A motor third party policy is not a matter of contract alone. The Motor Vehicles Act requires every vehicle in a public place to be insured against liability for injury or death caused to third parties, and it prescribes what the policy must cover. That is why an "act only" policy pays the victim of an accident even though the insured never asks it to, and why an insurer cannot rely on a private agreement to escape the statutory minimum.
The statutory duty to insure
Section 146 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, prohibits the use of a motor vehicle in a public place without a policy of insurance complying with the Act. Section 147 then sets the minimum content: the policy must cover liability for the death of, or bodily injury to, any person caused by or arising out of the use of the vehicle in a public place. For a vehicle carrying passengers or goods, the policy must also cover a passenger's baggage or goods, and must cover the liability of the insured under the workmen's legislation in relation to employees carried in the vehicle.
The statutory third party liability for death and bodily injury is not capped by an amount in the policy. Property damage is different: the Act fixes a limit for third party property damage and a policy that pays more than that is doing so voluntarily.
What "third party" includes
A third party is anyone other than the insured and the insurer. A pedestrian, a cyclist, a driver of another vehicle, a passenger in another vehicle and, importantly, a person travelling in the insured vehicle are all third parties for this purpose. The insured himself is not a third party, and damage to his own vehicle is not covered by a third party policy at all.
The driver of the insured vehicle is an employee, and his injury is covered where the policy includes the workmen's compensation cover and a premium has been paid for him. Where that cover was not paid for, the insurer is generally not liable to indemnify the owner, though the legal position on an unauthorised or unnamed driver requires care and depends on the policy terms.
A gratuitous passenger in a private car used for social purposes is covered after the 1994 amendment to the Act, because the policy is now required to cover a passenger as a third party. Passengers in a goods vehicle travelling unauthorised are treated differently; the courts have consistently held that an unauthorised passenger in a goods vehicle is not covered by the statutory policy, and any award in their favour is against the owner and driver.
What the policy never covers
- The insured's own injury and the insured's own vehicle damage, under a third party only policy.
- Damage caused by the use of the vehicle outside the permitted purpose, for example a private car used for hire.
- Use without a valid driving licence, or by a person disqualified from driving.
- Use in a racing or speed test, unless specifically covered.
- Damage caused while the vehicle was being used in breach of a condition of the permit, in some cases.
- Injuries to a person who was in the vehicle as a passenger in a goods vehicle, in the ordinary case.
Even where an exclusion applies, the insurer remains liable to pay the third party whose claim has been established, and is then entitled to recover that amount from the insured. This is the practical effect of Section 149, and it is the reason a tribunal award is usually satisfied by the insurer rather than by the owner. The recovery suit between the insurer and the insured is a separate proceeding, and the insured often discovers the problem only at that stage.
The defences an insurer may raise
Section 149 allows the insurer to defend a claim on defined grounds: that the policy did not cover the vehicle, that the condition as to the use was breached, that the driver was not licensed, and that the vehicle was not the one insured. Section 170 permits wider defences where the insurer applies and the tribunal so allows, typically where the insured has failed to appear or the vehicle was not traced.
An insurer cannot add defences at will. It cannot argue the quantum as if it were the owner's advocate unless Section 170 has been permitted, and it cannot avoid liability to the victim merely because the insured failed to cooperate. The statute places the loss on the insurer and leaves it to recover from the insured.
The no-fault provision
Section 140 provides a no-fault liability: where death or permanent disablement results from an accident, the owner of the vehicle is liable to pay a fixed statutory sum, whether or not negligence is proved. That liability is in addition to the fault-based claim, but the sum awarded under one head is deducted from the other, so the claimant is not paid twice. A claim under Section 140 can be decided quickly and gives the family something while the main claim proceeds.
A related provision covers a hit and run case, where the vehicle cannot be identified, through the statutory scheme under Section 161 rather than the policy.
Reading a policy before you rely on it
The schedule shows the insured, the vehicle, the period, the permitted use and the premium heads. The endorsement pages show whether a passenger cover, a driver cover or an unnamed passenger cover has been bought. The conditions show the obligation to report the accident, the requirement of a valid licence, and the limits on use.
The most useful habit is to check the permitted use clause against what the vehicle was actually doing. A private car registered for personal use and hired out for a wedding is outside the policy, and a commercial vehicle without a permit is a live defence. These things are not moral judgments; they are the words of the contract, and they are read strictly.
For a claimant, the practical question is whether the policy covers the vehicle on the date of the accident. The insurer must disclose the policy when impleaded, and a claim cannot be defeated because the claimant does not have a copy. Our motor accident claims practice impleads the insurer at the start, and the banking and finance side matters where a financed vehicle's policy is in the name of a lender.
Common questions
Can a pillion rider claim under the policy?
Yes, in the ordinary case the policy covers a passenger in a private car or on a two-wheeler, and the pillion rider is a third party. The claim is against the insurer of the vehicle, and the question of the rider's own negligence is separate.
Is the insured covered for his own injury?
Not as a third party. He is covered only where a separate personal accident cover or a driver's cover has been purchased, or where he was an employee covered under the workmen's compensation clause.
What if the policy had lapsed on the date of the accident?
Then there is no insurer to pay, and the claim is against the owner and driver personally. A policy that lapses on the previous day is a common and expensive discovery, and it is why the certificate of insurance should be checked at the time of the accident.
Does the insurer pay even if the driver was drunk?
The insurer pays the third party and may recover from the insured, because the statutory liability to the victim is not extinguished by the insured's breach. Whether recovery succeeds depends on the policy and the evidence.
A third party policy is a statutory floor, not a shop of options. Read the schedule, keep the certificate of insurance, and join the insurer in the claim. If you need help with a claim or a policy dispute, contact our office; the consultation fees are listed on the site.