A woman in a domestic relationship has a right to reside in the shared household, and that right does not depend on her owning any part of it. Section 17 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 says so expressly, and section 19 gives the magistrate the power to make orders protecting that residence: restraining the respondent from dispossessing her, directing him to remove himself from the household, restraining him from entering the portion she occupies, and in appropriate cases directing alternative accommodation.
The order is a protection during the relationship and during the proceedings. It is not a transfer of ownership, and it does not convert a wife or a daughter-in-law into a co-owner of her in-laws' flat.
What counts as a shared household
Section 2(s) defines a shared household as a household where the aggrieved person lives or has at any stage lived in a domestic relationship, either singly or along with the respondent. The definition is about residence, not about title.
The Supreme Court considered the scope in Satish Chander Ahuja v Sneha Ahuja. The decision accepted that the shared household can include a house owned by the husband's parents, and that a woman's right of residence is not defeated merely because she has no ownership. It also held that the right cannot be asserted against a property in which the respondent has no right at all, and that the definition should not be read so widely as to take in every property connected with the family.
The practical effect is that a wife living in her husband's parents' house can claim residence there, while a claim against a property owned by an unrelated third party, or a property in which the husband himself has no interest, is much weaker.
What a residence order can contain
- Restraint on dispossession from the shared household, in any manner.
- Restraint on the respondent from entering the portion of the household occupied by the aggrieved person, where tempers make cohabitation impossible.
- A direction that the respondent remove himself from the shared household.
- A direction to provide alternative accommodation of a similar standard, where removal or continued residence is not practicable.
- Restraint on alienating, encumbering or disposing of the shared household, so that the right is not defeated while the case is pending.
- A direction to the officer in charge of the police station to assist in implementing the order.
The order is made by the magistrate, and the court has to balance the rights of the parties. Where the property belongs to the husband's aged parents who have no other home, a direction that they remove themselves will rarely be made; the court is more likely to restrain the husband and leave the parents in possession, or to order alternative accommodation.
The interim order, and why it matters more than the final one
Section 23 allows the magistrate to pass interim orders, including a residence order, during the pendency of the application. The interim order can be made ex parte where the magistrate is satisfied that the situation requires it, and it operates until the application is decided.
In practice the interim order is the relief that matters. Proceedings can take a year or more, and a woman who is protected in her home during that period is in a very different position from one who is not. The application should therefore ask for interim relief expressly, with the facts that justify urgency — a lock changed, a threat of dispossession, an assault.
How the application is made
- A domestic incident report is obtained from the protection officer appointed for the district, or the application is filed directly before the magistrate.
- The application under section 12 sets out the domestic relationship, the shared household, the incidents of violence, and the reliefs sought under sections 18 to 22.
- Notice is served on the respondent and on the protection officer, and the magistrate fixes a date.
- The magistrate hears the parties and passes an interim order, usually on the first or second hearing if the application is complete.
- A final order follows after evidence, and it can include protection, residence, monetary relief, custody of children and compensation.
The application does not require court fees, and it can be filed by the aggrieved woman herself or through a protection officer, a service provider or an advocate. Section 12 expressly permits a relative or a social worker to file on her behalf with the leave of the magistrate.
Enforcement
A breach of a protection, residence or monetary order is an offence under section 31, punishable with imprisonment and fine. That is the strongest feature of the Act: the order is not merely a civil direction but a criminal one, and the police can act on it.
Where the respondent disobeys, the remedy is a complaint before the same magistrate under section 31, and a direction to the police to register and investigate. A civil execution application is not necessary.
Where the right ends
The right of residence depends on the domestic relationship. A divorced woman is no longer in that relationship, and the courts have generally held that the right under section 17 does not survive the divorce as a permanent right in the former husband's property. Orders made during the proceedings continue for the period they specify, and the matrimonial court can make arrangements for residence in the maintenance order.
A woman who has never lived in the household, or who left years before the application, faces a different difficulty: the Act protects a residence that exists, and the magistrate will examine when she last lived there and why she left.
Property sold during the proceedings raises the question of whether the purchaser is bound. A residence order does not by itself bind a purchaser who bought before the order, but a sale after the order, in defiance of it, can be dealt with as a breach, and the doctrine of lis pendens may apply where the suit was properly notified.
The Kolkata courts
Applications under the Act are heard by the judicial magistrate having jurisdiction where the aggrieved person resides or where the incident occurred. In Kolkata that means the metropolitan magistrate's courts, and the protection officer is the officer appointed for the district under the Act. An appeal against an order lies to the court of session within thirty days, which in the city is the City Sessions Court.
The same set of facts usually supports several proceedings at once — the domestic violence application, a maintenance claim, and a matrimonial petition. The residence order is the one that has to be obtained quickly, because everything else can proceed while she is still in the house. Our domestic violence practice handles the application and the appeal, and the maintenance practice deals with the money relief that goes with it.
Can my husband's parents throw me out of their flat?
Not lawfully, if it is the shared household and you are in a domestic relationship with them. Section 17 gives you a right of residence that does not depend on ownership, and a forcible eviction can be restrained by a residence order under section 19. The court will, however, weigh their own housing needs, and where they have no other home the order is likely to be directed at the husband rather than at them.
Does a residence order give me a share in the property?
No. It protects possession and prevents dispossession; it does not create an ownership right, and it does not entitle you to sell or mortgage the property. A claim to a share has to be made in a partition or matrimonial property proceeding, on the basis of the applicable law, and the two remedies are different in kind.
What can I do if he sells the flat while the case is pending?
Apply immediately for a restraint on alienation under section 19, and bring the sale to the magistrate's notice. Where the sale took place after the order, it is a breach punishable under section 31; where it took place before, the question is whether the purchaser had notice of the proceedings, and the answer depends on the facts and on whether the notice of pendency was registered.
A residence order is worth seeking on the first day, with the incident report and the address proof. The rest of the case can be argued at leisure; the roof cannot.
If you are dealing with this now, the page on family law sets out the documents we ask for and the fee for each stage.