Court is the remedy, and the deposit or security the court requires should be planned for.

For an employee denied a benefit, the corporation's local office is the first port of call, and the grievance should be in writing with the card number and the employer's contribution history. Where the employer has not deposited, the corporation can recover from the employer, and the employee's benefit should not depend on that recovery. A service grievance pursued in parallel with the corporation often produces the record that the employee cannot obtain himself.

Records an inspection will ask for

  • The registration certificate and the employer's code number.
  • The register of employees with the insurance numbers and the dates of joining.
  • Wage registers for the period inspected, showing the components of wages.
  • Challans and the monthly returns, with the bank statements showing the debits.
  • Accident register and the reports of employment injuries.
  • Contracts with contractors, with the clause on ESI contribution, and the contractor's own challans.

A compliance review of the statutory registers before an inspection is cheaper than the damages that follow one, because most demands are arithmetic once the records are produced.

Common questions

Is ESI compulsory for a small office with twelve employees?

If the establishment falls within a notified category and employs the prescribed number of persons, yes. Coverage in West Bengal extends to shops and commercial establishments above the notified strength, and the corporation's local office can confirm whether a particular establishment and address are covered.

Can an employee opt out of ESI?

No. The scheme is statutory, and an agreement to pay an allowance instead of contributing is void and does not protect the employer. An employee who is covered remains covered while his wages are within the ceiling, and the deduction is lawful.

What happens if contributions are deposited late?

Interest runs from the due date, and the corporation can levy damages for the default in addition. The damages are recoverable as arrears, and criminal prosecution is available in a case of persistent default. Voluntary deposit with a written explanation reduces the damages in practice, though it does not remove the interest.

Does ESI cover the family of the employee?

Yes for medical benefit and for dependants' benefit on death from an employment injury. The family's eligibility for medical treatment depends on the family as defined in the Act and on the contribution record. Dependants' pension is distributed among the persons the Act treats as dependants, in the prescribed proportions.

ESI is the cheapest insurance a small establishment will ever buy, and the most easily lost through bad bookkeeping. Register every employee on the day he joins, contribute on gross wages, deposit by the fifteenth, and keep the challans in one file. Challenging a demand is possible, but it is far easier to have the records that make the demand unnecessary.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422