The notice under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act is the step that converts a bounced cheque into a prosecutable offence, and it has three deadlines attached to it. It must be sent within thirty days of receiving the bank's return memo, it must give the drawer fifteen days to pay, and the complaint must then be filed within one month. Miss any of the three and the criminal remedy is gone, though the debt survives.
What the notice must demand
The statute requires a demand for payment of the cheque amount. Not the amount plus interest, not the amount plus costs, and not a sum the payee calculates from the underlying account. Courts read the notice by its substance, and a demand that includes the cheque amount and asks for interest or charges in addition is generally treated as a valid demand, provided the cheque amount is clearly stated and clearly demanded.
Where the notice demands a figure larger than the cheque on the footing that the parties agreed interest, the danger is that the drawer pays the cheque amount within fifteen days and the payee refuses it. That refusal destroys the cause of action. The safer course is a demand for the cheque amount, with a reservation that the payee will claim interest and costs separately.
The essentials of a good notice
- The date, and the fact that it is issued under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
- The cheque number, date, amount and the bank and branch on which it was drawn.
- The date of presentation and the date of the bank's return memo, with the reason stated on it.
- A clear statement of the debt or liability for which the cheque was issued, with dates.
- A demand that the cheque amount be paid within fifteen days of receipt of the notice.
- A statement that failing payment, the payee will file a criminal complaint.
- The address to which payment should be made, and the mode.
Two further points of drafting. The notice should be addressed to the drawer at the address on the cheque and at any other address the payee knows, because service is the weak link in most prosecutions. And it should be signed by the payee or a person authorised by him, with the authority recorded where the payee is a company.
Service, and how it is proved
The statute requires the notice to be given within thirty days of the receipt of the return memo, and gives the drawer fifteen days from receipt of the notice. Service is therefore the fact on which everything hangs.
Send by registered post with acknowledgement due. Send a copy by a courier that provides tracking, and keep the tracking printout. Where the payee has the drawer's email or mobile number, send a copy that way too. The postal receipt, the acknowledgement card if it comes back signed, the returned envelope with its endorsement, and the courier's delivery report are the documents that prove service.
Where the envelope comes back with "refused" written on it, courts presume service. Where it comes back "unclaimed", the presumption also usually applies, because the drawer had notice of the proceedings and did not collect the letter. Where it comes back "left" or "no such person", the position is weaker and the payee should send again to a correct address and keep both sets of documents.
Affidavit evidence of the despatch is normal. The person who posted the letter can depose to it, and the postal receipt is exhibited.
The fifteen days, counted properly
The fifteen days run from the date of receipt of the notice, not from the date of posting. Where service is by registered post and the acknowledgement is signed, the date on the card is the date of receipt. Where service is presumed because the letter was refused, the courts calculate from the date of the postal endorsement.
During those fifteen days the drawer can pay and end the matter. Part payment does not. A drawer who pays a portion and promises the rest has not complied with the demand, and the offence is complete when the fifteen days expire without full payment.
The payee must be careful about accepting a late payment. If the drawer pays in full after the fifteen days but before the complaint is filed, the payee can still file, but the court will treat the payment as mitigation and the case will usually be compounded at once. If the payee accepts the payment and tells the drawer the matter is closed, there is no offence to prosecute.
The one-month window for the complaint
The cause of action arises on the sixteenth day after receipt, and the complaint must be filed within one month of it. The court has power to condone delay, on an application supported by an affidavit. Condonation is granted where the delay is explained and short; it is refused where the payee simply sat on the file.
The complaint is filed before the magistrate having jurisdiction over the place where the payee's bank branch is situated. For a payee banking in central Kolkata, that is the court of the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate at Bankshall. A payee banking in Salt Lake or Behala will file in the court that covers that branch. This rule is a statutory exception to the ordinary place-of-offence rule and it is one of the few advantages the statute gives a payee. The trial itself is described under criminal law.
Where the notice is defective, and what can be cured
A notice that does not demand the cheque amount is defective and cannot be cured by a later complaint that does. A notice sent beyond thirty days of the return memo is out of time, and a fresh notice will not help unless a fresh dishonour occurs. A notice sent to the wrong address is a service problem rather than a defect in the notice, and it can be cured by a second notice to the right address.
A notice that omits the fifteen-day period altogether is the most serious defect, because the drawer was never given the statutory opportunity to pay. A notice that gives fewer than fifteen days is treated in the same way by most courts.
Where the defect is curable, cure it before filing. Where it is not, the payee should consider whether the civil route is better than a prosecution that will be dismissed. Our page on legal notice drafting sets out the format that Kolkata courts expect, and our note on cheque bounce covers the complaint that follows.
The reply the drawer usually sends
Most drawers reply through an advocate, denying the debt, alleging that the cheque was given as security, or asserting that the amount was already paid. The reply is useful to the payee, because it fixes the drawer's position and any later change of story can be contrasted with it. It should be annexed to the complaint. Where the reply admits the debt and seeks time, a written acknowledgment obtained through our recovery notice service protects the civil claim.
A reply that admits the cheque and asks for time is better still. It is an acknowledgement for the purposes of the civil claim and it undermines any defence that the cheque was not issued for a debt.
Common questions
Can the notice be sent by email only?
The statute requires a notice in writing, and courts have accepted email service where delivery is proved. Email alone is risky. Send by registered post and add email as an additional mode.
Does the notice have to be sent by an advocate?
No. The payee can send it himself. A notice on an advocate's letterhead carries more weight and reduces the risk of drafting errors, but it is not a requirement of the section.
What if the drawer dies before the notice is served?
The criminal proceedings do not survive against the legal representatives, because the offence is personal. The civil claim on the debt does survive, and the payee should move to a suit against the estate.
Can one notice cover several cheques?
Yes, provided each cheque, its date, its amount and its return memo are separately stated, and the total demanded equals the sum of the cheques. A consolidated demand that does not identify the cheques individually invites an objection.
The notice is a one-page document that decides the value of the next two years. Draft it with the return memo in front of you, send it by two modes, keep every receipt, and diarise the sixteenth day. Nothing in a cheque case is harder to recover than a lost fifteen-day window.