14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Corporate & Insolvency

Section 12A: how a company exits insolvency early

A company in insolvency can be taken out of the process by a settlement with its creditors, without a resolution plan. The mechanism is section 12A ibc settlement: the applicant, usually the promoter, proposes a settlement, the committee of creditors approves it by ninety per cent of the vote, and the tribunal permits the withdrawal of the application. The company then returns to its management and the moratorium ends.

The threshold is the difficulty. Ninety per cent of the committee by value is a high bar, and a single large financial creditor can block the exit. That is why the negotiation happens before the application is moved, and why the proposal is usually made to the largest creditor first.

What the section allows

The tribunal may allow the withdrawal of an application admitted under the insolvency provisions, on an application made by the applicant with the approval of ninety per cent of the committee of creditors. The withdrawal ends the process, and the corporate debtor is restored.

The settlement is not confined to the amount of the admitted claims. It is a commercial arrangement, and creditors may accept a discount, a schedule, a mix of cash and assets, or a payment from a third party. What the section requires is the committee's approval and the payment of the costs of the process.

The costs come first. The fees of the resolution professional, the charges of the professionals he engaged, and the expenses of running the company during the process have to be paid before the settlement is implemented. A settlement that leaves the professional unpaid is not approved.

The procedure

  1. The applicant prepares a settlement proposal, with the amount, the schedule, the source of funds, and the treatment of each class of creditor.
  2. The proposal is submitted to the resolution professional in the prescribed form, with an affidavit and proof of the funds, and the professional places it before the committee.
  3. The committee considers the proposal and votes. Approval requires ninety per cent by value, and the vote is recorded in the minutes.
  4. The professional files the application before the tribunal, with the committee's resolution and the proof of the deposit of the costs.
  5. The tribunal hears the applicant, the professional and any creditor who objects, and passes an order permitting the withdrawal.
  6. The settlement is implemented, the moratorium is lifted, and the company's board resumes.

The form and the timelines for each step are prescribed by the regulations, and the professional's role is procedural: he cannot refuse to place a proposal before the committee, though he can report on its feasibility.

The stage question

The section is available at any time before the plan is approved by the tribunal, and the courts have considered its use at each stage. Before the committee is constituted, the applicant can seek withdrawal with the tribunal's permission, and the tribunal may require the committee to be constituted to consider the proposal.

After the committee has approved a resolution plan, the position is contested. Some tribunals have permitted a settlement at that stage where the plan had not been approved by the tribunal; others have refused, on the ground that the process had reached a stage at which the creditors' decision should be respected.

After the tribunal has approved the plan, the exit is ordinarily closed. The plan binds the creditors, and the company is no longer in the process. A promoter who wants to settle after approval is buying the company from the resolution applicant, not withdrawing the application.

Why creditors accept

A settlement usually offers more than the liquidation value and more, in cash terms, than the resolution plan on the table. The creditors weigh the certainty of a payment against the delay of a plan and the risk of an appeal.

The operational creditors are not members of the committee, and their treatment in a settlement is a point the tribunal examines. A settlement that pays the financial creditors and leaves the suppliers with nothing may be approved, but it is more likely to attract an objection and a delay.

The committee's approval is by value, so a settlement needs the large lenders. A proposal that satisfies the small creditors and not the banks fails at the vote, and the applicant has lost the time and the deposit.

The risks for the applicant

A settlement proposal requires proof of funds, and a proposal that is not funded is treated as an attempt to delay. The applicant should have the money or a binding commitment before filing, and the tribunal may direct the deposit of a part of the amount as a condition.

The settlement does not by itself discharge the personal guarantees of the promoters, or the criminal proceedings against them. It ends the corporate process, not the personal exposure, and the terms should be documented with the creditors so that the guarantee is dealt with.

A second risk is the professional's costs. The applicant who settles without paying the costs leaves the professional to apply to the tribunal, and the order can direct the applicant to pay with interest. A settlement negotiated before the tribunal should build the costs into the proposal from the start.

Where the file runs

The application is filed before the NCLT bench that admitted the case, which for a West Bengal company is the Kolkata bench. An order refusing the withdrawal is appealable to the appellate tribunal, and the appeal is heard on the committee's approval and the tribunal's reasons.

A corporate review of the settlement terms before the proposal is moved ensures that the guarantees, the charges and the statutory liabilities are dealt with. A bank's consent is the practical key, and a writ petition is not the route to challenge a refusal; the appeal is.

Common questions

What percentage of creditors must approve a 12A settlement?

Ninety per cent of the committee of creditors by value. The threshold was raised from seventy-five per cent, and it is the highest approval requirement in the insolvency framework.

Can the company settle after the resolution plan is approved?

Ordinarily no. Once the tribunal approves the plan, the process has ended and the plan binds the creditors. A settlement at that stage is a transaction with the resolution applicant, not a withdrawal of the application.

Do the operational creditors have a say?

They are not members of the committee, so they do not vote. Their treatment is examined by the tribunal, and an unfair exclusion can delay the order. Suppliers with large dues often object, and the objection is dealt with at the hearing.

What happens to the moratorium after withdrawal?

It ends with the withdrawal, and the creditors' rights revive, subject to the settlement they have approved. A creditor who voted against the settlement is bound by the committee's decision, and can enforce the settlement terms.

A settlement is faster than a plan and harder to get approved. Fund it before proposing it, pay the costs first, and take the ninety per cent seriously. The exit is available only while the process is alive, and the door closes with the tribunal's approval of a plan.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422