Executor powers before probate are real but limited, and the limit is the difference between administering an estate and disposing of it. The executor derives his authority from the will itself, and he becomes the legal representative of the deceased from the moment of death. He can take charge of the assets, protect them, pay the funeral expenses, defend claims and gather information. What he cannot safely do, for property within the original jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court, is establish his right as executor or legatee, sell the immovable property or distribute the legacies until probate is granted.
The source of the executor's authority
The Indian Succession Act, 1925 provides that the executor or administrator of a deceased person is his legal representative for all purposes, and that all the property of the deceased vests in him as such. The vesting is not a transfer; it is a consequence of the office. The executor can therefore sue and be sued in respect of the estate, and a person who deals with the executor in good faith is dealing with the estate.
That said, the authority is not unlimited, and it is not the same as ownership. The executor holds the assets for the purposes of the will: to pay the debts, the funeral and testamentary expenses, and the legacies, and to distribute the residue. He is accountable to the beneficiaries for every rupee, and he cannot use the estate for his own purposes.
What can be done immediately
- Secure the assets. Take possession of the documents, the keys, the bank statements and the jewellery, prepare an inventory, and keep the assets separate from his own.
- Insure and maintain. Keep the property insured, pay the municipal taxes and the electricity bills, and carry out urgent repairs, because a failure to preserve the estate is a breach of duty.
- Pay the funeral expenses and the expenses of obtaining the grant, which are a first charge on the estate.
- Notify the banks, the insurers and the debtors of the death, and collect the information needed for the petition.
- Defend or bring urgent proceedings where the estate is threatened, such as an encroachment, a tenant who refuses to pay, or a claim against the deceased.
- File the probate petition, which is the executor's first duty where a grant is required, and which he should not delay.
An executor who acts reasonably in these matters is protected; an executor who does nothing while the flat is vandalised or the taxes accumulate is exposed to a claim by the beneficiaries.
What must wait for the grant
For property within the local limits of the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court, Section 213 of the Indian Succession Act provides that no right as executor or legatee can be established in a court of justice unless probate or letters of administration have been granted. In practice that means the executor cannot complete a sale of the Kolkata flat, cannot transfer the shares, and cannot obtain the release of the bank balance without the grant.
The banks and the sub-registrar apply the same rule. A bank will generally release a fixed deposit to the executor only on production of the probate, and a sub-registrar will not register a deed executed by an executor without it. A buyer's advocate will insist on the grant, and a purchaser who buys without it takes a title that may be challenged.
The executor's authority begins at death, but his power to deal with the assets begins with the grant. Confusing the two is how families lose money to a buyer who pays too early.
The intermediate powers: sale for administration
Where the will gives the executor a power of sale, the executor may sell property for the purposes of administration even before probate, and the buyer's title depends on the will and the power. In practice, few buyers and fewer banks will accept that position without the grant, and the safe course is to obtain the probate first.
Where the estate has urgent debts and the assets are perishable, the executor can apply to the court for directions, and the court can authorise a sale or an interim arrangement. The application for directions is the proper route where the executor is in doubt, and it protects him from a later allegation of breach of trust.
Renunciation, and the point of no return
An executor may renounce the office before he has intermeddled with the estate, by a written renunciation filed with the court. Once he has acted as executor — by taking possession, paying the debts, or filing the petition — he cannot renounce, and he must complete the administration or obtain the court's leave to be discharged.
The choice should be made quickly. An executor who is elderly, unwell, in conflict with the beneficiaries or living abroad should consider renouncing in favour of a person who can act, because an executor who accepts the office and then fails to administer it is liable for the loss.
Duties, accounts and liability
The executor must keep accounts, produce them to the beneficiaries on request and to the court on direction, invest the estate's money prudently, and distribute only after the debts and the legacies are provided for. He must not mix the estate's money with his own, must not buy the estate's assets without the court's sanction, and must not prefer one beneficiary over another.
An executor who distributes the estate and leaves a creditor unpaid is personally liable to the creditor, and an executor who sells an asset at an undervalue to a relative is exposed to a claim for devastavit. The protection is a proper valuation, a written record of the decisions, and the court's directions where the position is uncertain.
Common questions
Can the executor sell the flat before probate?
Where the will gives a power of sale, the executor may contract to sell, but the transfer cannot be completed safely without the grant, and the sub-registrar will require it. The practical answer is to file the probate application at once and to explain the position to the buyer rather than to promise a completion date that depends on the court.
Can the executor take a fee?
The will may provide for a commission, and where it does not, the court can allow a reasonable remuneration in an appropriate case. The executor's expenses are recoverable from the estate, but a commission without the authority of the will or the court is a breach of duty.
What if the executor and the beneficiaries disagree?
The executor can apply to the court for directions, and the beneficiaries can apply for the removal of the executor for misconduct or for a delay that harms the estate. The court's supervision is the remedy, and it is quicker and cheaper than a suit against the executor in most cases.
Does an executor have to probate a will that gives away nothing in Kolkata?
If the will deals only with property outside the original jurisdiction, or with movable assets that the bank will release on an indemnity, probate may be unnecessary. Where the will deals with a Kolkata flat, the grant is required in practice, and the bank and the registrar will ask for it.
Act at once on what can be done, and file for the grant on what cannot. A dated inventory, the tax receipts and a prompt petition protect both the estate and the executor. Our family law practice advises executors on their powers and files the probate petition on the original side of the Calcutta High Court, and the registration team handles the transfer and the mutation once the grant is issued. Where a beneficiary or a creditor sues the estate, civil litigation defends the executor.