14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Accident & Consumer

The offer price system, and why not to take the first figure

The offer is a settlement proposal, not an assessment of your entitlement. Insurers commonly open with a figure built on a notional income, no future prospects and an early multiplier, and they present it as the amount the tribunal would award anyway. Sometimes that is close to true; often it is well short. The right response is to test the arithmetic against the settled heads of compensation before deciding, not to sign because the offer arrived quickly.

Why an offer is made at all

A motor accident claim that goes the distance takes time. Witnesses have to be served, the police papers obtained, the medical board's certificate produced, the employer brought to the box. Every one of those steps costs the insurer money and every month of delay costs the claimant. An offer is a way of buying certainty on both sides.

For the insurer, settlement caps exposure and avoids an award that may include interest and costs. For the claimant, settlement delivers money now, without the risk of a finding of contributory negligence or a lower disability assessment than expected. Both sides are trading something real. That is why the offer is not a trick, and also why it is not a valuation.

The practice in West Bengal is that the figure is discussed at the initial hearings, often through the insurer's panel advocate, before the evidence closes. Nothing in the Act prevents a settlement at any stage, and a compromise recorded by the tribunal is binding once it is recorded.

The four places the first offer usually goes wrong

Look at the arithmetic in the offer, not at the headline. Four inputs are habitually understated.

  • Income. An offer will often assume the notional or minimum-wage income for a claimant who has salary slips, a Form 16 and a bank statement. This is the single largest variable in a serious injury or fatal claim.
  • Future prospects. The settled rule adds an increment to the income for the years the victim would have progressed. An offer frequently omits it altogether.
  • The multiplier. A multiplier picked from a higher age band than the victim's age at the date of the accident shrinks the capital figure quickly.
  • Disability. An offer may take the medical certificate's percentage as the loss of earning capacity without asking whether the claimant's particular occupation makes the loss worse.

Add to these the heads that an offer often leaves out entirely: future treatment, loss of amenity, the conventional amounts for consortium and funeral expenses in a fatal case, and interest for the period already lost.

What your own calculation should look like

Before you respond to any offer, build the number yourself, on paper, with the documents you actually have. That means:

  1. Fix the annual income from the strongest evidence available — salary certificate, ITR, bank credits, or the minimum wage notification for the trade.
  2. Add the percentage for future prospects appropriate to the employment and the age band.
  3. Select the multiplier for the age at the date of the accident.
  4. Multiply, then apply the loss of earning capacity, not the bare certificate percentage.
  5. Add the separate heads with a costing for medical expenses already incurred and an estimate for future treatment.
  6. Add interest from the date of the petition to the expected date of the award.

The difference between that figure and the offer is your negotiating range. It is also your reality check: if your own arithmetic lands near the offer, the offer is probably fair and there is no reason to litigate for another two years to recover the same money.

What a compromise costs you

A settlement recorded by the tribunal ends the claim. You cannot come back for more if the injury turns out worse than the doctors expected, unless the compromise expressly preserves that right — and compromises recorded in standard form do not.

This is the argument for caution in a case involving a head injury, a spinal injury or a child claimant. The long-term consequences are not knowable at the time of the offer, and the money is being paid once. In such a case it is often worth refusing the offer and letting the medical evidence settle, even at the cost of delay.

For a claimant whose injury has stabilised, whose income is documented, and whose disability certificate is in hand, a reasonable offer is simply a faster route to the same money.

Ask what the offer assumes. If the insurer's advocate cannot tell you the income, the multiplier and the disability share used, the figure has not been calculated — it has been quoted.

The mechanics of accepting

If you accept, the terms should be recorded in writing before the tribunal, with the amount, the date of deposit, the mode of payment, and the heads it covers. The tribunal then passes an award in terms of the compromise, which is enforceable like any other award. A private settlement between the parties that is not recorded leaves the claim alive, and an insurer that has paid privately may still contest the case.

Check who is entitled to receive. In a fatal case, the dependants are the claimants, and the tribunal will want to see how the money is to be apportioned and whether a minor's share needs to be held in a fixed deposit. An offer that ignores apportionment creates a dispute among the claimants after the money arrives.

Also check the tax and the deduction position. Interest awarded by the tribunal is part of the award; a deduction made by the insurer without an order is not permissible.

The Kolkata practice

Claims are heard by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal attached to the City Civil Court in Kolkata, and in the districts at the tribunals attached to the district court at Alipore or Barasat. Settlement discussions happen at the hearing, and the tribunal encourages them because the docket is heavy. That is a reason to be prepared at the first hearing rather than at the last.

An award passed on compromise is appealable in principle, but a party that has accepted the terms will struggle to reopen them. The practical effect of accepting is finality.

Common questions

Is the first offer usually below the award?

Usually, though not always. It depends on the documents and the insurer. The point is not that the offer is unfair but that it is made before the evidence is tested, and an offer made early is priced for the insurer's risk, not for your loss.

Can I negotiate?

Yes. A counter-offer supported by the income proof and the disability certificate is far more effective than a bare demand. Insurers respond to documents.

What if I accept and the cheque bounces?

The compromise award is enforceable. A dishonoured cheque from an insurer is unusual, but if it happens the remedy is execution of the award, and separately a complaint under the Negotiable Instruments Act if the cheque was for a legally enforceable debt.

The offer is worth considering, and worth pricing first. Our motor accident claims page sets out the tribunal procedure, our fee schedule tells you what an assessment costs, and a civil litigation advocate can run the arithmetic with you before you sign anything.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422