14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Family Law

Maintenance under section 144 BNSS: the evidence that counts

Maintenance under section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 — the provision that replaced section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure — is available to a wife, a child, and a parent who is unable to maintain himself, and the application is decided on a summary inquiry before a Magistrate. It is not a civil suit. There is no plaint, no written statement in the ordinary sense, and no long trial, which is precisely why it is the fastest route to a monthly order in favour of a neglected dependant.

Because the procedure is summary, the outcome depends almost entirely on the quality of the affidavits filed at the start. A maintenance section 144 bnss application supported by bank statements, salary slips, rent receipts, school fee bills and a disclosure affidavit on the Rajnesh v Neha Sharma format is decided differently from one that pleads only that the husband earns well.

Who can apply, and against whom

Section 144 covers three classes of claimant: a wife who is unable to maintain herself; a legitimate or illegitimate minor child, and a major child who is unable to maintain himself because of physical or mental abnormality or injury; and a father or mother who is unable to maintain himself or herself. The obligation runs against a person having sufficient means who neglects or refuses to maintain the claimant.

The section applies to all religions, which is its principal advantage over the personal-law routes. A wife may instead claim interim and permanent maintenance under section 24 and section 25 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, or under section 20 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, or monetary relief under section 20 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005. She is entitled to choose, and a claim under one statute does not automatically bar another, although the court will avoid double recovery for the same period.

The application and the affidavit

The application is filed before the Judicial Magistrate of the first class for the area where the claimant resides or where the respondent resides, or where the cause of action arose. In Kolkata the metropolitan magistrates sitting at Bankshall hear these applications, and a claimant living in Garia or Behala files in the court covering that area rather than in the district court at Alipore.

The filing should carry:

  • Particulars of the marriage with proof, and the names and dates of birth of any children.
  • Proof of the claimant's residence, which also establishes jurisdiction.
  • An affidavit of disclosure of the claimant's own income, assets, liabilities and expenses.
  • Evidence of the respondent's means: salary slips, Form 16, bank statements, property documents, vehicle registration, credit card statements, income tax returns, or the respondent's own disclosure.
  • Evidence of neglect or refusal: the notice demanding maintenance, the reply, the messages, and the bank record showing no payment.
  • Receipts for rent, school fees, medicines and other recurring necessities.

Where the respondent's income documents are not available, the claimant can apply for production, and the court can draw an adverse inference from a wilful non-disclosure. The Supreme Court's guidelines in Rajnesh v Neha Sharma require both sides to file the disclosure affidavit, and a respondent who files a false one risks both the maintenance order and a prosecution.

Interim maintenance, and the first hearing

The section does not spell out an interim order in detail, but the practice, endorsed by the Supreme Court's guidelines, is that the Magistrate fixes interim maintenance after hearing the parties on affidavits, so that the claimant is not left without support while the inquiry continues. The interim order is not a final finding; it is a holding arrangement pending the evidence.

In fixing the figure the court looks at the claimant's needs, the respondent's income and liabilities, the standard of living during the marriage, the number of dependants, and any separate income of the claimant. There is no statutory formula, and assertions that a fixed fraction of salary is the legal rule are wrong. What the court requires is a reasoned figure supported by the disclosure affidavits.

Enforcement when the order is disobeyed

Where an order is made and not complied with, the Magistrate may issue a warrant for the recovery of the amount as if it were a fine, and may sentence the respondent to imprisonment for a term up to one month for each month's default, or until payment. The section also allows the court to direct payment by way of a monthly allowance and to order that the allowance be paid from the date of the application, which is why delay in filing costs the claimant money that cannot be recovered afterwards.

Enforcement is where the practical value of the provision lies. A monthly order that is never enforced is worse than useless, and a claimant should keep a running statement of arrears, with the dates of default, so that an application for enforcement is a one-page document rather than a reconstruction.

Challenge and appeal

An order under section 144 is amenable to revision before the Sessions Court — the City Sessions Court at Kolkata for orders passed in the city — and thereafter to the Calcutta High Court under its revisional or writ jurisdiction. The revision is not a re-hearing of the evidence; the court interferes where the order is perverse, where jurisdiction was wrongly assumed, or where the figure is unsupported by the material.

A respondent who wants to challenge the figure should therefore challenge the finding on means at the interim stage itself, by producing his own documents, rather than waiting for the final order and arguing that the amount is excessive.

Where these applications go wrong

Claimants lose ground in three ways. The first is pleading the husband's income without a single document, which invites an order at the lowest end of the range. The second is claiming maintenance for children without naming them as applicants or producing their birth certificates, so that the order cannot cover them. The third is claiming from a date earlier than the application, which the court cannot grant.

Respondents lose ground by non-appearance, by filing a bald denial of income while the bank statement shows otherwise, and by remarrying or resigning to defeat the claim, which the court treats as a voluntary reduction of means rather than a defence.

Can a husband refuse maintenance because the wife is earning?

Not on that fact alone. Her income goes into the assessment of need, and where she earns enough to maintain herself the claim may fail; where her income is modest, the court may award a sum that bridges the gap. The test is inability to maintain herself, not absolute destitution.

Does a mutual consent divorce end the wife's right to maintenance?

A consent decree that provides a lump sum in full settlement can bar a later claim for the same period, and the terms govern. A term that leaves the wife without any provision, or that is vitiated by concealment of income, can be challenged, and a child's maintenance is never extinguished by a bargain between parents.

Is there a time limit for filing?

The application itself is not subject to a period of limitation, but maintenance is ordinarily awarded from the date of the application, so a claimant who waits for years loses the arrears that would otherwise have accrued. For a child, the entitlement runs until majority or until the inability ceases.

Can the order be increased later?

Yes. A material change in circumstances — the respondent's higher income, the child's school fees, the claimant's illness — supports an application for enhancement, and the court can revise the figure on the same file. A reduction is possible on the same logic where the respondent's means have genuinely fallen.

The work that decides these cases happens before the first hearing: the disclosure affidavit, the documents behind it, and a figure that can be defended line by line. Our maintenance and alimony practice prepares the application and the evidence pack, and the domestic violence practice deals with the overlapping monetary relief where a protection case is also running. Where the marriage itself is ending, the divorce practice coordinates the two proceedings so that the orders do not contradict each other. Begin at the contact page.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422