Lay-off and closure are two different events with two different sets of obligations, and employers routinely use one word for the other. A lay-off is a temporary stoppage — the workman's name stays on the roll, and he is entitled to half his wages for the period. A closure is permanent — the undertaking shuts, and the workman is entitled to fifteen days' average pay for every completed year of continuous service, in addition to notice. Layoff closure compensation is therefore computed on a different basis, and the label the employer uses does not decide which applies. The facts do.
The distinction has a practical edge. If a factory stops production for three months and calls it a closure, but keeps the plant, the licence and the workers' names on the register, the labour court will treat it as a lay-off, and the compensation demanded will be the lay-off rate plus the wages withheld. Getting the character of the event right at the beginning saves a year of litigation.
What a lay-off is, and who is entitled
The Act defines a lay-off as the failure, refusal or inability of an employer to give employment to a workman whose name is on the muster roll, on account of shortage of coal, power, raw material, the accumulation of stock, the breakdown of machinery, or any other reason. The definition is broad, and a dispute about whether the reason qualifies is decided by the labour court.
The lay-off provisions apply to industrial establishments above the prescribed size, and the entitlement is to compensation equal to half the total of basic wages and dearness allowance for the days of lay-off. A workman who is not on the muster roll, or who is a casual or a badli workman, is outside the entitlement. A workman who has been laid off for more than the prescribed number of days in a year may be retrenched on the terms the Act provides, which is how a prolonged lay-off becomes a retrenchment.
The obligation is to pay the compensation within the time the rules prescribe, and a failure to pay is a recoverable claim. Employers sometimes pay nothing and hope the workmen will not press; the claim does not expire, and it is enforceable with interest.
Closure: notice, permission and compensation
An employer may close an undertaking, but the Act prescribes a procedure that depends on the size of the establishment. Above the threshold — one hundred workmen — the employer must give at least sixty days' notice to the appropriate government, and must apply for prior permission ninety days before the intended closure. The permission is granted or refused by the government, and the refusal can be challenged before the industrial tribunal.
Below the threshold, the employer must still give notice to the government, and must pay the compensation. The notice requirement is not a formality: a closure without notice to the state is a closure in contravention of the Act, and the workmen can ask the labour court to treat the closure as illegal and to award compensation accordingly.
The compensation on closure is fifteen days' average pay for every completed year of continuous service, or part of a year in excess of six months, in addition to one month's notice or wages in lieu. Gratuity, earned leave and provident fund are separate, and they must be paid in addition. Our page on labour and employment law explains how the separate dues are computed.
The steps an employer must actually take
- Decide and record the character of the event — lay-off or closure — because the notice, the permission and the compensation follow from it.
- For a closure above the threshold, apply for permission ninety days in advance, with the reasons, the number of workmen, the compensation proposed and the date of closure.
- Give notice to the appropriate government, and display the notice at the establishment.
- Serve individual notice of one month, or pay wages in lieu, on every workman, and compute the closure compensation per workman with the service record.
- Pay the statutory dues before the closure takes effect, and settle gratuity, leave encashment and provident fund separately.
- For a lay-off, maintain the muster roll, record the days of lay-off, and pay the half-wage compensation within the prescribed time.
Where the establishment is a company and is wound up, the closure provisions interact with the insolvency process. A closure during a liquidation is treated differently, and the workmen's dues have a priority in the distribution. Our page on insolvency and bankruptcy sets out that order.
Where the employer calls it a "suspension of operations"
The relabelling is the commonest evasion. The plant stops, the power connection is intact, the licences are renewed, the watchman is on the payroll, and the workers are told not to come. Then a notice appears on the gate saying the unit has been "temporarily suspended". On those facts the event is a lay-off, and the compensation is half the wages, not fifteen days a year.
The evidence that decides it is mundane: the electricity bills, the renewal of the trade licence, the provident fund returns for the period, the attendance register, the security guard's payroll, and the correspondence with customers. A workman who collects these documents — or asks the labour inspector to collect them — prevents the relabelling from working.
The other evasion is a closure in stages. One department shuts, the workmen are retrenched, and the rest of the undertaking carries on. That is a retrenchment, not a closure, and the retrenchment conditions — notice, compensation, last-come-first-go, and permission where the establishment is above the threshold — apply to each stage.
Remedies, forum and time limits
The workman's remedy is an industrial dispute, raised through the labour officer and referred to the labour court or tribunal, or a claim for the statutory amount before the authority under the Act. For closure compensation and lay-off compensation, the claim is a money claim that can be pursued before the labour court, and delay does not extinguish it, though the tribunal may limit the period for which it awards relief.
Where the closure was without the permission required, the workman can ask the tribunal to declare the closure illegal, which strengthens the claim for compensation and, in some cases, for reinstatement. Where the employer has closed and disappeared, the practical remedy is against the assets and against the persons who controlled the company, and the recovery route is a separate exercise.
For a workman in Kolkata's manufacturing belt — the small engineering units, the jute and textile establishments, the food processing units — the labour officer for the area is the first stop, and the conciliation record is what starts the reference. A complaint made while the plant is still standing is worth far more than one made after the machinery has been sold.
Common questions
Is a lay-off the same as a retrenchment?
No. A lay-off is temporary and the workman remains on the roll, entitled to half wages. A retrenchment ends the employment, and the workman is entitled to notice, fifteen days' average pay per completed year, and the other dues. A lay-off that continues beyond the prescribed period can be converted into a retrenchment, but only by following the retrenchment conditions.
Can an employer close without paying compensation?
No. Closure compensation is a statutory liability, and it ranks with the workmen's dues in a winding up. An employer who closes without paying exposes the company and its officers to recovery proceedings and to prosecution under the Act.
Does a closure require the union's consent?
Not consent, but the union must be informed and the notice must be displayed. Where a settlement is reached with the union on enhanced compensation, that settlement binds the workmen who are parties to it, and it can improve on the statutory minimum.
What happens to gratuity when a unit closes?
Gratuity is payable on cessation of employment for every employee with five years of continuous service, and closure is a cessation. It is computed at fifteen days' wages for each completed year, subject to the statutory ceiling, and it is paid in addition to the closure compensation.
A closure notice on the gate is the moment to preserve evidence, not to wait for the final settlement. Photograph the notice, collect the salary slips and the appointment letters, and take the service record to a consultation. The labour practice page lists the documents, and the office can advise on the reference.