There is no statutory formula for alimony in India. The court fixes maintenance by looking at the income and assets of both spouses, the standard of living during the marriage, the needs of the claimant, the liabilities of the payer, the age and health of each, and the duration of the marriage. The frequently quoted figure of one-quarter or one-fifth of the husband's income is a judicial yardstick used in some decisions, not a rate fixed by any Act, and it is applied to net income rather than gross salary.
That is why two similar-looking cases produce different numbers. The outcome depends less on the formula than on the evidence of income, and the evidence is usually in documents the payer would prefer not to produce.
The statutory sources of maintenance
Four provisions matter, and they operate in different forums.
- Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 provides interim maintenance and litigation expenses while a matrimonial petition is pending. The application is decided on affidavit, and the Act directs the court to endeavour to dispose of it within sixty days.
- Section 25 of the same Act provides permanent alimony, in a lump sum or by monthly payments, on the decree or afterwards, and the order can be varied later if circumstances change.
- Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, which replaced section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, provides maintenance for a wife, child or parent unable to maintain themselves. It is a summary remedy before a magistrate and is not confined to Hindus.
- Section 20 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 provides monetary relief, including maintenance, in a domestic violence proceeding before a magistrate.
Parallel proceedings are common — an interim application in the divorce, a maintenance case before the magistrate, and a domestic violence application. The courts discourage duplication, and the amount fixed in one proceeding is usually taken into account in the others.
The factors that actually move the number
The reported decisions return to the same set of considerations, and each one is a question of evidence rather than of law.
Income. Salary, business profits, rent, interest, agricultural income, director's remuneration, and any benefit in kind — a car, a flat, school fees paid for children, club subscriptions. Tax returns are the starting point, but a return that shows a modest income while the lifestyle shows otherwise invites an estimate.
Assets and liabilities. Property held in the name of the payer, in the name of relatives, in a company or a trust. Loans and EMIs that genuinely reduce disposable income are usually allowed, but a loan taken from a family member after the dispute begins is scrutinised closely.
The claimant's own position. Qualification, earning capacity, actual income, the age of the children, and whether the claimant gave up a career during the marriage. A wife with a professional qualification and a steady income will receive less than one who has not worked for fifteen years, even where the husband earns the same in each case.
Standard of living. The measure is the household the claimant left, not subsistence. Maintenance is intended to preserve something close to the earlier standard, subject to the payer's capacity.
Duration of the marriage and conduct. A long marriage raises the expectation; a short one lowers it. Conduct matters at the margins — the statutory language refers to the conduct of the parties, but ordinary matrimonial allegations do not displace the duty to maintain.
The affidavit of disclosure
Since the Supreme Court's directions in Rajnesh v Neha, both parties are expected to file an affidavit of assets and liabilities in maintenance proceedings. The format covers income from all sources, movable and immovable property, bank accounts, investments, loans and monthly expenses. Filing a false affidavit is a serious matter, and the courts have taken the position that concealment of income can justify drawing an adverse inference.
For the claimant, the affidavit is only half the work. The other half is the corroborating document: Form 16, the income-tax return with the computation, bank statements for the relevant period, credit card statements, property registration records, and the employer's certificate. For a business, the balance sheet and the profit and loss account, and where those are not disclosed, an application for the production of documents or for a direction to the employer or the bank.
Net income, and why the distinction matters
The yardstick is applied to what the payer actually has available, after statutory deductions. Provident fund contributions, professional tax, income tax deducted at source and a genuine housing loan component reduce the base. Allowances that are merely labels — a "conveyance" allowance paid in cash with no travel — are usually added back.
Where income is concealed, the court estimates. Estimates rest on lifestyle evidence: the school the children attend, the locality of the residence, the vehicle, foreign travel, the credit card spend. That evidence is collected before the application is filed, not after, because the court will not order a roving enquiry.
Interim maintenance and the sixty-day expectation
An application under section 24 is decided on affidavits and documents, without a full trial. The court fixes an amount that is meant to keep the claimant afloat until the petition is decided, and the order is enforceable immediately. A party who refuses to pay an interim order faces execution and, in some cases, contempt.
The sixty-day direction in the statute is an expectation, not a guarantee; crowded lists produce longer waits. A well-drafted application with a clear computation and a complete affidavit is heard sooner than a vague one, because the court can decide it without calling for further material.
Lump sum or monthly payments
A lump sum is attractive because it ends the enforcement problem, and the courts have increasingly favoured it where the payer's income can be capitalised and the marriage is short. There is no statutory multiplier; the courts arrive at a figure by taking the monthly amount over an estimated period, discounted for the uncertainties of life, and by reference to the assets that can be transferred.
A monthly order is more common where the payer has a stable salary and the claimant needs a continuing income. It has the advantage of being variable, and the disadvantage of requiring enforcement every month. Where the payer is likely to leave employment, retire or move abroad, the lump sum is the safer order.
Enforcement and variation
An order under section 25 of the Hindu Marriage Act is enforced by execution, and an order under section 144 of the Sanhita is enforced by the magistrate's power to recover the amount as a fine, including by sentence in a continuing default. The domestic violence order is enforced under that Act's own machinery.
Variation is available both ways. A payer whose income has fallen, or who has retired, can apply for reduction; a claimant whose needs have risen, or who has discovered concealed assets, can apply for enhancement. The application must show the change in circumstances since the original order, not a re-argument of the original case.
The Kolkata forum
Interim and permanent alimony under the Hindu Marriage Act are decided by the family court hearing the matrimonial petition — in Kolkata, the family court for the city, and the district court at Alipore or Barasat for areas outside its jurisdiction. A maintenance application under section 144 of the Sanhita goes to the judicial magistrate having jurisdiction where the claimant resides, which in Kolkata means the metropolitan magistrate's courts. A domestic violence application goes to the magistrate designated under that Act.
The choice of forum affects speed more than quantum. Magistrates decide summary maintenance quickly but are limited in the amount they can award relative to the payer's means; the family court has a wider power and a slower calendar. Our maintenance practice advises on which to use, and the domestic violence practice deals with the residence and protection orders that often accompany a money claim. Where the petition itself is contested, see family law.
Can I get interim maintenance immediately?
Not immediately, but early. The application is filed with the main petition, and the court can pass an ad interim order on the first hearing if the affidavit and documents are complete. Realistically, an interim order within a few weeks of filing is achievable where the papers are in order; a contested application with incomplete disclosure takes longer.
Does my wife's salary reduce the maintenance?
Yes, but not proportionately. Her income is one factor among several, and the court will still compare the standard of living in the matrimonial home with what she can maintain on her own earnings. Where both earn comparable amounts, maintenance may be modest or nominal; where the husband earns several times more, her salary reduces the figure but does not eliminate it.
Can maintenance be increased or reduced later?
Yes. Both section 25 of the Hindu Marriage Act and section 144 of the Sanhita allow variation on proof of a change in circumstances — a rise or fall in income, retirement, remarriage, the children's education, or a serious illness. The application must be supported by evidence of the change, and it operates from the date of the application rather than from the original order.
The practical lesson is that alimony is an evidence question. A claim supported by a complete affidavit of disclosure and corroborating documents produces a defensible figure; a claim built on assertion produces an estimate the claimant will find disappointing, and a payer will find easy to appeal.