14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Corporate & Insolvency

Section 32A immunity: what it covers, who it does not

Section 32A immunity is the provision that gives an approved resolution plan its clean slate, and the section 32a ibc immunity question is always about which liabilities the clean slate covers. Once the tribunal approves a plan, no action can be taken against the corporate debtor or its property for an offence committed before the insolvency process began, or in relation to a claim arising from the earlier management of the company. The buyer of a distressed company is therefore not buying its criminal and legacy claims along with its assets.

The protection is narrow in three directions, and each of them matters. It is conditional on the plan being honest, it does not protect the resolution applicant in its own right, and it does not protect the people who ran the company before the plan.

What the section says

The protection operates on the approval of a resolution plan by the tribunal, and on the approval of a scheme of arrangement or compromise for a company in resolution. From that approval, no prosecution, suit or proceeding may be instituted or continued against the corporate debtor or its property for an offence committed before the commencement of the corporate insolvency resolution process.

The second limb covers claims, not prosecutions. No action may be taken against the corporate debtor or its property in relation to a claim arising from the earlier management of the company. That is the wider protection, and it is the one that buyers of distressed assets rely on when a department issues a notice for a period that ended years before the plan.

The protection attaches to the approval by the tribunal. A plan that the committee has approved, but that the tribunal has not sanctioned, has not yet produced the immunity. A plan that is sanctioned with conditions produces it on the terms approved.

The fraud exception

The immunity does not apply where the resolution plan has been obtained by fraud or by a material misrepresentation. Nor does it apply to a corporate debtor that was a party to the fraud or the misrepresentation.

The exception is examined at the time of approval, and the tribunal has the material: the information memorandum, the plan, the committee's minutes and the professional's report. A plan that conceals a liability known to the applicant is exposed, and the concealment can be raised later by a creditor or by the authorities.

The consequence of the exception is that the immunity is not a guarantee. The buyer's protection depends on the process having been honest, which is why the due diligence and the disclosures in the plan are not formalities.

Who the section does not protect

The promoters and the erstwhile directors. The protection is for the corporate debtor and its property, not for the individuals who managed it. A prosecution of a director for a pre-process offence continues, and so does the personal liability under a guarantee. The section does not turn the clock back on personal conduct.

The resolution applicant, for its own acts. The buyer is protected in respect of the corporate debtor's pre-process offences and claims. It is not protected for anything it does itself after the plan, and it is not protected for a misrepresentation it made in the plan.

Claims that arise after the process. A demand for a period after the plan is implemented is not a claim arising from the earlier management. Tax for the post-plan period, statutory dues accruing after the plan, and liabilities created by the buyer's own operations are all outside the section.

The plan's own conditions. Where the tribunal approves a plan with a condition, or where the plan itself undertakes to pay a category of claim, the undertaking binds the applicant. The immunity does not override the promise the buyer made to get the plan approved.

The notices that still arrive

In practice the authorities continue to issue notices and attach bank accounts for pre-process periods, because their systems do not read the tribunal's order. The buyer's response is the same each time: the approved plan, the tribunal's order, and a request that the proceedings be dropped on the strength of the immunity.

Where the authority does not accept the position, the remedy is a writ petition, and the courts have interfered where the attachment was for a period covered by an approved plan. The application should annex the order and the plan, and should identify the period of the demand against the date of commencement.

Where the demand is for a tax that the plan itself undertook to pay, the immunity does not help, and the dispute becomes one about the plan's implementation. A corporate review of the plan's undertakings after approval is the way to find those obligations before the notice arrives.

What a buyer should do

  • Read the plan's treatment of statutory liabilities, and check whether the plan assumes any of them.
  • Keep a certified copy of the tribunal's approval order and the plan, and a note of the date of commencement of the process.
  • Diarise the periods covered, because every notice has to be tested against the commencement date.
  • Obtain the professional's record of the claims admitted, to know what the process considered.
  • Record the representations made by the seller and the professional in the plan, because the fraud exception turns on them.

A resolution applicant's file should include these documents from the day the plan is approved, and the finance and legal teams should have them, not only the lawyer. A criminal proceeding against the company for a pre-process offence is met with the same order, and it should be raised at the first hearing rather than at the trial.

Where the protection is tested

The tribunal that approved the plan has the power to enforce its terms, and an application to it is one route where an authority or a creditor disregards the immunity. The appellate tribunal hears appeals from such orders, and the High Court hears a writ where the authority's action is without jurisdiction.

A writ petition before the Calcutta High Court is the effective remedy against an attachment by a state authority, because the authority is a public body and the order is administrative. It is quick, it is decided on documents, and it produces a direction that the authority must follow.

Common questions

Does the immunity apply to the promoters?

No. It protects the corporate debtor and its property. The individuals who managed the company remain liable for their own conduct, including criminal proceedings and personal guarantees. A plan that purports to discharge them does not bind a creditor who did not consent.

Is the immunity available before the plan is approved?

No. It arises on the approval of the plan by the tribunal. During the process, the corporate debtor is protected by the moratorium, which is a different protection, and the two are often confused.

What if a tax demand is for a period before the process?

It is a claim arising from the earlier management, and the immunity covers it, unless the plan assumed the liability. The buyer should respond with the order and the plan, and if the authority persists, move the High Court.

Can the immunity be taken away later?

It can be challenged on the fraud exception, and the challenge is decided on the material that was before the tribunal. A plan that was obtained by concealing a known liability is exposed, and the buyer's remedy is then against the seller and the professional rather than against the creditor.

The section gives a buyer a company without its history, not a seller without his. Read the plan's undertakings, keep the order, diarise the commencement date, and answer every legacy notice with the same two documents. The immunity is real, and it works when it is asserted.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422