14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Family Law

Executing a maintenance order when it is not paid

Maintenance execution arrears are recoverable, but only if the order is executed in the right forum within the right period. A maintenance order is not a standing instruction to the husband's bank; it is an order that has to be enforced, and the enforcement machinery differs depending on whether it was passed by a Magistrate under the criminal procedure, by a Family Court under the Hindu Marriage Act, or by a Magistrate under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act. The commonest reason arrears become unrecoverable is that the wife waits, accepts part payments in cash without receipts, and applies years after the default.

First, identify which order you hold

An order under the maintenance provision of the criminal procedure — Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, which replaced Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure — is enforced by the Magistrate who passed it, on an application showing the arrears. An order under Section 24 or Section 25 of the Hindu Marriage Act, or under Section 18 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, is enforced as a decree of the civil court under Section 28A of the Hindu Marriage Act, through execution proceedings under the Code of Civil Procedure. An order under Section 20 or Section 23 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 is enforced by the Magistrate, and a breach of a protection order is a separate offence.

Each route has its own limitation and its own powers. Applying under the wrong one produces an order of dismissal that costs months, so the first step is to read the order and see which statute it invokes.

The computation application before the Magistrate

  1. Prepare a statement of arrears: the date of the order, the monthly amount, the payments received with dates, and the balance for each month.
  2. File it before the Magistrate who passed the order, or before the Magistrate having jurisdiction where the order is transferred, with a copy of the order and an affidavit of non-payment.
  3. Attach proof of non-payment: bank statements for the relevant account, the absence of credits, and any messages in which the husband admits the default.
  4. Ask for a warrant, for attachment of property, or for the sentence the statute provides. The Magistrate can issue a warrant for the amount due and, on continued default, order imprisonment for each breach.
  5. If the husband has moved, apply for transfer of the order to the Magistrate having jurisdiction over his residence, so that enforcement follows him.

The statute limits the period for which arrears can be recovered on this route: an application for enforcement is ordinarily to be made within twelve months of the amount becoming due, and arrears older than that are at risk unless the delay is explained and condoned. The rule exists to prevent stale claims, and it is applied strictly against a wife who has simply not pursued the order.

Execution as a civil decree

Where the order was passed by the Family Court under the Hindu Marriage Act, execution is by application under Order 21 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The available modes include attachment and sale of movable property, attachment of the husband's salary where he is in employment, attachment of bank accounts, and attachment of immovable property. A salary attachment is limited to the portion the Code permits, and it requires the employer to be served.

Civil execution is slower than the Magistrate's warrant, but it reaches assets that the criminal route does not. In practice, a wife with an order from the Family Court often runs the civil execution for attachment of a flat or a bank balance, and keeps the Magistrate's route for a maintenance order passed under the criminal procedure. The two can proceed together where both orders exist, because they rest on different jurisdictions.

Appeals, stays and the mistake of stopping payment

Filing an appeal does not by itself suspend the order. A husband who appeals against a maintenance order must obtain a stay, and courts frequently require the deposit of arrears as a condition of the stay. A wife who receives a notice of appeal should immediately apply for the dismissal of any stay application or for a direction that the monthly amount continue during the appeal, and should not assume that the appeal means the order is frozen.

The monthly amount is not a bargaining chip. An order continues to run during the appeal unless it is stayed, and every unpaid month is a fresh default with a fresh cause of action.

What goes wrong, and how to prevent it

Cash payments without receipts are the biggest problem. A husband who pays part of the amount in cash and then claims in court that he paid in full puts the wife in the position of proving a negative. Insist on bank transfers, and where cash is unavoidable, issue a signed receipt for the exact amount and keep a copy.

The second problem is delay. Each month of default that passes without an application pushes the earliest arrears towards the twelve-month limit. A quarterly review of the account, with a fresh application whenever two months are missed, keeps the arrears alive and signals to the husband that the order will be enforced.

The third is a change of address. Enforcement follows the person, not the original court, so a wife who does not know where the husband works or lives should ask the court for disclosure, and can seek the assistance of the employer or the bank where the account details are known.

Where the applications are filed in Kolkata

An order passed by the metropolitan magistrate is executed in the same court at Bankshall, or in the court to which it is transferred. A Family Court order is executed by the Family Court, and where the order is a decree of the City Civil Court, by that court. For parties in the districts, the courts at Alipore and Barasat deal with both the order and its execution. A maintenance order from another state can be executed in West Bengal after transfer, and the reciprocating procedure in the criminal procedure allows the order to be sent for execution where the husband resides.

Where the husband is abroad, execution is difficult and slow. Attachment of his assets in India, a lookout circular in extreme cases, and an application for the amount to be deposited before he is permitted to contest are the practical tools, and they require the order and the arrears to be documented precisely.

Common questions

Can I claim arrears for several years at once?

On the criminal route, arrears older than twelve months before the application are at risk, and the court will ask why the application was delayed. On the civil route, execution can be filed within the limitation period for executing a decree, which is twelve years, so a Family Court order can be executed for arrears accumulated over a longer period. The safer practice is to apply promptly rather than to rely on the longer period.

Can the maintenance amount be increased later?

Yes. A change in the husband's income, the wife's needs, or the child's school and medical expenses justifies an application for enhancement in the same court. Enhancement operates prospectively from the date of the application, so it should be filed as soon as the change is known rather than at the end of the year.

Can he be sent to jail for non-payment?

Yes, on the criminal route, where the Magistrate finds wilful default and the statute permits a sentence for each breach. Imprisonment does not wipe out the arrears; the amount remains recoverable. Courts usually give the husband an opportunity to pay before ordering a sentence, and a genuine inability to pay is treated differently from a deliberate refusal.

What if he has transferred his property to a relative?

An attachment of property that has already been transferred requires the transfer to be challenged, and a transfer made to defeat a maintenance order can be examined as a fraudulent preference. The better protection is early attachment, which is another reason not to let the arrears accumulate.

Execution is unglamorous and decisive. Keep the order, the payment record and the bank statements in one file, apply within the period, and ask for attachment rather than for sympathy. Our maintenance practice prepares computation and execution applications before the Magistrates' courts and the Family Court in Kolkata, and the family law team handles enhancement and the connected protection proceedings where the default is accompanied by coercion.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422