An arbitration clause in an agreement to sell is enforceable, and where it is invoked properly it takes the dispute out of the civil court and into an arbitral tribunal. The buyer who wants specific performance, or the seller who wants to keep the earnest money, may find that the forum is not the City Civil Court but an arbitrator appointed by the Calcutta High Court. Whether the clause bites depends on its wording, on the stage at which the objection is taken, and on whether the relief claimed is one that arbitration can give.
The clause is often buried at the end of the agreement, drafted by the broker, and signed without attention. It is the provision that decides where the dispute will be fought, which is the first thing a party should know when the deal collapses.
What the clause has to say
Section 7 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 requires an arbitration agreement to be in writing, and it may be in a clause in the contract or in a separate agreement. The writing can be electronic, and it can arise by incorporation by reference to a document that contains the clause.
A clause that says "any dispute arising out of or in connection with this agreement shall be referred to arbitration" is sufficient. A clause that names the seat, the number of arbitrators and the mode of appointment is better, because it removes the need for a court application later.
Clauses that fail are usually too narrow or too vague. "Disputes regarding the payment schedule shall be referred to arbitration" does not cover a dispute about title, and the buyer who sues for specific performance will not be met with the objection that the whole matter belongs to arbitration. "Disputes shall be settled amicably, failing which by arbitration" is workable, but the party invoking it must show that an attempt at settlement was made.
The reference under section 8
Where a suit is filed in a matter covered by an arbitration agreement, the defendant may apply under section 8, before the first statement on the substance of the dispute, asking the court to refer the parties to arbitration. The court examines whether there is a valid arbitration agreement, and if it is satisfied, it refers the dispute and the suit does not proceed.
The enquiry at that stage is limited. The court does not decide the merits, and it does not decide whether the claim will succeed. It decides whether the parties agreed to arbitrate, and whether the dispute falls within the agreement. Objections about the scope of the clause, the existence of the agreement and the arbitrability of the dispute can be raised before the tribunal under section 16, which has the power to rule on its own jurisdiction.
The timing matters. An application under section 8 must be made before the defendant files his written statement or otherwise submits his first statement on the substance of the dispute. A defendant who contests the suit on the merits and raises the arbitration objection later will usually lose the objection.
Is specific performance arbitrable?
It is. The Supreme Court has moved away from the older view that only a civil court can grant specific performance of a contract relating to immovable property, and disputes under an agreement to sell are now generally treated as arbitrable. The arbitral tribunal can grant specific performance, and its award is enforceable as a decree.
What is not arbitrable is a dispute that concerns rights in rem, or the rights of third parties who are not bound by the agreement. A dispute about the title of the property as against the whole world is not a dispute between the parties to the agreement, and it is not sent to arbitration. A dispute between the seller and the buyer about whether the seller must convey the property to the buyer is a dispute between them, and it is arbitrable.
Where the property is subject to a third party's claim, or where the seller has already sold to someone else, the arbitration may still decide the dispute between the original parties, but it cannot bind the third party. That is a reason to consider joining the third party, or to proceed in the civil court where the rights of third parties have to be determined.
Interim relief while the arbitration is pending
Section 9 allows a party to apply to the court, before or during the arbitration, for interim measures: the preservation of the property, the appointment of a custodian, an injunction restraining the sale of the property to a third party, or the securing of the amount in dispute.
This is the provision that matters in a collapsing property deal. A buyer who learns that the seller is about to sell to someone else needs an injunction within days, and section 9 gives the court the power to grant it even where the dispute is destined for arbitration.
Once the tribunal is constituted, section 17 gives it the same power, and an order of the tribunal is enforceable as an order of the court. The application under section 9 can be made before the tribunal exists, and the court can continue an order made before the arbitration began.
Appointing the arbitrator
Where the clause provides a mechanism and the parties do not follow it, or where one party refuses to appoint, an application under section 11 lies to the Calcutta High Court. Since the amendments of 2015 and 2019, the application is made to the court rather than to the Chief Justice, and the court's examination at that stage is confined to the existence of the arbitration agreement.
The court appoints an arbitrator, and the arbitration then proceeds. The appointment application is not the place to decide the merits, and an attempt to argue the whole case at that stage is usually cut short.
The award and its enforcement
The award is enforced under section 36 as if it were a decree of the court. The party who wants to resist it must apply under section 34 within three months of receiving the award, with a possible extension of thirty days on sufficient cause, and the grounds are narrow: incapacity, an invalid agreement, want of notice, the award going beyond the scope of the reference, or a conflict with the public policy of India.
Until the setting-aside application is decided, the award can be enforced unless the court grants a stay, and the stay is usually conditional on security. For a buyer who has won specific performance, that means the award can be executed while the challenge is pending, subject to the court's order.
Practical points
The agreement to sell should be stamped. An unstamped or under-stamped instrument creates an objection at every stage, and although the courts have softened the position by permitting the instrument to be impounded rather than treating the clause as dead, the objection costs time.
The clause should be drafted to cover all disputes "arising out of or in connection with" the agreement, and it should name a seat and a mode of appointment. A clause that requires the parties to agree on an arbitrator before arbitration can begin is a clause that fails when they cannot agree.
And the clause should be considered for what it is worth. Arbitration is faster and more private than a civil suit, but it is not cheap, the arbitrator's fee is borne by the parties, and there is no appeal on the merits. For a modest earnest money claim, a civil suit may be the cheaper route; for a large property dispute, arbitration often is.
Kolkata: where the applications are made
Applications under sections 9 and 11 in a domestic arbitration go to the Calcutta High Court, and the court's original side handles them under its arbitration practice. A suit filed in the City Civil Court at Kolkata in a matter covered by the clause will be met with a section 8 application in that court, which then decides whether to refer.
Our arbitration practice handles the section 8 objection, the section 9 injunction and the section 11 appointment, and the specific performance practice deals with the decree or the award that follows. Where the agreement itself is being drafted, the property law practice advises on the clause before signature.
Can I still go to the civil court if there is a clause?
You can file, but the defendant may apply under section 8 and the suit will be referred to arbitration if the clause covers the dispute. The court will not refuse the reference because the claim is for specific performance. If the defendant does not object before the first statement on the merits, the right to object may be lost, and the suit proceeds.
Is specific performance arbitrable?
Generally yes, in a dispute between the parties to the agreement. The tribunal can order the seller to execute the conveyance, and the award is enforceable as a decree. The limit is that the tribunal cannot decide the rights of third parties who are not parties to the arbitration agreement.
How long does property arbitration take?
Faster than a suit in most cases, but not fast. The appointment takes weeks, the pleadings and evidence take months, and an award within a year to eighteen months is realistic for a contested matter. A challenge under section 34 adds time, and the enforcement of the award adds more if the losing party does not comply.
An arbitration clause agreement to sell is therefore worth reading before the deal is signed, and worth remembering when the deal collapses. It decides the forum, and the forum decides how long the dispute will last and what it will cost.