A civil suit follows a fixed sequence: the plaint, the service of summons, the written statement, the framing of issues, the evidence, the arguments, the judgement and the decree, and then execution. The sequence is in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, and it is the same in the City Civil Court at Kolkata, in the district court at Alipore or Barasat, and on the original side of the Calcutta High Court. What differs is the pace, and the pace is what clients most want to know.
Institution of the suit
The plaintiff files the plaint with the court having jurisdiction, pays the court fee under the state court-fees law, and satisfies the court on the valuation. The plaint must state the facts, the cause of action, the jurisdiction, the valuation and the relief claimed, and it must be verified. Along with it come the documents on which the plaintiff relies and an application for interim relief where one is required.
The court's office scrutinises the plaint and may return it for a defect, such as a missing verification, a wrong valuation or a short court fee. Section 149 allows time to make up the deficiency in court fee, and Order 7 Rule 11 allows rejection of the plaint on grounds such as the absence of a cause of action.
Before filing, a plaintiff should consider a caveat in the court where an application against him is expected, and a defendant who expects a suit should consider filing one as well. Notice before suit is required only where a statute requires it or where the contract provides for it; in a money claim the demand notice is a practical necessity rather than a legal one.
Service of summons and appearance
The court issues summons to the defendant after the suit is registered. Service may be by personal delivery, by registered post with acknowledgement due, by courier, or by email where the court permits, and substituted service by publication is available where the defendant cannot be found or is avoiding service. The method matters at the end of the case: an ex parte decree resting on defective service can be set aside years later.
The defendant appears, files a vakalatnama, and files a written statement. Order 8 requires the written statement within thirty days of the service of summons, and the court may extend that period for reasons recorded in writing. The provision is treated as mandatory, and a written statement filed very late requires the court's permission.
In the written statement the defendant must deal specifically with each allegation, and a failure to deny amounts to an admission in many cases. The defendant may also raise a set-off, a counterclaim or a plea of limitation, and any of these changes the shape of the trial.
Issues, and the end of the early stage
Once the pleadings are complete, the court frames the issues under Order 14: the points on which the parties are at variance and which the court has to decide. Issues of fact and issues of law are framed separately, and an issue of law that can dispose of the suit is tried first. The framing of issues is the point at which the case is fixed, and amendments afterwards are permitted on the terms the court imposes.
Where the defendant does not appear, the court proceeds ex parte. Where the plaintiff does not appear, the suit may be dismissed, though the plaintiff may apply for restoration. Where both parties seek time repeatedly, the court may fix a deadline and dismiss the suit for default, and the dismissal may be with or without liberty to sue afresh depending on the terms.
Evidence
Evidence begins with the plaintiff's witnesses, examined in chief, cross-examined and re-examined. On the original side of the Calcutta High Court, and increasingly elsewhere, examination in chief is by affidavit, and the witness adopts the affidavit and is then cross-examined. Documents are proved by the person who made them or by a person who can speak to their custody, and they are marked as exhibits.
The plaintiff must prove the documents he relies on; a document filed with the plaint is not evidence until it is proved in the manner the law requires, unless its genuineness is admitted. Where a party relies on the record of another institution, such as a bank, a hospital or a government office, a certified copy is usually produced, and the certificate is what makes it admissible.
After the plaintiff's evidence closes, the defendant leads evidence. A defendant who does not lead evidence can still rely on the weakness of the plaintiff's case, but he loses the ability to establish an affirmative defence such as payment or a lawful excuse. Where the defendant neither appears nor leads evidence, the court decides on the plaintiff's material.
Arguments, judgement and decree
After the evidence closes, the parties address oral arguments, often supported by written notes. The court then pronounces judgement, and a decree is drawn up in the form the court requires. The decree is the operative document for everything that follows, and the judgement records the reasons. An appeal lies from the decree, and it must be filed within the time allowed by the Limitation Act, ordinarily ninety days for a first appeal from a decree in the High Court and thirty days in other cases.
The decree should be checked before it is drawn up. Errors in the decretal amount, the description of the property or the names of the parties cause real trouble in execution, and the time to correct them is at the stage of drawing up the decree. A review application or an application for correction is far easier than litigating an ambiguous decree during execution.
Execution
A decree is enforced under Order 21 of the Code. The decree-holder applies for execution with a certified copy of the decree, the details of the judgement debtor's assets, and a request for the particular mode of execution: attachment of the bank account, attachment and sale of movable or immovable property, garnishee of receivables, or, in an appropriate case, detention. Notice under Order 21 Rule 22 is required in certain cases before execution proceeds.
Execution is where most decrees are lost, because the judgement debtor may have parted with his property or may hold his accounts in a name the decree-holder cannot trace. The decree-holder's advocate should therefore begin assembling asset information before the decree is passed, from the pleadings, the documents and the inspection of the registrar's records.
The faster routes
A creditor with a liquidated claim can sometimes avoid the full trial through the summary procedure under Order 37, available for suits on a bill of exchange, a hundi or a promissory note, and for suits for a debt or a liquidated demand arising on a written contract, an enactment or a guarantee, in the courts to which the Order applies. Under that procedure the defendant must obtain leave to defend, and the plaintiff can obtain judgement without a full trial if leave is refused. A bank that sues on a cheque and a supplier who sues on a written contract use it where it applies.
Arbitration is the other route, where the contract provides for it. A money claim under an arbitration agreement is resolved by an award, enforced under the Act, and the process is ordinarily quicker than a suit if the parties cooperate and the award is not challenged at every step. Our civil litigation practice runs suits and the summary procedure, recovery suits covers the money side, and arbitration covers the contractual route.
Common questions
How long does a civil suit take in Kolkata?
It depends on the court, the number of witnesses and whether the matter is contested. No one can give a reliable number, and a suit that goes through interlocutory applications and appeals takes longer than one that is tried. The summary procedure and arbitration are quicker where they are available.
Can I file a suit without a notice to the defendant?
Yes, unless a statute or the contract requires notice. A demand notice is still useful, because it fixes the date of default and often produces payment.
What happens if the defendant does not file a written statement?
The court may proceed on the plaint, and the defendant loses the opportunity to raise his defences in the ordinary way. The plaintiff still has to prove his case.
Can the suit be settled during the trial?
Yes, and courts encourage it. A compromise before evidence often saves a portion of the court fee if the state law allows, and it is recorded in a consent decree that is enforceable like any other.
Know the stages and the file stays under control. If you need a suit filed or a decree executed, contact the office; our fees and court appearance rates are published.