On admission of an insolvency application, the management of the corporate debtor passes out of the hands of its directors and into the hands of the resolution professional. That transfer is the central feature of the resolution professional powers ibc provides: the professional takes control of the assets, collects the claims, verifies them, runs the business as a going concern, and places a resolution plan before the committee of creditors. The directors remain in office but their powers are suspended, and the professional acts under the directions of the committee except in the matters reserved to him.
The creditor's relationship with the resolution professional is therefore not adversarial in principle. The professional is an officer of the process, accountable to the committee and to the tribunal, and a creditor who understands what he may ask for gets better answers than one who writes angry letters.
What the professional takes over
The statute provides that the management of the affairs of the corporate debtor vests in the resolution professional, and that the powers of the board of directors are suspended. The professional takes control of the assets, the books, the bank accounts and the records, and he may appoint accountants, legal advisers and other professionals at the cost of the process.
He must collect the information relating to the assets and the liabilities, take control and custody of the assets, and receive and collate the claims of creditors. He constitutes the committee of creditors, convenes its meetings, and records its decisions. Where the business is to be kept running, he manages the operations, either directly or through the existing personnel, and he may appoint a professional to assist him.
Where the corporate debtor has avoided a transaction, or has been party to a preferential or undervalued transaction, he must file an application before the tribunal for the avoidance of that transaction, and for the restoration of the value to the estate. That duty is not discretionary; it is part of his mandate.
What a creditor may ask of him
- The status of the claim. A creditor may ask whether his claim has been received, verified, admitted or rejected, and on what basis.
- The list of creditors. The committee members are entitled to the information that the professional is required to provide, and the list is part of it.
- The minutes of the committee. The minutes are circulated to the members, and a member who has not received them may ask.
- The financial position. The professional's reports, the cash flow statements and the details of the assets are provided to the committee.
- The plan. When a plan is received, it must be provided to the members with the information needed to decide.
- The reasons for a decision. A creditor whose claim is rejected is entitled to the reason, and to the opportunity to file a representation before the committee considers the claim.
The request should be in writing, and it should identify the claim and the information sought. A professional dealing with hundreds of creditors responds to specific requests; a general demand for "all records" is answered with the documents the law requires, not with the file.
Claims: verification and rejection
The creditor files a claim in the prescribed form, with the proof, within the period the professional notifies. The proof is documentary: the agreement, the invoices, the ledger, the bank statement, the decree or the award. The professional verifies the claim and admits it or rejects it, and the rejection is communicated with reasons.
A rejection is not the end. The creditor may file a representation, and the committee considers it. Where the committee is not satisfied, the creditor may apply to the tribunal, which has the power to direct the professional to consider the claim. The application is filed before the NCLT bench dealing with the process — for a company in West Bengal, the Kolkata bench.
The claim must be filed even where the creditor has a decree or an arbitration award. A decree is a strong proof, but it does not by itself place the creditor in the committee; the claim must be filed, and the amount must be computed on the date the process commenced.
The limitation on his powers
The professional does not have the power to decide the commercial future of the company. That decision belongs to the committee, which votes on the plan with the majority the Code requires. The professional conducts the process and places the plan; he does not select the resolution applicant on his own.
Nor can he continue a transaction that is outside the ordinary course of business without the committee's approval. The sale of a material asset, the grant of a security interest, the change of the auditor and the institution of a suit require the committee's approval, and the requirement is a check on the professional's discretion.
His fees are part of the process cost, and they are examined by the committee. A fee that is disproportionate to the estate is a matter the committee can question, and the tribunal can reduce it.
Where the professional fails
A professional who fails to perform his duties is subject to the discipline of the insolvency regulator, and a creditor can complain to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board. The complaint should set out the duty, the failure, the material and the prejudice, and it should be supported by the correspondence.
The tribunal also supervises the process, and a creditor can apply to it for directions where the professional has acted beyond his powers, has failed to file an avoidance application, or has admitted or rejected a claim without reasons. The application is not an appeal against a commercial decision, and the tribunal will not substitute its view for the committee's on the plan.
Our pages on insolvency and bankruptcy and banking and finance cover the parallel remedies, and recovery suits covers the claim before the process begins.
Common questions
Does the resolution professional replace the board?
The board remains in existence but its powers are suspended, and the management vests in the professional. The directors must cooperate, and a failure to cooperate is a ground for an application to the tribunal.
Can a creditor attend the committee meetings?
Only the members of the committee attend, and the membership is determined by the claims admitted. A creditor whose claim is admitted as a financial creditor is a member and is entitled to notice and to the minutes. An operational creditor is not a member.
How long does the process take?
The Code prescribes an outer period for the process, extendable by the tribunal within limits. In practice the period is often extended, and the committee's progress and the litigation over claims decide the timeline.
Can the professional be removed?
Yes. The committee may replace him by a vote, and the tribunal may remove him on an application. The replacement requires the approval of the committee and the appointment of another registered professional.
A creditor who has not received the claim status or the minutes should ask in writing, and should keep the correspondence. If a claim has been rejected, bring the rejection, the proof and the claim form to a consultation, or write to the office before the committee approves the plan.