14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Corporate & Insolvency

IBC or SARFAESI: which a secured creditor should use

A secured creditor with a defaulting borrower has two routes: enforce the security under the SARFAESI Act, or take the company into insolvency under the code. Sarfaesi vs ibc is not a question of which is stronger. It is a question of what the creditor is trying to recover: an asset, or a business.

SARFAESI is faster and stays in the creditor's hands. The code is slower and takes the company away from the creditor, but it can preserve a business that is worth more than its assets, and it brings every other creditor into one process.

What SARFAESI does

The secured creditor classifies the account as a non-performing asset, issues a demand notice calling on the borrower to discharge the liability within sixty days, and then takes one of the measures the Act allows: possession of the secured asset, the transfer of the asset, the management of the business, or the appointment of a receiver.

The sale of the asset follows a procedure with a reserve price, a valuation, a public notice and a timeline, and the proceeds are distributed in the order the Act prescribes. The borrower can appeal against the measures to the Debts Recovery Tribunal within the period the Act allows, and the appeal carries a deposit.

The advantage is control. The creditor decides when to sell, at what reserve price, and to whom, subject to the procedure. There is no committee, no resolution professional and no vote of other creditors. For a creditor whose security covers the debt and whose borrower has no business left, that is the shortest route to money.

What the code does

An insolvency application brings a moratorium, which stops the SARFAESI enforcement in its tracks, and hands the company to a resolution professional. The creditors form a committee, and the committee decides the fate of the company by a vote of sixty-six per cent.

The secured creditor's security does not disappear. In a resolution, the plan must provide for the secured creditor's claim in the manner the committee approves, and in a liquidation the secured creditor can either realise the security and receive the proceeds, or surrender it and claim in the waterfall.

The advantage is collective. The moratorium stops the race between creditors, the process can preserve the business as a going concern, and a resolution plan can produce a recovery that a sale of the plant and the land would never produce.

The comparison that decides it

  • Asset value against enterprise value. Where the business is worth more running than broken up, the code can capture that value and SARFAESI cannot.
  • The security cover. Where the security is ample and the asset is realisable, SARFAESI recovers the debt without sharing the proceeds with the other creditors in a resolution.
  • The other creditors. Where there are large operational creditors, workmen's dues or statutory claims, the code forces them into one process; SARFAESI leaves them to pursue the company, which may be in no position to pay.
  • Speed and cost. SARFAESI is measured in months; the code in years, with the professional's fees and the litigation.
  • The promoter. A promoter who is uncooperative, or who has diverted assets, is better dealt with in a process that suspends his powers.

In practice, a bank with a mortgage over a commercial building and a borrower who has stopped trading will use SARFAESI. A consortium with a running factory, a large workforce and a product still in demand will use the code, because a sale of assets would destroy the value they are owed.

How the two interact

Once the insolvency application is admitted, the moratorium prohibits the enforcement of any security interest, and a SARFAESI sale that is in progress must stop. A sale that was completed before the admission is protected, and the creditor keeps the proceeds, subject to the avoidance provisions if the sale was at an undervalue.

A creditor cannot have both at once. The admission of the application displaces the SARFAESI route for the duration of the process, and the creditor's remedy is then within the process, through the committee and the plan.

There is a timing game that the courts have had to police. A borrower who files an insolvency application to stop a SARFAESI auction is met with the argument that the application is not for resolution but for delay, and the tribunal can reject it. A creditor who completes a sale before the admission protects the transaction.

The forums in Kolkata

An appeal against a SARFAESI measure goes to the Debts Recovery Tribunal, and the Kolkata tribunal hears the matters from this region. The tribunal's order can be challenged before the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal, and a writ petition lies only where the tribunal's process is bypassed or the action is without jurisdiction.

An insolvency application goes to the NCLT Kolkata bench, with an appeal to the appellate tribunal. A recovery suit, where the creditor chooses litigation instead of either route, is filed before the City Civil Court or the Calcutta High Court depending on the value, and a recovery suit is the slowest of the three.

A banking and finance file should hold the security documents, the valuation, the classification record and the demand notice, because all three routes depend on the same papers. A creditor's insolvency strategy is decided on the security cover and the enterprise value, not on the preference of the officer handling the file.

Common questions

Can a bank start SARFAESI after the company is in insolvency?

No. The moratorium bars the enforcement of a security interest during the process, and a sale attempted after admission is void. The creditor's remedy is within the process, through the committee and the resolution plan.

Does a secured creditor lose its priority in the code?

The security is recognised. In a resolution the plan provides for the secured creditor's claim, and in a liquidation the creditor can realise the security or surrender it and claim in the waterfall. The priority is not the same as the SARFAESI order of distribution, and the difference should be modelled before choosing.

Which route recovers more?

It depends on the asset and the business. Where the security covers the debt and the asset is liquid, SARFAESI usually recovers more for that creditor. Where the business has value as a going concern, a resolution can produce a recovery that a sale of assets would not, even after the costs and the sharing with other creditors.

Can the borrower stall a SARFAESI sale by filing an insolvency application?

The application must be for resolution, not for delay, and the tribunal examines whether the company meets the tests. An application filed to frustrate an auction, without a genuine proposal, is rejected, and the sale can proceed.

The choice is between recovering an asset and restructuring a company. A creditor that knows which one it is owed will choose correctly; a creditor that treats the two as rival remedies usually spends a year in the wrong forum and recovers less in either.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422