A second notice under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act is valid in some situations and useless in others, and the difference is limitation rather than form. If the first notice was served and the fifteen days ran out, the cause of action had already crystallised, and a second notice does not extend the month that follows. If the first notice was never served, or the cheque was presented again and dishonoured again, a fresh notice is not merely permissible but necessary.
The mechanism the section creates
The sequence in Section 138 is fixed. The cheque is presented within three months of the date it bears. The bank returns it unpaid for insufficiency of funds or because it exceeds the arrangement. The payee then has thirty days from receiving the bank's return memo to issue a demand notice. The drawer has fifteen days from receipt of that notice to pay. If he does not, a cause of action arises and a complaint must be filed within one month of it.
Every step has its own clock, and the clocks do not stop. That is why a second notice is a tactical instrument and not a reset button.
When a second notice is proper
Three situations justify one. The first is non-service. Where the first notice was sent to an address the drawer had abandoned, or was refused and the refusal is disputed, the payee may send a second notice to the correct address, and the fifteen-day period runs from service of that notice. Courts have accepted this because the statute requires a demand, and a demand that never reached the drawer cannot start the clock.
The second is a fresh dishonour. Where the cheque was presented again within its validity and was dishonoured again, a new return memo gives a new thirty-day window, a new notice and a new cause of action. Presenting a cheque twice within its three-month life is lawful, and the second dishonour is a distinct event.
The third is a defective first notice. Where the first notice did not demand payment of the cheque amount, or demanded an amount the cheque did not cover, it may fail to qualify as a notice under the section. A corrected notice then serves the statutory purpose. This is the weakest of the three grounds because courts read a notice by its substance rather than its form, and a demand for the cheque amount plus interest or charges is usually treated as a valid demand.
When it is not
Where the first notice was served, the fifteen days expired and the payee did nothing for a year, a second notice does not revive the complaint. The offence was complete on the sixteenth day, the limitation of one month began then, and a later notice cannot push the date forward. A complaint filed on the second notice will be met with an objection that it is barred by limitation, and the objection will usually succeed.
The consequence is uncomfortable. The payee still has a civil claim on the debt, which has a three-year limitation, and can sue for recovery. He has lost the criminal route, with its presumption under Section 139, its speed and its pressure. Our page on legal notice for recovery sets out how the civil route is pleaded when the cheque remedy has gone.
The one-month window and condonation
The complaint must be filed within one month of the cause of action, and the court has power to condone delay in filing. Condonation is granted on an application with an affidavit explaining the delay, and it is a discretion exercised on cause shown. Delay of a few weeks while a payee is negotiating, or while he is trying to locate the drawer, is often condoned. Delay of a year is not, and a court will ask why the statutory remedy was ignored.
Practically, the safest course is to file within the month and continue talking. A complaint on file does not stop a settlement; a settlement reached after the limitation has run does not create a complaint.
How a second notice should be drafted differently
- State the date of the first notice, how it was sent and what happened to it. A second notice that pretends the first did not exist looks like an afterthought.
- Refer to the fresh return memo if there is one, with its date and the bank's reason.
- Demand the cheque amount, and say clearly that it is the cheque amount that is demanded.
- Give the full fifteen days, calculated from the date of receipt, and say so.
- Send it by registered post with acknowledgement due, and by a courier with tracking, keeping the receipts and the tracking printout.
- Keep the returned envelope if it comes back unclaimed or refused. Endorsements on the cover are evidence of service.
Service is the battleground
Most second-notice cases are really service cases. The drawer says he never received the notice; the payee says it was sent to the address on the cheque and the envelope came back with "left" written on it. Courts have held that where a notice is sent by registered post to the correct address and is returned unclaimed, service is presumed. Where it is returned with a report that the addressee refused, service is also presumed. The form of the demand is dealt with on our legal notice drafting page.
What defeats the presumption is a wrong address, or an address the payee knew was no longer current. If the payee has the drawer's email, mobile number and a copy of his election card showing a different residence, sending the notice only to an old shop address invites the objection that service was never effected. A second notice to the current address, with the earlier attempt on record, is then the better course.
Where the complaint is filed
Under Section 142 of the Act, the complaint is filed where the branch of the bank at which the payee maintains the account is situated. For a payee banking in Kolkata, that means a complaint before the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate at Bankshall, or before the appropriate magistrate in the district, even where the drawer's bank and the drawer himself are elsewhere. This is one of the few places in criminal procedure where the complainant's convenience is written into the statute. Once the complaint is numbered, the trial runs as described under cheque bounce.
Second notice and the security cheque
Where the cheque was given as security rather than in discharge of a debt, the drawer argues that no debt was due when it was issued. That argument does not answer a notice sent after the liability crystallised, because the cheque's character as security does not remove it from the section once the underlying obligation is due and the cheque is presented in terms of the arrangement. The pleadings should state when the liability arose, not merely when the cheque was signed.
Common questions
Can I send a second notice if the first was sent to the wrong address?
Yes, and you should. Send it to the address on the cheque and to any current address you have, keep the proof of the earlier attempt, and calculate the fifteen days from the second service. A court will want to know why the first address was wrong.
Does a second notice restart the thirty days?
Only if there is a fresh dishonour. The thirty days run from receipt of the bank's return memo, and a re-presentment produces a new memo. Without a re-presentment, there is nothing for the thirty days to run from.
What if the drawer replies to the second notice denying the debt?
A denial does not stop the complaint. It is a defence to be proved, and the statutory presumption under Section 139 places the burden on the drawer to show that the cheque was not issued for a debt. The reply should be annexed to the complaint as part of the record.
Is the notice valid if it is sent by email or WhatsApp?
The statute requires a notice in writing, and courts have accepted service by email where the receipt is proved. Registered post remains the safer course, and a notice sent by both post and email is stronger than either alone.
The second notice is worth sending when service failed or the cheque bounced again, and worth avoiding when the first notice did its work. Before drafting one, draw the dates on a page: cheque date, presentation, return memo, notice, service, sixteenth day, one month. The page will tell you whether you are reviving a claim or burying it.