Section 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act puts the burden on the drawer. Once the complainant proves the cheque, its signature, its presentation and its dishonour, the court presumes that the cheque was received for the discharge of a debt or liability. The drawer must then prove the contrary. Section 147 is a different provision altogether: it makes the offence compoundable, so that a settlement ends the prosecution.
The presumption, stated precisely
The section says that it shall be presumed, unless the contrary is proved, that the holder of a cheque received it for the discharge, in whole or in part, of any debt or other liability. It is a presumption of law, mandatory in form, and it operates once the foundational facts are established.
Those foundational facts are narrow. The complainant must show that the cheque was drawn by the accused, that it was presented within its validity, that it was returned unpaid, and that the statutory notice was served and the fifteen days elapsed. Nothing else is required to raise the presumption, and in particular the complainant does not have to prove the underlying transaction in his opening evidence.
This is why cheque cases are tried in the order they are. The complainant's evidence is short and largely documentary. The burden then shifts, and the drawer's evidence carries the weight of the trial.
The other presumptions that help the complainant
Section 139 does not stand alone. Section 118 of the Act raises presumptions about consideration, about the date, and about the order of endorsement, until the contrary is proved. Section 20 deals with instruments signed and delivered blank, and Section 87 with the effect of material alteration.
Taken together, the complainant's case is constructed from presumptions and a small number of documents. That is a deliberate design: a cheque is a negotiable instrument, and commerce depends on the holder being able to rely on it without proving the whole history behind it.
The design has a limit. A presumption is not evidence, and it cannot survive a demolition of the transaction on which it rests. If the drawer shows that the complainant's own account of how the money moved is false, the presumption is displaced even without the drawer proving an alternative story in full.
What the drawer has to do
The standard is "unless the contrary is proved", which the courts have read as proof on a preponderance of probabilities, not beyond reasonable doubt. But the drawer cannot discharge it by assertion. What works, in roughly descending order of strength:
- Documents that contradict the claimed transaction — an agreement, a receipt, a bank statement, a tax return.
- Admissions by the complainant in cross-examination, particularly about the absence of any record of the advance.
- Evidence that the cheque was not issued by the drawer, or was materially altered.
- Evidence that the cheque was issued for a purpose that created no liability, as in a security cheque for a contingency that never happened.
- Evidence that the debt was discharged before presentation.
What fails: a bare denial in the reply to the notice, a claim that the cheque was lost without a police complaint, and a general allegation that the complainant is a money-lender without any material to support it.
Section 147: compounding
Section 147 declares that every offence punishable under the Act is compoundable. That means the complainant and the drawer may settle, and the court may record the composition and close the case. Compounding is not the same as a civil settlement: it ends the criminal proceeding, and it is available at any stage, including after conviction and before the appeal is decided.
In practice, compounding is how most cheque cases end. The drawer pays, the complainant files a compounding petition or a joint compromise memo, and the court records it. The court will usually want the terms in writing and may want the payment to be made before it records the composition, rather than after.
A compromise recorded by a Lok Adalat has an additional effect, because the award of the Lok Adalat is treated as a decree of a civil court and is final. That route is dealt with separately on this site.
Where the two provisions meet
They meet at the point of settlement. A drawer who accepts that the presumption will be hard to rebut may choose to compound rather than fight. A complainant whose documents are weak may choose to compound rather than risk dismissal. The presumption shapes the negotiating position on both sides, and the compounding provision gives that position a way to be realised without a judgement.
There is a third possibility that complainants should know. Even after the criminal case is compounded, the civil claim on the debt is not automatically extinguished unless the compromise says so. A compromise that recites full and final settlement of all claims does extinguish it; a compromise that recites only the criminal proceeding does not.
The Kolkata courts
Section 138 complaints in Kolkata are tried by the Magistrates, with the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate's court at Bankshall handling a large share of the city's commercial cheque litigation. Appeals go to the City Sessions Court and then to the Calcutta High Court. Compounding petitions are heard by the same Magistrate who is trying the case, and the terms are recorded in the order sheet.
The civil side runs separately in the City Civil Court, or on the original side of the Calcutta High Court for higher-value claims.
Common questions
Does the presumption apply if the cheque was not signed by the accused?
No. The foundational fact is that the cheque was drawn by the accused. If the signature is denied and the denial is supported by expert evidence, the presumption never arises, and the complainant is left to prove the signature as a fact.
Can the drawer rely on the absence of a written agreement?
He can rely on it as part of the picture. Oral transactions are recognised, and the absence of writing is not fatal to the complainant. But where the claimed amount is large and the complainant is a business, the absence of any record is powerful support for the defence.
Is compounding available after conviction?
Yes. The Act permits composition at any stage, and appellate courts routinely record compositions and set aside convictions on that basis. The complainant's consent is required.
If you are prosecuting, your file should be built to trigger the presumption cleanly and to survive the drawer's rebuttal attempt. If you are defending, the reply to the notice is the first place the rebuttal is built. Our cheque bounce practice covers both, legal notice drafting covers the demand, and recovery suits is the civil route if the criminal one is compounded or lost.