14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Family Law

Probate before the Calcutta High Court

A probate petition is filed on the original side of the Calcutta High Court, and it asks the court to certify the will and the executor's authority to administer the estate. The petition carries the will, the death certificate, the affidavit of assets and the court fee; the court then issues a citation to the heirs and the next of kin, and if no caveat is filed within the period, the probate is granted. If a caveat is filed, the proceeding becomes contentious and is tried like a suit.

For a Hindu will made within the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the High Court, probate is generally necessary before a right as legatee can be established, which is why the banks, the sub-registrar and the revenue office ask for it.

The forum, and why the High Court

The Indian Succession Act, 1925 confers probate jurisdiction on the High Courts and the District Judges. In Kolkata, the original side of the Calcutta High Court exercises the jurisdiction for estates within the ordinary original civil jurisdiction, and the district court at Alipore has concurrent jurisdiction in the defined cases.

The original side has its own practice and its own rules. The petition is presented through an advocate on record, the proceedings carry the original side numbers, and the taxations and the drawing-up follow the original side practice. That is a different procedure from the one followed in the district courts, and it is the reason probate work in Kolkata is handled by practitioners who appear on the original side.

The petition

The petition under section 276 of the Act sets out the petitioner's name and address, the name and address of the deceased, the date of death, the will and its date, the petitioner's interest as executor, the assets and their value, and the facts that establish the court's jurisdiction.

The documents annexed are the original will, the death certificate, the schedule of assets and liabilities, the valuation, and the consent of the executor where someone other than the executor applies. Where the will is in a language other than English, a translation is filed.

Where the petitioner is not the executor, the petition is for letters of administration, and the person entitled to the estate under the will or under the intestacy rules applies. The procedure is largely the same, and the grant has the same effect for the purpose of administering the estate.

The citation and the caveat

The court issues a citation to the heirs and the next of kin, calling on them to come forward if they have any objection. The citation is served, and in some cases published, and the period allowed for a caveat runs from the service.

A person who objects files a caveat, and with it an affidavit setting out the grounds: that the will is not genuine, that the testator lacked capacity, that it was obtained by undue influence or fraud, or that the will was not properly executed. Once a caveat is entered, the probate proceeding becomes contentious, and it is tried as a suit, with the propounder proving the will and the caveator attacking it.

Where no caveat is filed, the court considers the petition and the evidence, and grants probate. The grant is issued in the prescribed form, and the executor takes the oath and files the inventory and account as the court directs.

The affidavit of assets and the fee

The court fee on a probate is ad valorem on the value of the estate, computed under the Court Fees Act as applied in West Bengal. The value is the market value of the assets less the debts and encumbrances, and the valuation is supported by the documents: the title deeds, the bank statements, the share certificates and the valuation report for the immovable property.

The fee is a real cost, and it is one of the reasons families postpone probate. The postponement is a false economy where the estate includes immovable property, because the probate will be needed at the point of sale, and the fee will be the same then, with the value possibly higher.

Where the estate is small, the fee is modest, and the district court's concurrent jurisdiction may be cheaper and faster. The choice of forum should be made on the value of the estate and the location of the assets.

What probate does, and does not, do

Probate establishes the will and the executor's authority. It is conclusive as to the will's validity against the world, subject to an appeal, and it is the document on which the executor acts: collecting the assets, paying the debts, and distributing the legacies.

It does not decide questions of title to property that the testator did not own, and it does not bind a person who was not cited and who had no notice. It does not transfer the property to the legatees by itself; the executor's assent and the subsequent mutation and registration complete the title.

It also does not prevent a later challenge on the ground of fraud, or a claim by a person who was not before the court. Those are rare, and they are the exception rather than the rule.

The practical timeline

  1. The will and the death certificate are collected, and the assets are valued.
  2. The petition is drafted and presented on the original side, with the court fee.
  3. The court issues the citation, which is served on the heirs and the next of kin.
  4. The caveat period runs, and if no caveat is filed, the matter is listed for orders.
  5. The court satisfies itself on the evidence and grants probate.
  6. The grant is issued, the executor's oath is filed, and the administration begins.

An uncontested probate can be obtained in a few months, depending on the court's list and the completeness of the petition. A contested probate takes years, and it is tried like any other suit.

Where probate is not required

Outside the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court, the requirement is narrower, and a legatee may be able to establish a right under the will without probate. Where all the heirs accept the will and the assets are movable, the banks may act on an indemnity and the will, though the larger banks usually insist on probate or letters of administration.

A will of a person who is not a Hindu is governed by the same Part of the Act, and probate is available in the same way. The personal law affects the rules of intestate succession, not the probate procedure.

The Kolkata courts

The original side of the Calcutta High Court hears the probate petitions for the city, and the district court at Alipore has concurrent jurisdiction in the defined cases. The sub-registrar and the BL&LRO act on the probate for the mutation and the registration, and the banks act on it for the release of deposits and securities.

Our succession practice drafts and presents the probate petition and handles the citation, and the registration practice deals with the transfer that follows. Where the will is contested, the civil litigation practice conducts the contentious proceeding.

Is probate always necessary?

No. It is necessary for a Hindu will within the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court, and in practice it is required whenever immovable property or a large bank balance is involved. Outside that area, and for small estates, the will may be acted on without probate, subject to the institution's own requirements.

How much is the probate fee?

The fee is ad valorem on the net value of the estate, computed under the Court Fees Act as applied in West Bengal. The figure depends on the valuation of the assets, so it cannot be stated without the schedule. The valuation should be prepared carefully, because the fee is based on it and an under-valuation invites an objection.

Can the executor sell the property before probate?

Not safely, where probate is required. The executor's authority is established by the grant, and a sale before it is a sale that the buyer's title will have to defend. The buyer should see the probate, and the sale should be completed after the grant.

Probate calcutta high court is a procedural step with a substantive effect: it converts a document into an authority that the institutions will accept. The petition, the citation and the fee are the three things that decide how long it takes, and each of them is within the executor's control.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422