A client who believes his advocate handled a matter badly cannot take that grievance to a consumer commission. The Supreme Court has held that the services of an advocate, engaged in the practice of law, are not "service" for the purposes of the Consumer Protection Act, because the engagement rests on a contract of personal service and the relationship is professional rather than commercial. The remedy lies elsewhere, and it is worth knowing precisely where.
Why the consumer route was argued at all
The argument was straightforward. A client pays fees, the advocate provides a service, and if the service is deficient the client has suffered. On that reasoning, several consumer commissions entertained complaints against advocates for missing a limitation date, failing to appear, or settling a matter without instructions.
The difficulty is the definition. The Act excludes services rendered under a contract of personal service from the definition of "service", and it has always been understood that the professions sit differently from trades. A patient does not buy a cure; a client does not buy a result. The advocate is engaged for his judgement, and judgement cannot be priced as a product with a warranty attached.
What the Supreme Court settled
The Court examined the history of the consumer law, the definition of service, and the nature of the legal profession, and concluded that advocates are not covered. The reasoning rests on three points. The legal profession is a profession and not a trade or business. The relationship between advocate and client is one of personal service founded on trust. And the Act's own exclusion of contracts of personal service was intended to keep professional engagements outside the consumer forum.
The consequence is practical rather than theoretical. A complaint against an advocate before a District Commission is not maintainable, and it will be dismissed at the admission stage. Time spent in that forum is time lost from the remedy that does exist. Where the grievance is against a service of another kind, the commission remains open, as our consumer protection page explains.
The three remedies that remain
The first is a civil suit for damages for professional negligence. The forum is the City Civil Court in Kolkata, or the original side of the Calcutta High Court where the value exceeds the court's pecuniary limit. The claim is that the advocate failed to exercise the skill and care that an ordinarily competent advocate would have exercised in the same circumstances.
The second is a complaint to the Bar Council of West Bengal, which has disciplinary jurisdiction over advocates on its rolls under the Advocates Act, 1961. A finding of professional misconduct can lead to reprimand, suspension or removal from the roll. What the Bar Council does not do is award compensation to the client.
The third is a complaint to the disciplinary committee where the advocate is a member of a bar association with its own rules, though that is a weaker instrument and rarely produces a remedy for the client.
For most clients the civil suit is the only route that produces money, and it is the route least often taken, because it requires the client to litigate against a member of the same profession. It is pleaded in the manner set out under civil litigation.
What counts as negligence in this context
The standard is not perfection. An advocate is not liable for a wrong opinion on a difficult question of law, or for a strategy that failed in a case that could have gone either way. He is liable where he departed from the ordinary standard of competence: a limitation date missed, an appeal not filed within time, a plaint not presented at all, a hearing missed without a vakalatnama on record, a settlement entered into without authority.
The distinction is sometimes put as an error of judgement against an error of professional skill. Courts have been slow to hold advocates liable for judgement, and quicker where the failure is administrative and obvious. A missed limitation is the clearest case, because it requires no judgement at all, only a diary.
Proving it needs the court record. The certified copy of the order sheet, the cause list entry, the date of the impugned order and the date on which the appeal was presented are the documents that establish the failure without much argument. Our page on legal notice drafting notes the parallel situation where a defective notice costs a client a case.
The damages question
The loss claimed is the loss of the chance. Where a suit was dismissed for default through the advocate's failure, the client's loss is not the whole claim but the value of the chance that the suit would have succeeded, discounted for the risk that it might not have. Courts assess that with the underlying case's merits in view, which means the client has to prove the case he says he lost.
Costs thrown away, fees paid, and any additional expense caused by the failure are recoverable as special damages with receipts. Interest may be awarded from the date of the loss.
A claim that the advocate should have won a case that was always weak will fail, and it will fail after the client has spent more on the second case than the first. That is the reason these claims are rare and should be assessed honestly before they are filed.
Where an advocate is doing something other than law
The exclusion is for legal services. An advocate who runs a separate business, provides a title search as a commercial service with a fixed fee and a written report, or sells a product, is not sheltered by the profession for that activity. The consumer forum may well have jurisdiction over the commercial part.
The line is drawn by the character of the service, not the qualification of the person. A chartered accountant certifying a return, a surveyor valuing a property, a doctor treating a patient: each raises the same question, and the consumer law has answered it differently in different contexts. What matters for an advocate is that the practice of law itself is outside.
What a client should do before suing
- Obtain the complete court record of the matter: the plaint or petition, the order sheet, and every order passed.
- Obtain the advocate's file, or a copy, by written request. If it is refused, apply to the court for the record.
- Write down the dates on which instructions were given, the fees paid, and the receipt for each payment.
- Get a written opinion from another advocate on whether the original case had merit.
- Decide between the civil suit and the Bar Council complaint, and note that the two need not be exclusive.
Where the matter is still live, the first priority is to save it: a fresh application, a condonation petition, or a restoration application may still be available, and it should be filed before any claim against the previous advocate is considered. A client who wins back the case has nothing to sue for.
Common questions
Can a complaint be filed against an advocate before a consumer commission anywhere in India?
No. The position settled by the Supreme Court applies across the country, and a commission that admits such a complaint acts without jurisdiction. The complaint will be rejected, and the client will have lost the filing fee and the time.
Does the Bar Council award compensation?
No. It decides whether professional misconduct is proved and imposes a disciplinary consequence on the advocate. A client who wants money has to sue.
What is the limitation for a suit against an advocate?
Three years from the date the client knew of the loss, which is usually the date of the order that went wrong. The clock is not extended by the client's attempts to reason with the advocate.
Can an advocate be sued for a fee dispute?
The fee itself is a contract matter and can be sued on either side. A client who withholds fees for poor service and an advocate who sues for fees will usually find both claims decided in the same suit, on the same evidence.
The consumer forum was never the right place for this grievance, and the Supreme Court has now said so. A client whose case was damaged by his advocate has a real remedy, but it is a civil suit with a real evidentiary burden, and it should be brought only where the failure is plain.