When a resolution plan is not approved and the tribunal orders liquidation, the company's assets are sold and the proceeds are distributed in a fixed order. That order, the liquidation waterfall ibc prescribes, puts the insolvency costs first, then the workmen's dues and the secured creditors in equal rank, then the other employees, then the unsecured financial creditors, then the government, then the residual claims, and only at the end the shareholders. A creditor who knows the position in that order knows what to expect, and can decide whether to be in the process at all.
The order is not the same as the order in a winding up under the companies law, and it is not the same as the order in a bank's recovery proceedings. The Code's waterfall applies in a liquidation under the Code, and the secured creditor's position within it has its own rules.
The estate and what is excluded
The liquidator takes charge of the assets of the corporate debtor, and the assets form the liquidation estate. The estate includes the cash and the bank balances, the movable and immovable property, the books, the receivables and the assets that the corporate debtor holds as a trustee or in a fiduciary capacity for the benefit of others.
The Code excludes certain assets: the assets owned by a third party in the possession of the corporate debtor, the assets held under a trust, the assets subject to a security interest held by a secured creditor who has chosen to enforce it outside the process, and the deposits held in the accounts of the process. The exclusion matters because a creditor whose security falls within an exclusion is not sharing in the waterfall at all.
The liquidator may also avoid transactions and bring the value back into the estate, and the proceeds of those avoidance applications are part of the estate, distributed in the same order.
The waterfall, in order
- The insolvency resolution process costs and the liquidation costs, in full, before anything else.
- The workmen's dues for the twenty-four months preceding the liquidation commencement date, and the debts of the secured creditors, ranking equally, with the secured creditor's share limited to the value of the security where he has realised it.
- The wages and the unpaid dues of the other employees for the twelve months preceding the liquidation commencement date.
- The financial debts of the unsecured creditors.
- The unpaid government dues, and the dues of the secured creditors remaining after the enforcement of the security interest, ranking equally between them.
- The remaining debts and dues.
- The preference and equity shareholders, in the order of their priority and equally within each class.
- The surplus, if any, to the persons entitled to it as partners or owners.
The equal ranking at the second stage is the provision that surprises creditors. A workman and a secured bank share the same tier, and the bank's claim in that tier is limited to the value of its security, with the balance shifting to the fifth tier. The arrangement is peculiar to the Code, and it is a compromise between the rights of labour and the rights of the secured lender.
The secured creditor's option
A secured creditor has a choice. He may relinquish his security interest and take his place in the waterfall, or he may enforce his security outside the process, in which case he realises the security and receives the proceeds to the extent of his claim, and the balance of the claim is treated as unsecured.
The choice is made at the beginning, and it is not revocable in every circumstance. A bank that enforces its security outside the process does not share in the distribution of the other assets for the balance of its claim in the same manner, and the calculation must be done before the choice is made. In practice, the decision depends on the value of the security and the size of the estate.
Where the secured creditor realises the security, the liquidator must be informed, and the proceeds are accounted for. A realisation without notice to the liquidator is a breach of the process.
Related party claims
The claims of related parties of the corporate debtor are subordinated. The Code requires the liquidator to treat the claims of related parties below the claims of the other creditors, and the subordination applies to the distribution. A promoter who has lent money to the company does not stand in the same queue as an independent lender.
The definition of a related party is wide, and it covers the directors, the promoters, the holding and subsidiary companies and the persons who control the corporate debtor. A claim filed by a related party is admitted, but its ranking is subordinate, and the distribution reflects that.
What a creditor should do in a liquidation
- File the claim in the prescribed form with the liquidator, with the proof, within the period notified.
- State the security, if any, and the value, and make the election on enforcing it or relinquishing it.
- Ask for the list of claims and the valuation of the estate, and check the ranking of your claim.
- Attend the meetings of the stakeholders, and ask for the progress of the sale of the assets.
- Apply to the tribunal where the liquidator rejects the claim or misclassifies it.
The liquidation process is conducted by the liquidator, and the tribunal supervises it. A creditor's remedy against a rejection is an application to the NCLT bench dealing with the company, which for a West Bengal company is the Kolkata bench, and an appeal lies to the appellate tribunal.
A creditor who has a decree should say so in the claim, and should attach the certified copy. A decree obtained after the liquidation commencement date is a claim that arose before it, and the liquidator must be informed of it. Where the decree was obtained against the corporate debtor during the moratorium, the creditor has a separate grievance, because the moratorium restrains the institution and continuation of suits, and a decree obtained in breach of it is vulnerable.
Common questions
Are workmen paid before banks?
They rank equally with the secured creditors in the second tier, not before them. The workmen's dues for the twenty-four months preceding the commencement date are in that tier, and the secured creditor's claim is in the same tier to the extent of the value of the security.
Do government dues come before unsecured creditors?
No. The government's dues are in the fifth tier, below the unsecured financial creditors. That is a change from the position under the older law, and it has been the subject of litigation and of a proposed amendment.
Can shareholders recover anything?
Only after every other claim in the waterfall has been paid, which in practice means almost never. The preference and equity shareholders are in the seventh tier, and the surplus in the eighth is rare.
How long does a liquidation take?
Longer than a resolution, and the period depends on the assets and the litigation. The sale of immovable property, the resolution of title disputes and the avoidance applications each add time, and the process can run for years.
A creditor facing a liquidation should file the claim at once and take the decision on the security with the valuation in hand. Bring the security documents, the claim proof and the liquidator's notices to a consultation, or read insolvency and bankruptcy and banking and finance. The office can advise on the election.