A homebuyer who has paid for a flat that has not been delivered is a financial creditor under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, and can file an application to initiate the corporate insolvency resolution process against the builder. That status was not obvious when the Code was enacted; it was settled by amendment, and the route is now well worn. The homebuyer financial creditor ibc application is filed before the NCLT Kolkata bench, and it is decided on documents rather than on the buyer's grievance.
The route is not a consumer complaint and it is not a RERA complaint. It is a collective insolvency proceeding, and the remedies available at the end are different. A buyer who wants his money back may find the application a blunt instrument; a buyer who wants the project completed may find it the only instrument that keeps the company alive.
Why an allottee is a financial creditor
The Code defines a financial creditor as a person to whom a financial debt is owed, and a financial debt includes an amount borrowed against the time value of money. The explanation to the definition provides that a person who has paid a amount towards the purchase of a real estate project, and to whom the promoter owes an amount, is a financial creditor for the purposes of the Code.
The consequence is significant. As a financial creditor, the allottee is a member of the committee of creditors, votes on the resolution plan, and shares in the distribution in the manner the Code provides. The allottee is not a secured creditor unless the agreement creates a security interest, and the ranking in liquidation reflects that.
The classification also means that the allottee cannot pursue the application as an individual in every case. The Code requires a minimum number of allottees of the same project to join, and that requirement is discussed below.
The threshold and the joint filing rule
The application must show a default of at least one crore rupees. That is the threshold for a financial creditor's application, and for a single allottee it is rarely met. The Code therefore allows a class of allottees to file together, and the threshold for the class is the same one crore, with the further requirement about the number of applicants.
The requirement is that the application is filed by at least ten per cent of the allottees of the same real estate project, or one hundred allottees, whichever is less. The provision was introduced to prevent a single disgruntled buyer from precipitating an insolvency, and it is a condition of maintainability. An application that does not plead and prove the number is liable to be rejected at the admission stage.
Computing the class is itself work. The allottees of the same project must be identified from the promoter's records, the registration documents and the agreement list, and the applicants must show that they constitute the required proportion. The NCLT has dealt with disputes about whether two towers are one project, and the answer lies in the RERA registration.
The documents the application needs
- The application in the prescribed form, with the details of the project and the registration.
- The allotment letter, the agreement to sell and the payment schedule.
- The payment receipts, the bank statements and the demand letters issued by the promoter.
- The possession date in the agreement, and the correspondence about the delay.
- The RERA registration certificate and the project's declared completion date.
- The list of allottees who join the application, with their agreements and payments, and the computation of the ten per cent or hundred allottees.
- The demand notice, where the statutory notice is required, and the proof of service.
The application should be precise about the default. The default is the failure to deliver possession by the agreed date, or the failure to refund after a valid termination, and it must be quantified. A vague assertion that the project is delayed is not a default for the purposes of the Code.
The hearing and the admission
- The application is filed before the NCLT bench having jurisdiction, which for a company registered in West Bengal is the Kolkata bench.
- The tribunal examines the application and the evidence of default, and may issue notice to the corporate debtor.
- The corporate debtor is heard, and may raise the defence that the default has been cured, that the application is not maintainable for want of the required number of applicants, or that the dispute is not a default within the Code.
- Where the tribunal is satisfied, it admits the application, initiates the resolution process, declares a moratorium, and appoints a resolution professional.
- Where it is not satisfied, it rejects the application, and the rejection is appealable to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal.
The period between filing and admission is used by the corporate debtor to settle with the applicants. A settlement that results in withdrawal is common, and the Code permits withdrawal with the approval of the committee where the process has already begun.
What the homebuyer gets, and what he does not
Once the process begins, the moratorium stops the pending proceedings against the builder, including some RERA proceedings and some consumer complaints, and the buyers' claims are consolidated before the resolution professional. The claims are filed in the prescribed form, with the documents, and the resolution professional prepares the list of creditors.
The resolution plan must provide for the allottees, and the plan that does not is not compliant. In practice the plans offer possession of the flat within a revised timeline, or a refund with a haircut, and the committee votes on the plan. The allottees' vote is weighted by their claim, and a large class of allottees can carry the plan.
Where the plan fails and the company goes into liquidation, the allottees rank as financial creditors in the waterfall, below the secured creditors and the workmen's dues. The recovery in liquidation is usually a fraction of the claim, which is why the resolution route is the one to prefer.
Our pages on insolvency and bankruptcy and RERA practice cover the alternatives, and recovery suits covers the individual claim.
Choosing between the IBC, RERA and a consumer complaint
The three remedies are not exclusive in principle, but they interact. A RERA complaint can produce an order for refund with interest, and it is faster than an insolvency application. A consumer complaint can produce compensation, but its execution against a company in distress is difficult. The insolvency route is the only one that binds all creditors and keeps the company as a going concern.
The choice depends on the project's state. Where the builder has other projects and cash flows, a collective process may rescue the project. Where the company is a shell with no assets, the RERA order is a better paper to hold, because the insolvency process will produce little. The decision should be taken with the company's financial statements and the RERA filings in front of you.
Common questions
Can one homebuyer file alone?
Only where the class requirement is satisfied or the application is one that the Code permits by a single creditor. For real estate allottees, the Code's special requirement of ten per cent or one hundred allottees applies, so a single buyer usually cannot file alone.
Does the RERA order survive the moratorium?
A moratorium restrains the initiation and continuation of proceedings against the corporate debtor, and the RERA proceedings are affected. An order already passed may be enforced only in the manner the Code permits, and the claim is filed before the resolution professional.
Can a buyer who has already taken possession join?
A buyer who has been given possession and has no outstanding claim is not a creditor. A buyer with possession but a pending claim for delay compensation may have a claim, and the documents decide whether the claim is admitted.
What if the builder has already been admitted to insolvency?
The buyer files his claim before the resolution professional in the prescribed form, with the agreement and the payment proofs, and the claim is considered in the committee. A fresh application is not required, and filing a claim is the step that protects the buyer's position.
An insolvency application against a builder is a collective step, and it needs the cooperation of other buyers. If a project has stalled, bring the agreement, the payment record and the RERA registration to a consultation, or write to the office with the project details.