A property under litigation can be bought, but the buyer takes it subject to the result of the suit. Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 provides that a transfer of a property in dispute during the pendency of a suit does not affect the rights of the parties to the suit, and the transferee is bound by the decree that follows. The buyer's remedy is against the seller for the price, and by then the seller may have nothing.
That is the doctrine of lis pendens, and it is the reason a title search must include a litigation search and not merely a search of the registration office.
The conditions the doctrine requires
- A suit or proceeding is pending in a court of competent jurisdiction.
- The suit concerns a right to immovable property.
- The property is transferred during the pendency of the suit.
- The transfer affects the rights of the other party to the suit.
- The notice of the pendency of the suit has been registered, as the proviso to the section requires.
All five must be present. The last one is the amendment of 1929, and it changed the position: before it, every purchaser was fixed with notice of every pending suit, which was an unreasonable burden. The proviso requires the plaintiff to register a notice of the suit, and a purchaser who searches the register and finds nothing is protected against the suit.
What pendency means
Pendency begins with the institution of the suit and continues until the final decree, and it includes the appeal and the execution proceedings. A transfer made after the decree of the trial court, while an appeal is pending, is a transfer during the pendency, and it is caught by the section.
That is the point most buyers miss. They check whether the suit is pending in the trial court, find that it has been decreed, and complete the purchase, without checking the appeal.
The notice of pendency
The notice is registered under the Registration Act in the office of the sub-registrar for the area where the property lies. It identifies the suit, the parties and the property, and it is entered in the register so that a search discloses it.
A buyer's search should therefore cover both the property and the litigants: the property for the registered notice, and the courts for the suit. The registration search will show the notice if it was registered; the court search will show the suit even if it was not.
Where the notice has not been registered, the transfer is not affected by the doctrine, and the purchaser's title prevails against the plaintiff's claim, although the purchaser may still be joined in the suit and may have to prove his purchase. The proviso protects the purchaser, not the seller.
The effect on the buyer
A buyer caught by the doctrine is bound by the decree. If the court holds that the plaintiff owns the property, the buyer loses it, and the sale deed is of no effect against the plaintiff. If the court holds that the property must be partitioned, the buyer's share is the seller's share, and no more.
The buyer's remedy is against the seller: for breach of contract, for a refund of the price, and for damages. Where the seller has other assets, that claim may be worth pursuing; where he does not, the buyer has lost the money and the property.
The exceptions, and the court's sanction
Section 52 contains an exception for a transfer made with the sanction of the court that is hearing the suit. A sale under a court's order, an auction in execution, or a sale approved by the court in the course of the proceedings is not caught by the doctrine.
Where the plaintiff consents to the sale, the transfer is not affected either, and the consent should be recorded in the suit. The consent is the cleanest way to remove the lis pendens, and it is cheaper than waiting for the decree.
The related traps
An attachment before judgment under Order 38 of the Code of Civil Procedure binds the property, and a transfer after the attachment is void against the attaching creditor. A buyer who searches only for suits and not for attachments will miss it.
The moratorium in an insolvency proceeding freezes the company's assets, and a transfer during the moratorium is void. Where the seller is a company, the NCLT record should be checked.
A suit for partition is the most common form of lis pendens in family property. A buyer who purchases a share from one co-owner during the suit buys a share that is subject to the decree, and the partition may allot him a plot he did not expect.
What a buyer can do
- Search the courts and the registration office, and record the results.
- Ask the seller for an affidavit that no suit is pending and no notice has been registered, and make it a term of the agreement.
- Where a suit exists, obtain the plaintiff's consent or the court's sanction, and record it before the sale.
- Where the suit cannot be resolved, price the risk into the transaction and structure the payment so that a part is held back until the decree.
- Consider waiting for the decree, particularly where the suit is at the final argument stage.
- Insure the risk by an indemnity from the seller with security, not by a clause alone.
The Kolkata courts and offices
The suit may be in the City Civil Court at Kolkata, the Calcutta High Court, or the district court at Alipore or Barasat, and the notice of pendency is registered at the sub-registrar's office for the area. The eCourts portal and the High Court's case search give the status, and the registration office gives the notice.
Our title disputes practice handles the search and the opinion, and the civil litigation practice deals with the suit itself. Where the buyer has already completed and the decree has gone against the seller, the specific performance practice advises on the claim against the seller.
Can I buy a property that is under litigation?
Yes, but you buy it subject to the suit, and the price should reflect that. The safe course is to obtain the plaintiff's consent or the court's sanction, or to wait for the decree. Buying without either is a gamble on the outcome, and the buyer is not a party to the case and cannot control it.
What if the notice of pendency was never registered?
Then the proviso to section 52 protects the purchaser, and the transfer is not affected by the doctrine. The purchaser may still be drawn into the suit, and the plaintiff may argue that the purchase was not bona fide, but the registered notice is the statutory condition and its absence is the purchaser's defence.
What does the buyer get if the plaintiff wins?
Nothing in the property. The buyer's claim is against the seller for the price, for damages and for the costs, and it is a money claim that ranks with the seller's other creditors. That is why the search, the consent and the payment structure matter more than the indemnity clause.
A lis pendens property purchase turns on a rule about notice, and the notice is a document that either exists in the register or does not. The buyer who checks both the register and the courts knows what he is buying; the buyer who checks neither is buying the lawsuit.