An appeal from a decree of a subordinate court to the Calcutta High Court must be filed within ninety days of the decree, and the period starts from the day the decree is passed and not from the day the appellant read the judgment. The memorandum of appeal has to be accompanied by the certified copy of the judgment, which means the copying application should be made the day the judgment is delivered.
The ninety days and how it is calculated
The Limitation Act fixes ninety days for an appeal from a decree or order of a court other than a High Court to the High Court, and thirty days for an appeal from a decree or order of a High Court to the same court. The time runs from the date of the decree or order, not from the date of the judgment, though in practice they are usually the same day or a few days apart.
Two exclusions help the appellant. The time taken to obtain a certified copy of the decree and the judgment is excluded, which is why the copying application should be made immediately. And time during which the appellant was prosecuting a remedy in another forum in good faith may be excluded, in limited circumstances.
Beyond that, an appeal filed late needs an application for condonation of delay under the Limitation Act, with an affidavit setting out the reasons day by day. Condonation is discretionary, and the Supreme Court has repeatedly said that a liberal approach is appropriate where the delay is explained and the case has merit, and that a court should not dismiss a meritorious appeal on a technicality without examining the explanation. It is still better not to need the application.
Who can appeal, and on what
A first appeal lies from a decree in an original suit to the court authorised to hear it, and it can be on a question of fact, of law, or of mixed fact and law. A second appeal lies to the High Court from an appellate decree and can be entertained only on a substantial question of law, which the Court is required to formulate and state in the judgment.
An appeal from an order, as distinct from a decree, lies where the Code of Civil Procedure permits it. Orders that are appealable and orders that are not are listed in the Code, and an order that is not appealable is challenged by a revision or by a writ petition in an appropriate case.
The distinction between a decree and an order decides both the limitation and the form of the appeal, and it is worth settling before drafting, because an appeal filed as a first appeal from an order that was not a decree will be returned.
The memorandum of appeal
The memorandum must set out the grounds of objection to the decree under distinct heads, stated concisely and without argument or narrative. It must be accompanied by the certified copy of the judgment, and it must be signed and verified by the appellant or his advocate. Where the decree appealed from is not the final decree in the suit, the memorandum must state the reason for appealing before the suit has been disposed of.
The grounds are where an appeal is won or lost on paper. A ground that says only "the learned Judge erred in law" tells the Court nothing and helps nobody. A ground that says "the learned Judge erred in holding that Exhibit B, an unregistered agreement, created a lease, notwithstanding the registration requirement in the Transfer of Property Act" identifies the finding, the document and the provision.
The memorandum should be prepared from the judgment, paragraph by paragraph, with the findings numbered against the grounds. Where a finding was not challenged in the memorandum, the appellate court will not normally permit it to be argued later, so leave to urge additional grounds should be sought when the need arises.
Court fee, paper book and the papers filed
The appeal carries an ad valorem court fee on the value of the subject matter, under the West Bengal court fees law, and the memorandum is defective without it. Along with the memorandum, the appellant files the certified copy of the judgment and decree, the certified copy of the pleadings and the material exhibits, the depositions if the appeal raises questions of fact, and a certified copy of the order sheet. Where the underlying suit was one for specific relief, the appellate grounds track the points described under specific performance.
On admission, the appellate side of the Calcutta High Court requires a paper book of the record, and the parties are given time to prepare it. Appeals from the districts are heard on the appellate side, and the Court's rules deal with the filing of the paper book and the index. A case is listed for hearing under the rule that allows a summary dismissal where the appeal has no merit after a perusal of the memorandum.
Where the appellant has strong grounds, the admission stage usually passes with a notice to the respondent and an order on the stay application. Where the grounds are weak or the appeal is filed to delay, the Court can dismiss it at that stage after hearing the appellant.
Stay of execution
The filing of an appeal does not, by itself, stay the execution of the decree. The appellant must apply for a stay, and the court's discretion is exercised with reference to whether the appellant has made out a substantial loss that cannot be repaired, and whether the decree-holder is protected. Where the decree is for money, the usual order requires the appellant to deposit the decretal amount or furnish security, and the money is then held pending the appeal.
An application for stay is heard with the appeal's admission, and the appellant should be ready with an affidavit setting out the assets and the proposal for security. A stay application filed as an afterthought, after the decree-holder has attached something, is much weaker.
Our page on civil litigation sets out how the execution stage is defended when a stay is refused.
Cross-objections and the respondent's position
A respondent who wants to challenge part of the decree in his favour must file a cross-objection within one month of the date of service of the notice of admission of the appeal. A respondent who does not file one, and who succeeds in the appeal on a point decided against him below, risks the appellate court's refusal to grant him relief on that point.
The cross-objection is filed in the same appeal and does not need a separate court fee on the full value. Respondents frequently forget it, and then find that the decree in their favour on the counterclaim cannot be supported.
Where appeals are filed and heard
Appeals from the City Civil Court at Kolkata, from the district courts at Barasat and Alipore, and from other subordinate civil courts in West Bengal are filed on the appellate side of the Calcutta High Court. The filing counter is at the Court's premises in Kolkata, and the ancillary departments, including the copying department and the stamp reporter, decide the defects that must be cured before the appeal is numbered. For first-instance work in North 24 Parganas, see our Barasat page.
The stamp reporter's report is the first hurdle. A defect that is not cured within the time allowed leads to the appeal being listed for dismissal, and the appellant's advocate should attend to the report within days rather than weeks.
Common questions
Can an appeal be filed without the certified copy of the judgment?
No, the memorandum must be accompanied by it, and the rules provide for the return of a memorandum filed without it. The copying application should be made on the day of the judgment.
Does the appeal stay the decree automatically?
No. A separate application for stay is required, and it is heard with the admission of the appeal. Until a stay is granted, the decree-holder can proceed with execution.
What is the difference between a first appeal and a second appeal?
A first appeal can raise questions of fact and law. A second appeal from an appellate decree lies only on a substantial question of law, and the Court will not re-appreciate evidence unless the findings are perverse or unsupported by any evidence.
Can new evidence be produced in the High Court?
Order 41 of the Code allows an application to produce additional evidence where the lower court refused to admit evidence that ought to have been admitted, or where the evidence is material and could not have been produced earlier. Such applications are granted sparingly.
The appeal is won on the memorandum and lost on the calendar. Grounds drawn from the judgment paragraph by paragraph, a copying application made on the day of the decree and a stay application ready with security are the difference between an appeal that is heard and an appeal that is dismissed for a defect that could have been cured in a week.