14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Corporate & Insolvency

Section 7 vs 9 vs 10 of the IBC: which route fits

The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code offers three doors into corporate insolvency: Section 7 for a financial creditor, Section 8 with Section 9 for an operational creditor, and Section 10 for the company itself. The ibc section 7 vs 9 vs 10 choice is decided by the character of the debt and by who is applying, not by preference. A lender holding a term loan files under Section 7; a supplier of goods files under Section 9 after a statutory demand notice; and a company that has lost the ability to pay files under Section 10 on its own.

The threshold that applies to all three

No application is admitted unless the default exceeds the threshold notified by the government, which was raised to one crore rupees in 2020 and remains the operative figure unless changed. The default is the amount due and unpaid, and the calculation is not a matter of convenience: a debt of ninety lakh does not become a crore because interest is added later, and a debt of one crore five lakh is within the threshold even if part of it is disputed.

Each route also has a limitation. The application has to be filed within three years of the date of default, since the residuary limitation provision applies, and a default that is time-barred produces an application that the tribunal will reject. Acknowledgement of the debt in the accounts or in correspondence can extend the period, which is why the emails and the balance confirmations matter.

Section 7: the financial creditor

A financial creditor is one to whom a financial debt is owed — a loan, a debenture, a facility, a guarantee, or a debt that carries the time value of money. The application is filed in the prescribed form with the record of the default, the facility agreement, the sanction letter and the statement of accounts. There is no demand notice requirement, and the creditor can proceed directly.

  • Who files: a bank, a non-banking financial company, a bondholder, an assignee of a loan, or a guarantor who has paid.
  • Proof of default: the sanction, the disbursement, the statement of account showing the default, and the notice of demand given by the lender under its own agreement.
  • No dispute requirement: the existence of a dispute does not bar the application, though it may affect the tribunal's view of the admission.
  • Interim resolution professional: appointed on admission, and the moratorium follows automatically.

Section 8 and Section 9: the operational creditor

An operational creditor is one owed a debt in respect of goods or services, including employment dues and dues to government authorities. Here the Code insists on a step before the application: a demand notice in the prescribed form, delivered to the corporate debtor, calling for payment within ten days. The corporate debtor may reply within those ten days showing that it has paid, or pointing to the existence of a dispute.

If the ten days pass without payment or a dispute, the creditor files under Section 9 with the demand notice, the proof of delivery, an affidavit confirming that no notice of dispute was received, and a certificate from the bank. If a dispute is shown — a genuine pre-existing dispute, not a defence invented after the notice — the application is rejected and the creditor is left to a civil suit or arbitration.

  1. Serve the demand notice, with the invoice attached, by registered post, speed post or email.
  2. Keep the proof of delivery. Without it, the application fails at the threshold.
  3. Wait the ten days, and record any reply received.
  4. File within the limitation period, with the affidavit and the bank certificate.
  5. Address any pre-existing dispute in the application itself, rather than waiting for the company to raise it.

Section 10: the company itself

A corporate debtor that has defaulted may file on its own, and the application must be accompanied by the books of account, the information on its assets and liabilities, and a resolution of the shareholders or of three quarters of the partners, together with a declaration that the filing is not fraudulent or malicious. The declaration is taken seriously: a filing made to defeat creditors attracts the penal provisions.

Section 10 is used where the management wants the protection of the moratorium and a resolution process rather than a piecemeal recovery by creditors. It is also the route that a company chooses when the alternative is a winding-up petition, because the Code suspends the individual enforcement that a winding-up would invite.

Practical differences that decide the choice

A financial creditor's application is faster, because there is no demand notice, and the admission test is narrower. An operational creditor's application is cheaper but slower, and the dispute defence is a real obstacle. A Section 10 filing gives the company control of the timing but exposes the directors to scrutiny of their conduct.

There is also the question of what the applicant wants. A supplier wants to be paid, and an insolvency application is a pressure tactic that sometimes produces a settlement before admission. A bank wants the process, because the resolution plan may realise more than a recovery certificate. The company wants breathing space and a resolution. Each purpose points to a different section.

Where the application is filed in Kolkata

Applications go to the National Company Law Tribunal, Kolkata bench, which has territorial jurisdiction over companies whose registered office is in West Bengal and the neighbouring states. The application is filed through the tribunal's electronic filing system, with the prescribed fee, and the first hearing is usually for admission. An order admitting the application can be appealed to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal within thirty days, and the committee of creditors is constituted soon after admission.

The insolvency and bankruptcy practice prepares the application and appears before the tribunal, the legal notice service drafts and serves the operational creditor's demand notice, and a debt that is disputed on facts is better pursued as a recovery suit than as an insolvency application. Company law questions that arise alongside the filing are dealt with under corporate law.

Can an operational creditor skip the demand notice?

No. Section 9 requires the Section 8 notice, and an application filed without it is rejected at the admission stage. The defect is not curable by serving the notice after filing.

What if the company disputes the debt after the notice?

A dispute raised after the notice, without any prior correspondence, is usually not treated as a genuine pre-existing dispute. A dispute that was raised before the notice, with material to support it, defeats the application.

Is a bank's claim under a guarantee a financial debt?

Yes, where the guarantee secures a financial debt. The creditor can proceed against the corporate debtor and against the guarantor, and the two proceedings can run concurrently, as the personal guarantor provisions allow.

Can the same creditor file twice for the same default?

Not for the same debt and the same default. Withdrawal and refiling is permitted in limited circumstances, and a second application on a default already adjudicated is barred.

Choose the section by asking two questions: what kind of debt is it, and what do you want the process to achieve. The form, the notice and the tribunal follow from those answers.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422