14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

Agricultural land and the non-agriculturist buyer

Agricultural land in West Bengal cannot be bought freely by a person who does not cultivate land, and the restriction is enforced at the registration office as much as in the revenue office. Agricultural land purchase non agriculturist files fail for two reasons: the buyer did not obtain the Collector's permission, or the land was already converted to non-agricultural use in the record and the buyer paid for a plot that is still agricultural in the khatian.

The precise provision and the current form of the permission should be checked with the Block Land and Land Reforms Officer for the block, because the restriction has been amended and the practice varies with the district. What does not vary is the consequence: a transfer that breaches the restriction is open to challenge, and the mutation will not be recorded.

Who is an agriculturist

An agriculturist is a person who cultivates land personally, by his own labour or by the labour of his family, or by hired labour under his supervision. A company, a partnership firm, a trust and a society are not agriculturists, and a salaried professional who has never cultivated land is not one either.

A person who owns agricultural land but leases it out is in a weaker position than one who cultivates, and a person whose only connection with land is an investment is not an agriculturist. The revenue office decides the question on the applicant's own record, and a certificate from the local office is the usual evidence.

Why the restriction exists

The restriction is part of the land reforms scheme. It keeps agricultural land with those who farm it, it prevents the consolidation of holdings by investors, and it protects the ceiling provisions from being defeated by transfers to persons who would hold beyond the limit. The same policy underlies the bargadar's protection and the ceiling on holdings.

The restriction is not a total bar. Transfers by inheritance, by will, by operation of law, to a co-sharer, and transfers of land that has been converted to non-agricultural use are outside it or are permitted on conditions. The classification in the record is therefore the first thing to check: a plot shown as non-agricultural is not agricultural land for this purpose, even if it is lying vacant.

The permission, and the application

Where permission is required, the application goes to the Collector through the BL&LRO, with the plot particulars, the proposed deed, the purpose of the purchase, the applicant's own landholding, and an affidavit that the purchase will not take the holding beyond the ceiling. The office reports on the applicant and on the land, and the order either permits the transfer on conditions or refuses it.

Conditions commonly imposed include a limit on the area, a requirement that the land be used for the stated purpose, and a bar on further transfer for a period. A permission granted for a specific purpose does not authorise a different use, and a transfer in breach of the conditions can be set aside.

The permission should be obtained before the deed is executed, because the sub-registrar may refuse to accept a deed for agricultural land in favour of a non-agriculturist without it. Where the deed is registered and the permission is refused later, the buyer holds a deed that the revenue office will not act on.

The consequences of buying without permission

The mutation will be refused, and the record will continue to show the seller. A buyer in possession without a recorded transfer has a possession that is difficult to defend and a title that cannot be sold to anyone who does a search.

The transfer is open to challenge by the state and, in an appropriate case, by a person whose right is affected. The land may also attract the ceiling provisions, and a holding that exceeds the ceiling is liable to vest.

A resale by the buyer to an agriculturist does not automatically cure the original defect. It may, if the state has not taken action and the record can be regularised, but the file will always show the transaction that should not have happened.

Buying for a house: the correct sequence

Where the buyer's object is to build, the sequence is conversion first, then purchase. The seller applies for the conversion, the Collector passes the order, the record is corrected to non-agricultural, and the sale then takes place as a transfer of non-agricultural land, which is not affected by the restriction.

Where the buyer purchases first and converts later, the purchase is a transfer of agricultural land to a non-agriculturist, and it needs the permission. The conversion afterwards does not retrospectively validate the purchase, although in practice the office may regularise the position if the conversion follows quickly and the buyer's holding is within the ceiling.

Where the plot is within a municipal area or a planning area and is shown as agricultural in the record, the same analysis applies: the municipal classification does not change the revenue classification, and both have to be addressed.

What goes wrong

The first failure is a buyer who relies on the seller's assurance that the land is already converted. The khatian shows the classification, and it takes two minutes to check.

The second is a purchase in the name of a relative who is an agriculturist, to get around the restriction. That is a benami arrangement, and it is vulnerable to both the revenue authorities and the benami law.

The third is a purchase of a plot that is partly agricultural and partly homestead, with the deed describing the whole as homestead. The office reads the record, not the deed.

Can a company buy agricultural land in West Bengal?

Not without the permission, and a company is not an agriculturist. A company that wants land for a project should buy non-agricultural land, or obtain the conversion before the purchase, and should take advice on the ceiling provisions before committing to an area.

Does inheritance require permission?

Succession is not a purchase, and a heir who takes agricultural land by inheritance does not need the Collector's permission. The ceiling, however, applies to the holding that results, and a large inheritance may attract the ceiling provisions.

What happens if permission is refused?

The transfer should not proceed. Where it has already proceeded, the mutation will be refused and the buyer's remedy is against the seller for the purchase price, on the basis that the seller could not convey what he contracted to convey.

Can an NRI buy agricultural land?

The foreign exchange regulations restrict the purchase of agricultural land, plantation property and farm houses by a person resident outside India, and the revenue restriction applies on top of that. The two sets of rules should be checked before any commitment.

The classification in the record, not the broker's description, decides whether the restriction applies. Our title practice checks the classification and the ceiling position, registration handles the conversion, the permission and the deed, and the property team advises on the transaction's structure. Begin at our contact page.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422