14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Corporate & Insolvency

Section 43 preferences: the look-back and the defence

A payment made to one creditor shortly before an insolvency process began can be undone. Section 43 ibc preference is the provision that allows the resolution professional to apply to the tribunal to declare a preferential transaction void, and the test is whether the transfer put that creditor in a better position than the other creditors would have been in a liquidation.

The provision is aimed at the last-minute payment to a friendly lender, the transfer of a flat to a relative, and the discharge of a director's loan while the suppliers went unpaid. It is not aimed at the ordinary course of trade.

The two elements

The first element is a transfer of property or an interest in property of the corporate debtor to a creditor. The transfer can be direct or indirect, and it includes the creation of a security interest, a set-off, and a payment.

The second element is that the transfer was made on account of a pre-existing debt, and that it had the effect of putting the creditor in a beneficial position compared with the other creditors in the event of a liquidation. A payment of a debt that was due before the transfer is the paradigm case.

Both elements have to be present. A payment for goods supplied on the same day is a payment for a current obligation, not a preference for an antecedent debt. That distinction is the ordinary course defence in its simplest form.

The look-back period

The transfer must have been made within the look-back period preceding the insolvency commencement date. For a transfer to a related person, the period is two years. For a transfer to any other person, it is one year.

The related person definition is wide, and it covers a director, a promoter, a holding or subsidiary company, and a person who controls the corporate debtor. A payment to a director's loan account within two years is therefore within the period, while the same payment to an unrelated supplier would be outside it after one year.

The commencement date is the date of admission of the insolvency application, not the date of the default. A transaction that was completed before the admission is within the period if it falls in the window, and the professional computes the window from the admission date.

The exclusions

The section itself excludes certain transfers. A transfer made in the ordinary course of business or financial affairs is excluded, which is the defence that a trader relies on for the payments it makes every day. The exclusion is not a licence to prefer a creditor; it protects the routine.

A transfer that creates a security interest for a fresh advance is excluded, because the creditor has given new value at the time of the security. The exclusion does not cover security taken for an old debt, which is the transaction that the provision is designed to catch.

There is also a presumption for transfers to related persons within the look-back period, which the recipient has to rebut. The burden shifts, and a related-party transaction that has no commercial explanation is treated as a preference.

What the professional does

The professional examines the company's bank statements, its ledger and its asset transfers for the look-back period, and identifies the transactions that meet the test. He then files an application before the tribunal, and the transaction is declared void if the tribunal is satisfied.

The consequence of a void transaction is that the beneficiary must return the property or the money to the corporate debtor, and the amount is added to the estate for distribution. The creditor's claim is then dealt with as an ordinary claim, without the advantage it had obtained.

The application is usually filed along with the other avoidance applications, and the tribunal hears them together. A creditor who receives a notice should respond with the contract, the invoice and the bank record, because the ordinary course defence is documentary.

The defences that work

  • The payment was for a current supply, made on delivery or within the credit period in the contract.
  • The security was taken for a fresh advance, and the advance was actually disbursed.
  • The transfer was a sale at market value, in the ordinary course, with the consideration received.
  • The transaction was outside the look-back period, computed from the admission date.
  • The transfer was to a person who is not a creditor, and was not on account of an antecedent debt.

The defences that fail are usually the ones that rely on the relationship: a payment to a director described as a salary, a transfer of a flat to a relative at a discount, or a set-off of a loan against a supply that the company needed. The tribunal looks at the substance, and the relationship supplies the motive.

Adjacent provisions

The same chapter deals with undervalued transactions, with transactions defrauding creditors, and with extortionate credit transactions. A transfer at a price below the market value is examined under the undervalued provision even where it is not a preference, and the two applications are often filed together.

The provisions operate on the estate, and their purpose is to enlarge what is available for distribution. A creditor who has received a preference is not a wrongdoer in the criminal sense; he is a creditor who has to give back what the law treats as an unfair advantage.

A creditor's response to an avoidance application should be built on the documents, and a bank's file should show the sanction, the disbursement and the security creation dates, because the timing decides the case. A review of the group's transactions before the process begins tells a promoter what is exposed.

Where the tribunal declares a transaction void, the order is appealable to the appellate tribunal, and a written response at the notice stage is where the ordinary course defence is first put on record.

Common questions

Is a payment to a supplier within the credit period a preference?

Ordinarily no. The exclusion for the ordinary course of business covers a payment made in the terms of the contract, within the credit period. A payment made early, to prefer one supplier over others, is a different transaction.

What is the look-back period?

Two years before the insolvency commencement date for a transfer to a related person, and one year for a transfer to anyone else. The commencement date is the date of admission of the application.

Does the creditor have to return the whole amount?

The transaction is declared void, and the beneficiary returns the property or the money. The creditor's claim is then admitted in the process as an ordinary claim, without the priority it had obtained. The return is of the benefit received, not a penalty.

Can a security interest be a preference?

Yes, where it was created for an existing debt within the look-back period. A security interest created for a fresh advance is excluded, because the creditor gave new value. The date of the security against the date of the debt decides it.

Preferences are found in the bank statements and the ledger, and they are defended with the contract and the invoices. A creditor who receives the notice should produce the documents that show when the debt arose and when the payment was made, because the gap between the two is the whole case.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422