14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Civil Procedure

Written statement and the limitation for filing it

A defendant must file the written statement within thirty days of being served with the summons, and the court may extend that to ninety days from the date of service for reasons to be recorded. Beyond ninety days the right to file is lost in the ordinary course, though the defendant can still cross-examine the plaintiff's witnesses and argue the plaintiff's failure to prove his case.

The rule and the two periods

The Code of Civil Procedure prescribes thirty days for the written statement from the date of service of the summons on the defendant. The proviso allows the court to extend the period, but not beyond ninety days from the date of service, and the reasons for the extension must be recorded.

The periods are counted from service, not from the date of the summons or the date of appearance. Where service is substituted by publication, the date of the publication is the starting point, and the defendant who appears later must apply for permission to file.

The rule is mandatory in form, and the courts have been firm about it. The purpose is to prevent defendants from delaying the trial by filing a written statement years later, after the plaintiff's evidence has closed. A defendant who treats the ninety days as a formality will find the application refused.

What goes in the written statement

The written statement is the defendant's pleading, and it must respond to the plaint paragraph by paragraph. It should contain:

  • A specific denial or admission of each material allegation. A general denial of the entire plaint is treated as no denial of the facts that are not specifically traversed.
  • New facts that the defendant relies on, such as payment, release, limitation, or a prior agreement.
  • Any preliminary objection — jurisdiction, valuation, non-joinder of a necessary party, the suit being barred by law.
  • The defendant's own claim, where a set-off or a counterclaim is sought, set out as a separate part with the particulars the rules require.
  • The verification and the signature.

An allegation in the plaint that is not denied is treated as admitted. That is the rule that defeats defendants who file a short written statement saying the plaint is denied in its entirety.

Set-off and counterclaim

A set-off is a claim by the defendant against the plaintiff for a sum that would reduce or extinguish the plaintiff's claim, and it must be for a sum that is legally recoverable and within the court's jurisdiction. A counterclaim is a separate claim by the defendant against the plaintiff, and it is treated as a plaint for the purposes of court fee, limitation and the right of reply.

Both must be pleaded in the written statement and, for a counterclaim, the court fee must be paid. Where the counterclaim exceeds the court's pecuniary jurisdiction, the court may require the defendant to pursue it separately.

A defendant who omits a set-off or counterclaim from the written statement may be allowed to amend later, subject to the amendment rules and to limitation. It is cleaner to plead it at the outset with the documents to support it.

What the defendant can still do after ninety days

The Losing the right to file does not end the defendant's participation. Three points follow:

  1. The plaintiff must still prove his case. A defendant who has not filed a written statement can cross-examine the plaintiff's witnesses, point to the gaps in the evidence, and argue that the claim is not established.
  2. A point of law, such as want of jurisdiction or the suit being barred by limitation, can be raised at any stage, because it goes to the court's power to decide.
  3. The defendant may apply for leave to file the written statement at a later stage with an application supported by reasons, and the court has a discretion, though it is exercised narrowly and the appellate courts have deprecated its routine exercise.

So a defendant who has missed the date should not stay away. Non-appearance leads to an ex parte decree, which is far worse than participating without a written statement.

Where the defendant makes a default

Where the defendant does not appear at all despite service, the court may proceed ex parte and pass a decree. The remedy thereafter is an application to set aside the ex parte decree, which can be made to the same court on showing sufficient cause for non-appearance, or an appeal. The application to set aside is filed within the time the Code allows, and the court may impose costs and conditions.

A defendant who has appeared but not filed a written statement is not in default of appearance, and the suit proceeds on the basis that the plaint's allegations are not specifically denied, but the plaintiff still has to prove his case for the relief claimed.

Ninety days is not an opening offer. It is the whole of the time the Code gives, and it runs from the day the summons reaches you.

Filing in the Kolkata courts

In the City Civil Court at Kolkata and on the original side of the Calcutta High Court, the written statement is filed with the affidavit of documents where the rules require it, and a copy is served on the plaintiff's advocate. The case then proceeds to the framing of issues and to the admission and marking of documents. In the district courts at Alipore and Barasat the practice is the same, with local variations in the listing.

The written statement should be accompanied by the list of documents the defendant relies on, and a defendant who keeps documents back risks being refused permission to produce them later.

Common questions

Can the ninety days be extended further?

The Code does not permit it in the ordinary course, and an extension beyond ninety days requires the court to be satisfied of special circumstances, which the appellate courts have said should be rare. A defendant should assume ninety days is the outer limit.

What if the summons was never served?

Then the time has not begun to run. A defendant who learns of the suit otherwise, for instance through a newspaper publication, should appear at once and apply for the time to be reckoned from the date of actual knowledge, supported by an affidavit.

Can a written statement be amended?

Yes, with leave, on the amendment principles: the amendment should be necessary to decide the real question, should not change the nature of the defence, and should not be barred by limitation. Amendments that introduce a new defence after the plaintiff's evidence has closed are refused.

Diarise the date from service, deny each allegation specifically, and plead the set-off and the preliminary objections at the outset. Our civil litigation practice handles defences in the Kolkata courts, breach of contract covers the contractual disputes that most often produce these suits, and recovery suits covers the money claims.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Civil Procedure

The Stages of a Civil Suit in Kolkata

From the plaint and summons through issues, evidence and judgement to execution, the stages of a civil suit in a Kolkata court and what each costs in time.

Read
Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422