Part III of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code extends the insolvency framework to individuals and partnership firms, and its adjudicating authority is the Debt Recovery Tribunal, not the NCLT. For a person in Kolkata, that means the DRT at Kolkata. The part iii individual insolvency ibc route exists, is notified, and is used far less than the corporate process, for reasons that are practical rather than legal.
The framework offers three things: a fresh start for a debtor with very little, an insolvency resolution process in which a repayment plan is negotiated, and a bankruptcy process in which a trustee realises the assets and distributes the proceeds. Each has its own entry conditions, and the entry conditions are where most applications fail.
Who the part applies to
The part applies to individuals, to partnership firms and to persons who are not corporate debtors. A sole proprietor's business debt is the individual's debt, and the part applies to him personally. A partnership firm is treated as a separate debtor for the purpose, with the partners being separate persons who may also be subject to the process.
The debtor must have a connection with India, and the debt must be owed to a creditor. The application is made by the debtor himself, or by a creditor, in the manner the part prescribes. A creditor's application requires the support of the requisite number of creditors or the specified proportion, and the threshold is modest compared with the corporate process.
The part is not available to a corporate entity, and a company that is in distress must use the corporate process before the NCLT. A director who has given a personal guarantee is an individual for the purpose of Part III, and the guarantee can be pursued against him in this forum.
The fresh start process
The fresh start is for a debtor whose assets and income are below the limits the Code prescribes, and whose debts are within the prescribed ceiling. It is a summary relief: the debtor is discharged from the qualifying debts after a period, and the creditors are restrained from pursuing them during the process.
The conditions are strict, and they exclude a debtor who owns a dwelling house above the prescribed value, who has been through a fresh start in the preceding years, or who has been convicted of an offence under the Code. The application is made to the DRT, and a resolution professional is appointed to examine the eligibility and the assets.
The fresh start is designed for the very poor debtor, and it is not a general debt forgiveness. A person with a salary, a car and a flat will not qualify, and the application will be rejected at the eligibility stage.
The insolvency resolution process
The resolution process under Part III is closer to the corporate process in design. A resolution professional is appointed, the creditors are identified, a repayment plan is prepared and voted on, and the plan is approved by the tribunal. The plan can restructure the debt, extend the period, or provide for a lump sum payment.
The process is initiated by the debtor or by a creditor, and the application must show the default. The DRT examines the application and admits it, and the moratorium protects the debtor from recovery proceedings during the process. A creditor who has a decree can still file the application, and the decree is the proof of the debt.
The plan must be approved by the requisite majority of the creditors, and the tribunal sanctions it. A sanctioned plan binds all the creditors, including those who voted against it, and the debtor who fails to comply with the plan can be subjected to the bankruptcy process.
Why the route is rarely used
The practical obstacles are three. The institutional capacity of the DRTs is stretched by the recovery cases they already hear, and an individual insolvency application competes with them. The number of resolution professionals registered for the individual process is small, and the fee for a small estate is hard to justify. And the process offers the debtor little that a settlement does not, while exposing him to the loss of his assets and to the stigma of insolvency.
The Code also leaves several parts of the framework to be operationalised by rules, and the gaps make practitioners cautious. A creditor with a decree often prefers the recovery route in the DRT, which is faster and does not require the debtor's cooperation, to the insolvency route, which may produce a plan that pays a fraction of the debt.
None of this makes the part unusable. For a debtor with multiple creditors, no realistic prospect of repayment, and a genuine interest in an orderly settlement, the resolution process offers a binding outcome that a private settlement cannot. For a creditor facing a debtor who has transferred assets, the threat of the process, and the investigation that a resolution professional conducts, is a lever.
Filing before the DRT at Kolkata
- Identify the debtor, the creditors and the default, and compute the amounts with the interest.
- Prepare the application in the prescribed form, with the statement of the debts and the assets.
- Attach the proof of the debt — the loan agreement, the decree, the bank statement, the guarantee.
- File before the DRT having jurisdiction, which for a debtor in Kolkata is the DRT at Kolkata.
- Attend the admission hearing, and cooperate with the resolution professional appointed.
The application should be supported by a statement of affairs, and the statement is examined. A debtor who conceals an asset in the statement commits an offence under the Code and loses the protection of the process.
Common questions
Can a salaried person use the resolution process?
Yes, the resolution process is not limited by income, unlike the fresh start. The plan can provide for repayment out of the salary over a period, and the tribunal sanctions it if the creditors approve.
Does the process protect the family home?
The dwelling house is part of the estate in the resolution and bankruptcy processes, subject to the exemptions the rules provide for the debtor's personal effects and the tools of his trade. The fresh start has a value limit for the dwelling house, and a house above it disqualifies the debtor from that route.
What happens to a personal guarantee?
The guarantee is a debt of the individual guarantor, and it can be pursued in the Part III process. A bank that holds a guarantee from a promoter can file an application against him personally, separately from the corporate process against the company.
Is the DRT the same forum as for bank recovery?
It is the same tribunal, exercising a different jurisdiction. A recovery application by a bank and an individual insolvency application are separate proceedings, though they may be heard by the same presiding officer.
The Part III route is technical and rarely travelled, and the application is worth making only with a clear view of the outcome. If a personal guarantee or a proprietorship debt is being enforced, bring the loan documents and the statement of affairs to a consultation, or read insolvency and bankruptcy and recovery suits. The office can advise on the forum.