A government hospital that charges you fees is a service provider under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, and a patient who pays those fees is a consumer. A free treatment is different. The Act excludes any service rendered free of charge, and that single exclusion decides many complaints against public hospitals. Beyond hospitals, government departments that supply water, power or telecom service are covered when they act as service providers; departments performing a statutory function are not.
Why "free of charge" is the dividing line
The definition of service in the Act excludes the rendering of any service free of charge. A government hospital that treats a patient on a paying bed, charges a registration fee and a consultation fee, and bills for investigations is providing a service for consideration. A patient who pays those charges has a grievance under the Act if the service is deficient.
Where the treatment is entirely free, the exclusion applies and the consumer commission has no jurisdiction. That is not a comment on quality; it is the words of the statute. A patient in a free ward who suffers harm has other remedies, such as a writ petition for negligence of a public authority or a civil suit, but he is not a consumer.
The mixed case needs care. A hospital may offer a free ward and paid cabins, and a patient may move between them. The commission will look at whether any part of the treatment was paid for, and what the bill records. A receipt for a paid scan, taken during an otherwise free stay, may be enough to make the patient a consumer for the transaction on which the complaint rests.
Medical negligence and deficiency
A complaint against a hospital is a complaint of deficiency in service. The patient must show what the hospital failed to do: a diagnosis missed on the evidence before the doctor, an infection caused by unclean hands or instruments, a wrong drug administered, a delay in referring a patient to a higher centre, or a record that was never maintained.
Medical practice is not judged by hindsight. The standard is the care expected of an ordinary practitioner of the same competence, and a mere adverse outcome is not proof of negligence. The commission will want the full medical record, an opinion from a qualified doctor, and, where the facts are technical, an expert opinion from a recognised institution.
Hospitals carry a separate duty that does not depend on the doctor's judgment: the maintenance of records, the duty to obtain informed consent, the duty to provide emergency treatment, and the duty to hand over the patient's papers on request. Non-availability of staff and records are failures of the institution, and they are the easiest allegations to prove.
When the complaint is not against a hospital
Public utilities are covered. A municipal water supply that bills a resident and never supplies water, an electricity board that bills for a meter that was removed, a telecom provider that continues to charge after a disconnection: each is a service for consideration, and each has been the subject of consumer commissions' orders.
Statutory functions are not. The refusal of a licence, the cancellation of a permit, the assessment of tax and the decision of a land acquisition officer are exercises of statutory power, and they belong in a writ petition under Article 226 before the Calcutta High Court. A consumer commission will reject such a complaint as not being a service.
Government-run insurance schemes, where a premium is deducted and a benefit is promised, sit in between. The commission may take up a complaint where the subscriber paid a contribution and the promise of cover creates a service relationship. Where the scheme is a purely statutory welfare benefit, the route is the department and the writ court.
Filing it in Kolkata
- Write to the hospital's medical superintendent setting out the complaint and the relief you want, and give a reasonable time to reply. This letter becomes the best evidence of the demand.
- Apply for a certified copy of the entire medical record under the hospital's records procedure; keep the application and the receipt.
- Obtain an opinion from a doctor of the same specialty, in writing, on the standard of care and the cause of the harm.
- File the complaint before the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission for the district where the hospital is situate, or before the State Commission at Kolkata if the value exceeds the district limit, through the e-Daakhil portal or in person.
- Attach the bills, the discharge summary, the expert opinion, the correspondence and an affidavit.
Within the two-year limitation, which runs from the date of the negligence or, in an appropriate case, from the date the patient discovered it. The commission can condone delay, but the explanation has to be credible.
Interim relief is available for a serious case: the commission can order the hospital to produce records, and in an appropriate case to pay compensation at the end of the case. There is no provision for an interim payment as of right, unlike some other forums.
What the commission can order
It can direct the removal of the deficiency, the refund of fees paid, compensation for the loss and injury suffered, and the cost of the proceedings. Against a hospital it may also direct a change of practice, such as the maintenance of records or the display of charges.
The order is enforceable as a decree, and non-compliance can attract proceedings under the enforcement provisions of the Act. In practice the order is honoured more often against a public institution after the commission's order is communicated to the department, since the alternative is attachment of the institution's property.
The practical difficulty
The hardest part of a hospital complaint is medical causation. The patient knows something went wrong; the record must show what. That is why the certified copy of the full record, including the nursing notes and the operation notes, is the first document to obtain, and why an expert opinion should be sought before the complaint is drafted rather than after the hospital files its reply.
There is also the question of who to sue. The treating doctor, the hospital, the consultant engaged on a fee, and the nursing agency may each be liable to a different extent. Complaints that name everyone without distinguishing their roles are difficult to decide, and the commission may dismiss against the parties about whom nothing specific is said. Our consumer protection practice settles the parties and the evidence before filing, and civil litigation is the route if the hospital's negligence also supports a compensation suit.
Common questions
Can I complain about a free government hospital?
Not as a consumer, because the Act excludes free services. A writ petition alleging arbitrariness or negligence by a public hospital, or a civil suit for damages, remains possible but is a different case with a different burden.
Do I need a lawyer at the commission?
You may appear yourself, and many complainants do. A complaint that involves medical records and expert opinion is better prepared with help, because the pleadings must identify the specific deficiency rather than the outcome.
Is a doctor's adverse opinion enough?
It helps but is not conclusive. The commission weighs the opinion against the hospital's explanation and the record. An opinion that says only that the treatment was not ideal is weaker than one that identifies a departure from standard practice and its consequence.
Can I claim the cost of treatment in a private hospital after a referral?
Yes, where the referral was necessitated by the deficiency and the cost was reasonable. The bills and the referral note are the evidence, and the commission examines whether the treatment was avoidable.
A government hospital is not immune; it is a service provider when it charges. The case then turns on the record and the standard of care, like any other complaint. If you are considering one, contact the office; the consultation fee is ₹2,000 and is published.