Section 66 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code is aimed at the promoter who ran the company into the ground while paying himself, transferring the assets to a sister concern, and keeping the creditors at bay. The provision allows the resolution professional, or a creditor with the leave of the tribunal, to apply for an order that such a person contribute to the assets of the company. The section 66 ibc fraudulent trading claim is not a criminal prosecution; it is a civil recovery, and it is proved on the accounts.
The claim sits alongside the avoidance provisions, which deal with preferential, undervalued and extortionate transactions within a defined look-back period. Section 66 is different. It looks at the conduct of the business as a whole, and it asks whether the business was carried on with the intent to defraud the creditors.
What the section requires
The provision applies where, during the corporate insolvency resolution process, the business of the corporate debtor has been carried on with the intent to defraud the creditors, or for a fraudulent purpose. The resolution professional is under a duty to file the application, and a creditor may file it with the leave of the tribunal.
The second limb applies to a person who was knowingly a party to the carrying on of the business in that manner. That reaches the directors, the promoters, the key managerial personnel and, in some cases, the lenders and the advisers who participated. The order the tribunal may pass is that the person contribute such sum to the assets of the corporate debtor as the tribunal thinks fit.
The intent is the crux. A business that failed because the market turned is not a business carried on with intent to defraud. A business that continued to collect advances from customers while the promoter knew that delivery was impossible, and simultaneously moved the receipts to another entity, is. The difference is established from the internal records, the bank statements and the related-party transactions.
The evidence that makes the case
- The related-party transactions, with the transfer pricing and the absence of any commercial rationale.
- The diversion of customer receipts to the promoter's personal accounts or to a connected entity.
- The payment of dividends or management fees while the statutory dues and the creditors went unpaid.
- The sale of assets below value to a connected party, shortly before the default.
- The correspondence showing that the promoter knew of the liability and continued to incur new ones.
- The statutory auditor's notes, the qualifications and the resignations.
- The bank statements of the corporate debtor and of the connected entities, obtained through the tribunal where necessary.
The resolution professional has the advantage of access to the books, the information utilities and the statutory filings. A creditor who is pursuing the claim should place the material before the professional and press for the application, because the professional's investigation is the foundation of the case.
The look-back, and the overlap with avoidance
The avoidance provisions have defined look-back periods — two years for preferential transactions with unrelated parties, one year for related parties, and similar periods for undervalued transactions. Section 66 is not tied to those periods in the same way, and it can reach conduct that falls outside them, though the tribunal will consider how far back the evidence goes and whether the claim is stale.
In practice, the two claims are pleaded together. The avoidance application seeks to restore a specific transaction to the estate, and the section 66 application seeks a contribution for the conduct. The same transfer can support both, and the tribunal can grant relief under both, provided the relief does not double-count the same amount.
The creditor's standing is a condition. A creditor cannot file the application on his own; he needs the leave of the tribunal, and the leave is granted where the professional has declined to act or where the creditor has material that the professional does not. The application for leave should be supported by the material and by the correspondence with the professional.
Procedure before the Kolkata bench
- The application is filed before the NCLT bench dealing with the corporate debtor's process, which for a company registered in West Bengal is the Kolkata bench.
- The applicant sets out the conduct, the period, the amounts and the persons sought to be made liable.
- Notice is issued to the respondents, who may include persons who are not parties to the insolvency process.
- The tribunal hears the evidence, and may direct the production of the books and the bank records.
- The order directs the contribution, and the amount is recovered as part of the process, or in the manner the tribunal directs.
The application can be filed during the process, and it survives the approval of a resolution plan in some circumstances, though the plan usually deals with the pending proceedings. A creditor who intends to pursue the claim should raise it before the plan is approved, because the approval extinguishes many claims against the corporate debtor and against the persons who controlled it.
The limits
The claim is against the persons who carried on the business, not against the company. The contribution goes to the estate, for the benefit of all creditors, and not to the applicant alone. A creditor who pursues the claim does not thereby obtain a priority over the others.
The standard of proof is high. The tribunal requires more than a showing that the company failed, and the material must connect the conduct to the loss. An application that recites the company's decline, without identifying the transactions and the intention, is usually dismissed.
The criminal route is separate. A complaint for cheating, forgery or criminal breach of trust can be filed with the police, and a prosecution under the companies law for the falsification of books is also possible. Those proceedings do not produce a recovery for the creditors, and they are pursued for a different purpose.
Common questions
Can a creditor file under Section 66 without the RP?
Only with the leave of the tribunal. The application for leave should show that the professional has been asked and has declined, or that the creditor has material the professional does not have. The tribunal decides whether the creditor may proceed.
Does the claim survive the resolution plan?
The plan, once approved, binds the corporate debtor and the creditors, and it usually provides for the withdrawal of the proceedings against the corporate debtor. The claims against the persons who carried on the business are treated differently, and the position depends on the terms of the plan and the order approving it.
What is the standard of intent?
The applicant must show that the business was carried on with the intent to defraud the creditors or for a fraudulent purpose. The intent can be inferred from the conduct and the transactions, and the inference is stronger where the promoter continued to incur debts while diverting the receipts.
Is there a time limit for the application?
The application is made during the process, and the tribunal has considered applications filed at a late stage with the explanation for the delay. The practical limit is the approval of the plan and the end of the process.
If a company has gone into insolvency and the books show transfers to connected parties, the material should be placed before the professional early. Bring the financial statements, the related-party details and the bank records to a consultation, or write to the office. Our insolvency pages and corporate law material set out the parallel remedies.