14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Family Law

Revoking or altering a will: codicils and later wills

A will is revocable at any time before the testator's death. It can be revoked by a later will or codicil, by a written declaration signed and attested in the same way, or by burning, tearing or otherwise destroying the document with the intention of revoking it. The difficulty is evidentiary: when two documents exist and the earlier has not been destroyed, the court has to decide which was the last valid will, and the answer decides the whole estate.

The commonest family dispute in succession is not about forgery. It is about which of two genuine documents the testator intended to govern, and whether a codicil changed one clause or the whole will.

The modes of revocation

The Indian Succession Act, 1925 allows revocation by a subsequent will or codicil, by a writing declaring the intention to revoke, executed in the manner of a will, and by the destruction of the will with the intention of revoking it.

The destruction must be by the testator, or by someone in his presence and by his direction, and it must be done with the intention to revoke. Tearing a will in anger and then keeping the pieces is not a revocation; destroying it and telling the executor that it has been revoked is.

A will can also be revoked in part. A later will that deals with one asset revokes the earlier will only to the extent of the inconsistency, and the earlier will stands for the rest. A codicil does the same thing more explicitly.

The codicil

A codicil is a supplement to a will. It must be executed with the same formalities — signed by the testator and attested by two witnesses — and it alters, adds to or confirms the will.

The advantage of a codicil is that it leaves the rest of the will untouched. A testator who wants to change one legacy, or add a bequest to a charity, can do it with a short document, without re-executing the whole will.

The disadvantage is that a codicil can create confusion. A codicil that is inconsistent with the will, that refers to a clause that has been renumbered, or that is itself later superseded, produces exactly the dispute the testator wanted to avoid. Where more than one clause is to change, a fresh will is often cleaner.

The later will problem

Two wills, both genuine, the later undated or the earlier not destroyed: the court has to decide which is the last. The propounder of the later will must prove its execution and the testator's capacity, and the propounder of the earlier will argue that the later document is not what it appears.

The date matters. A will should be dated, and the date should be on every page. A registered will carries the registrar's record of the date, which is why registration, though optional, is useful.

The custody of the documents matters too. A will that is traced to the testator's possession and cannot be found after his death raises a presumption that he destroyed it with the intention of revoking it. That presumption is rebuttable, but it is a serious obstacle for the person who propounds the earlier document.

Revoking properly

  1. Decide whether the change is one clause or the whole scheme. A codicil for a clause, a fresh will for the scheme.
  2. Draft the document with an express revocation clause: "I revoke all my former wills and codicils".
  3. Execute it with two independent witnesses, in the presence of each other and of the testator.
  4. Obtain the affidavits of the witnesses at the time of execution.
  5. Register the will or the codicil, which is optional but records the date.
  6. Destroy the earlier original, or endorse it as revoked and keep it, so that no one can later claim it is the operative document.
  7. Tell the executor where the current document is, and give a copy to the person who will need it.

Alteration without revocation

An alteration made on the face of the will — an interpolation, a strike-through, a correction — is treated differently. An alteration that is not executed with the same formalities is ineffective, unless it is a mere correction of an obvious error, and the original text may be read through the alteration.

The practical rule is that a will should not be altered by hand. A fresh document, or a codicil, is the safe course, and it costs very little compared with the litigation that an ambiguous alteration produces.

Revival

A revoked will can be revived only by re-execution, or by a codicil that shows an intention to revive it. The mere destruction of the later will does not revive the earlier one, unless the intention to revive is established.

That rule catches families who find a later will, decide it is invalid, destroy it, and then rely on the earlier will. The earlier will was revoked when the later one was executed, and it does not come back by the destruction of the later document.

The deposit of a will

The Registration Act allows a will to be deposited with the registrar in a sealed cover, to be opened after the testator's death. The deposit is a record of the date and of the testator's identity, and it prevents the loss or the suppression of the document.

The deposit does not make the will public, and it does not require the testator to disclose its contents. It is a simple protection, and it is worth using where the family is likely to dispute the will.

The Kolkata probate

Where the will falls within the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court, probate is required, and the court examines the execution, the revocations and the codicils. A later will that is produced after probate has been granted on the earlier one is dealt with by an application to revoke the grant.

Our succession practice drafts the will and the codicil and handles the probate, and the civil litigation practice deals with the challenge to a later document. Where the estate includes land, the registration practice handles the transfer under the probate.

Can I change just one clause of my will?

Yes, by a codicil executed with the same formalities as the will. The codicil should identify the will, state the clause it alters, and set out the new provision. If several clauses are to change, a fresh will is usually clearer and cheaper in the long run.

Does a later will automatically revoke the earlier one?

Yes, to the extent of the inconsistency, and a later will that says it revokes all former wills revokes them entirely. If the later document is a codicil, it revokes only what it alters. The question in a dispute is always which document is the last valid will, and the date and the execution decide it.

Can a will be revoked after the testator's death?

No. The will takes effect on death and cannot be revoked afterwards. What can happen after death is that the probate is revoked, where the grant was obtained on a document that was not the last will, or where fraud or a later will is discovered. That is a challenge to the grant, not a revocation of the will.

Revoking will codicil practice is easy to do and easy to do badly. A dated document, a clear revocation clause, two independent witnesses and the destruction or endorsement of the earlier original are the whole of the discipline, and they are what keeps a family out of the probate court for years.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422