India has no franchising statute. A franchise is a contract, governed by the Indian Contract Act, 1872, with a trade mark licence and a supply arrangement attached. There is no statutory obligation on a franchisor to hand over a disclosure document before signing, which means that everything a franchisee needs to know must be asked for, in writing, before the agreement is signed.
What a franchise agreement actually is
The franchisor grants the franchisee the right to use its brand, system and know-how in a defined manner, in return for fees and royalties. The agreement covers the trade mark licence, the operating standards, the supply of goods or the specification of suppliers, the training, the fees, the term, the territory and the exit.
Because there is no single statute, the agreement does all the work. Competition law comes in where the arrangement restricts the market; the trade mark statute comes in where the licence is recorded; the stamp law comes in on the instrument itself; and consumer law, labour law and the food safety or drug licensing regime come in on the business rather than the contract.
A franchise agreement in West Bengal is stamped under the state stamp law as an agreement, with the duty depending on the nature of the instrument and the consideration. An unstamped or under-stamped agreement is not inadmissible for all purposes, but it is not receivable until the duty and penalty are paid, and a party who is relying on it should have it stamped before the dispute rather than during it.
Disclosure: what there is, and what there is not
There is no equivalent of the franchise disclosure rules that apply in some foreign jurisdictions. A careful franchisor prepares a disclosure document voluntarily, because it reduces disputes and because courts read a failure to disclose against the party that had the information.
Where a franchisor makes a representation about the likely turnover, the number of outlets, the exclusivity of a territory or the support it will provide, and the representation is false, the franchisee can seek rescission or damages for misrepresentation. The difficulty is proof. The representation was usually oral, made at a meeting, and the agreement contains an entire agreement clause stating that no representation outside the document was relied upon.
The practical answer is to ask for everything in writing: the projection, the list of existing outlets and their performance, the training programme, the support obligations, the identity of the supplier and its prices, and the basis on which the royalty is computed. An email that sets out the numbers, sent before signing, is worth more than any assurance given at the meeting.
The territory clause
The territory clause says where the franchisee may operate and whether the grant is exclusive. Three questions decide most disputes. Is the territory defined by a radius, a ward, a pin code or a named locality? Is the exclusivity subject to a condition, such as a minimum number of stores or a minimum monthly purchase? And may the franchisor open a company-owned outlet or a second franchisee inside the same territory?
A clause that grants "the territory of Kolkata" is an invitation to argue. A clause that grants a named area defined by roads and pin codes, with a map annexed to the agreement, is enforceable. Where the franchisor reserved the right to open its own outlet, the clause should say so, and the franchisee should price the grant accordingly.
Online sales are the modern version of the same problem. If the franchisor sells over its own website into the territory, the franchisee's exclusivity is hollow unless the agreement addresses it. The clause should state whether the franchisor's online sales count, and whether the franchisee may sell online itself.
Fees, royalty and audits
The franchise fee is paid once and is ordinarily non-refundable. The royalty is a percentage of gross sales, and the definition of gross sales is where disputes live: whether taxes are excluded, whether returns are deducted, whether the value of goods supplied by the franchisor counts. The audit right should be reciprocal enough to be credible; a franchisor who can inspect the franchisee's books but will not disclose the royalty computation to the franchisee is inviting a complaint.
Where the franchisor supplies the goods, the supply price is the real profit centre, and the franchisee should negotiate a cap, a most favoured customer clause, or the right to buy from approved alternative suppliers.
Non-compete after termination
Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act makes an agreement in restraint of trade void. A clause that prohibits the franchisee from carrying on a similar business anywhere in India for two years after termination is therefore difficult to enforce, though a clause that protects confidentiality or prevents the solicitation of the franchisor's staff and customers stands on better ground, and the franchisor may protect its trade mark and its know-how as property.
The practical drafting answer is to provide for de-identification: the removal of the signage, the return of the manuals and the cessation of the domain name, with a liquidated sum for delay. That clause is enforceable, and it addresses the harm the franchisor actually suffers.
Termination and exit
The agreement should state the grounds for termination, the notice period, and the opportunity to cure a default. A termination clause that allows the franchisor to terminate without cause on short notice makes the investment insecure, and a franchisee should ask for a cure period of a defined length and an obligation to state the default in writing.
On exit, the agreement should deal with the stock, the equipment, the outstanding royalties, the refundable deposit and the customers' records. Where the franchisor retains a right to buy the fixtures, the valuation method should be stated, or the exit becomes another dispute.
Disputes go to arbitration if the agreement has a clause, and to the civil courts if it does not. In Kolkata, an application for interim protection under the arbitration law lies before the Calcutta High Court or the City Civil Court, depending on the value, before the arbitrator is appointed. Our franchise agreements practice drafts and reviews these documents, and the arbitration practice handles the disputes that follow.
Common questions
Is a franchise agreement required to be registered?
The agreement itself is not registrable as a deed of property. Where it grants a trade mark licence, the licence should be recorded with the Trade Marks Registry through the IP India portal, and where it grants a lease of premises, that lease is separately registrable.
Can a franchisor terminate for a single breach?
Only if the agreement says so and the breach is material. A clause that allows termination for any breach without notice is read strictly, and a court or arbitrator will look at whether the franchisee had an opportunity to cure.
What if the franchisor sells another franchise in my area?
If the territory was exclusive, that is a breach, and the remedy depends on the clause: damages, a refund of part of the fee, or an injunction. If the clause allowed the franchisor to appoint additional franchisees, there is no breach.
Do I need government approval to franchise a foreign brand in India?
It depends on the sector and the ownership structure. Foreign investment in single brand retail is permitted under the automatic route within limits, while other sectors need approval, and franchise arrangements that are really licensing arrangements are treated differently. The structure should be settled before the agreement is drafted.
The contract is the whole of the relationship, so it should be read line by line before signing. If you are taking or granting a franchise, contact the office; our fees for a document review are published.