An unregistered sale deed does not transfer ownership of immovable property worth more than a hundred rupees. Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 requires a sale of tangible immovable property of that value to be made by a registered instrument, and section 17 of the Registration Act, 1908 makes registration compulsory. What the unregistered deed does give the buyer is evidence of a contract, and with it the right to sue for specific performance — which is a remedy, not a title.
The practical consequences of an unregistered sale deed are worth stating plainly, because a great many transactions in and around Kolkata are completed on stamp paper with a notary's seal and the parties believe the sale is done.
What the unregistered deed is, in law
It is a contract to sell, in the eyes of the law, whatever its heading. It records the terms, the price and the intention, and it may be stamped and notarised, but it does not convey. The buyer who paid the price and took possession holds under a contract, not as owner.
Section 49 of the Registration Act, with its proviso, allows an unregistered document affecting immovable property to be received in evidence of a contract in a suit for specific performance, or as evidence of part performance of a contract under section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act. That is the doorway through which an unregistered deed becomes useful: it proves the contract, not the conveyance.
The risks, in order of seriousness
The first risk is a second sale. The seller who has taken the buyer's money can execute a registered deed in favour of another purchaser, and the registered purchaser prevails. The buyer with the unregistered deed is left to sue the seller for his money and for damages, and the property is gone.
The second is succession. If the seller dies, the property devolves on his heirs, and the buyer's contract is a claim against the estate rather than a right in the land. The heirs are not bound to complete the sale unless the contract binds them, and litigation against a set of heirs is slower and more expensive than against one seller.
The third is a mortgage or a charge created by the seller after the unregistered sale. The bank's security is over the property, and the buyer's possession does not defeat it.
The fourth is mutation. The Block Land and Land Reforms Officer will not record a transfer on an unregistered deed, and the record stays in the seller's name, which is the document that a later purchaser, a bank or an acquisition authority will read.
Part performance under section 53A
Where the buyer has taken possession in part performance of the contract, has performed his part, and is willing to perform the rest, section 53A protects his possession against the seller and against anyone claiming under the seller, other than a transferee for consideration without notice. The protection is a defence to possession; it is not a title, and it does not enable the buyer to sell or mortgage the property.
Section 53A requires a written contract signed by the seller or on his behalf, and it requires the buyer's possession to be in part performance of that contract rather than under a separate arrangement. A buyer who paid cash against a plain paper and took possession has a weak case, because the writing must show the terms.
Specific performance, and the decree
A suit for specific performance of the contract lies before the City Civil Court at Kolkata, or the district court at Alipore or Barasat, and it must be brought within three years of the date fixed for performance, or of the date the plaintiff had notice that performance was refused. The court can decree specific performance, or award damages in lieu, and the discretion is exercised on the conduct of the parties.
The decree for specific performance is a decree that directs the execution of a sale deed. It must itself be registered when it is presented, and the buyer then becomes the owner. Until the deed is executed and registered, the decree gives the buyer a right to compel, not a title.
Where the seller has already sold to a third party who has registered and paid, specific performance may be refused because the seller cannot perform, and the buyer's remedy becomes damages. That is the outcome the registration requirement exists to avoid.
Can an old unregistered deed be registered now?
Section 23 of the Registration Act requires a document to be presented for registration within four months of its execution. Section 25 allows the registrar to accept a document presented after that period, up to a further four months, on payment of a fine, and section 34 and the following sections deal with the enquiry. Beyond that window, the document cannot be registered on its own.
The alternative is a decree. A suit for specific performance, or a suit for a declaration that the sale is complete, produces a decree that can be registered, and the decree is the route that many old transactions eventually take. A deed executed twenty years ago cannot be registered today simply by paying a penalty.
Where both parties are still alive and willing, the simplest cure is a fresh registered sale deed, executed now, reciting the earlier transaction and the payment already made. That requires the seller's cooperation, and it is worth paying for a proper deed rather than litigating for a decree.
Possession, tenancy and the police
A buyer in possession under an unregistered deed is not a trespasser, and he cannot be thrown out by the seller without a court order. The police will treat a possession dispute as a civil matter, and the buyer's remedy against dispossession is a suit for injunction, or for restoration of possession under section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 within six months of dispossession.
Where the buyer has let the property to a tenant, the tenancy is valid as between the buyer and the tenant, but the seller remains the recorded owner and can create difficulties in the municipal record and in the mutation.
Is a notarised sale deed valid?
No, not as a transfer. Notarisation is an authentication of signatures, not registration, and it does not convey title. A notarised sale deed is evidence of a contract at best, and the property remains with the seller on the record.
Can I get mutation on an unregistered deed?
No. The revenue office requires a registered instrument or a decree. An application on an unregistered deed will be returned, and the record will continue to show the seller.
What if the seller refuses to register after taking the money?
File a suit for specific performance within the limitation period, and apply for an injunction restraining the seller from transferring the property to anyone else. The injunction is what preserves the asset while the suit is pending.
Does an unregistered agreement to sell create any right?
It creates a contractual right, and it can support an injunction and a suit for specific performance. It does not create an interest in the land, and it does not bind a bona fide purchaser for value without notice.
The lesson of these files is consistent: registration is not a step in a sale, it is the sale. Our registration practice handles deeds and the cures available for defective ones, and the specific performance practice runs the suits where the seller has resiled. Title questions are dealt with by the title team, and the first step is a consultation.