A protection order under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 is the main prohibitory relief the Act offers, and it is wider than most respondents expect. It can restrain a man from committing any act of domestic violence, from aiding or abetting it, from entering the woman's place of employment, from communicating with her, from alienating assets, and from operating a bank account or a locker she uses. Breach of the order is a criminal offence, not a contempt.
The order is passed by a Judicial Magistrate of the first class — in Kolkata the metropolitan magistrates at Bankshall — on an application under section 12, and it can be granted ex parte on the day of the first hearing where the magistrate is satisfied that immediate relief is necessary.
What the Act treats as domestic violence
Section 3 defines domestic violence to include physical abuse, sexual abuse, verbal and emotional abuse, and economic abuse. Physical abuse covers assault, criminal intimidation and any act of bodily harm. Verbal and emotional abuse covers insult, ridicule, humiliation, name-calling, and repeated threats to the woman's reputation or to her family. Economic abuse covers deprivation of financial resources, stopping her from using a shared household resource, disposing of her stridhan, and prohibiting her from carrying on her employment.
That definition matters when the protection order is drafted, because each head of abuse can be matched to a specific prohibition. An application that pleads only beatings will get an order about beatings, and nothing about the salary account the husband emptied.
The application and the first hearing
The application under section 12 is filed before the magistrate having jurisdiction where the woman resides or where the violence occurred. It may be filed by the aggrieved woman herself, or by a protection officer or a registered service provider on her behalf. In West Bengal, protection officers are appointed by the state for each district and the women's protection cells attached to the police districts assist them.
Section 9 requires the magistrate to fix the first hearing within three days of the application, and the Act directs that the proceedings be disposed of within sixty days from the first hearing, though in practice an interim order is what the woman gets in that window, and the final order takes longer.
The application should be accompanied by the domestic incident report prepared by the protection officer, medical records, photographs of injuries, the complaint or the general diary entry at the police station, messages and call records, proof of the shared household, and a statement of the woman's income and needs.
What a protection order domestic violence act application can contain
Section 18 lists the prohibitions: committing or aiding any act of domestic violence, attempting to communicate with the aggrieved person, entering the place of employment or the school of the children, contacting her relatives, alienating any assets including stridhan, operating a joint bank account or locker, and causing violence to the dependants. The magistrate may add any other direction necessary for the protection of the woman.
Section 19, the residence order, is often the more valuable relief. It restrains the respondent from dispossessing the woman from the shared household, and where she has no other residence, it restrains him from entering the portion she occupies. The Supreme Court in Satish Chander Ahuja v Sneha Ahuja considered the scope of the shared household, and the position that emerges is that a woman cannot be excluded from a shared household merely because the premises belong to a relative of the husband, though the court will balance the rights of other residents.
Section 20 provides monetary relief — maintenance, medical expenses, loss of earnings, and compensation for the economic abuse. Section 21 allows interim custody of children, and section 22 allows compensation for injuries and mental pain.
Interim and ex parte orders
Section 23 allows the magistrate to pass an interim order during the pendency of the proceedings, and to pass it ex parte where the magistrate is satisfied that it is just and proper. An ex parte protection order is served on the respondent, who can then apply to set it aside, and the hearing on that application is the first real contest.
An ex parte order is not a weak order. It carries the same penal consequence for breach, and a respondent who removes the woman from the house after service of an order restraining him from doing so commits an offence.
Breach, and the consequence
Section 31 makes a breach of a protection order or an interim order an offence punishable with imprisonment which may extend to one year, or with fine which may extend to twenty thousand rupees, or with both. The offence is tried by the same magistrate, and a conviction under section 31 is independent of any other criminal proceeding arising out of the same facts.
This is why the protection order is taken seriously by respondents in a way that a maintenance order sometimes is not: a monetary order is enforced through arrears, whereas a protection order can put a man in custody for a phone call.
Appeal and parallel proceedings
Section 29 allows an appeal against an order under the Act to the Sessions Court within thirty days. In Kolkata, the City Sessions Court hears those appeals. The appeal lies against the order, not against the findings in a parallel criminal case, and the appellate court can stay the operation of the order pending appeal.
The Act is deliberately designed to run alongside other proceedings. Section 26 allows relief under sections 18, 19, 20, 21 and 22 to be claimed in any pending civil, family or criminal proceeding, so a woman defending a divorce petition can ask the family court for the same reliefs. A criminal complaint under section 498A of the Indian Penal Code, or its equivalent in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, can proceed at the same time, and so can a maintenance application under section 144 BNSS.
What goes wrong in practice
The commonest failure is an application that describes the history without particularising recent incidents, which leaves the magistrate unable to identify an act to restrain. The second is a residence order sought without proof that the woman has no alternative residence, which is the condition section 19 attaches to the direction restraining the respondent from entering the shared household.
The third is the absence of a domestic incident report. Where the protection officer has not prepared one, the magistrate can direct that it be called for, and the report is usually the document that turns a narrative into a record.
Respondents, for their part, lose ground by ignoring the notice, by communicating with the woman through relatives after an order restraining contact, and by transferring the flat or closing the joint account that the order names.
Can a man apply for a protection order under this Act?
No. The Act defines an aggrieved person as a woman in a domestic relationship, and the reliefs are available to women. A man facing violence has other remedies, including a criminal complaint and, where the facts support it, a civil action, but not this Act.
Is the protection order the same as a maintenance order?
No. A protection order restrains conduct; monetary relief under section 20 is a separate relief in the same proceeding. An order can grant both, and a woman should claim both in the application rather than assume the protection order carries money with it.
How long does the order last?
The Act does not fix a uniform duration. A final order usually states the period, often for a substantial term, and interim orders run until the final order is passed. An order may be varied or discharged on an application to the magistrate, and it can be extended where the need continues.
Can I get an order if I am living with my in-laws?
Yes, if you are in a domestic relationship in the shared household, which includes a household where you lived with relatives of your husband. The residence order can restrain them from dispossessing you, though the court will weigh the rights of the other residents, especially where they are elderly.
The strength of a domestic violence case is in the documents: medical records, the general diary entry, the messages, and the domestic incident report. Our domestic violence practice prepares the application and works with the protection officer, and where maintenance is the pressing need the maintenance practice runs the parallel claim. Custody of children is handled through the child custody practice, and a first consultation can be booked at our contact page.