Attachment before judgment lets a plaintiff freeze the defendant's property before the suit is decided, so that a decree is not defeated by a defendant who sells everything first. The court will not grant it on a bare allegation of dishonesty. The plaintiff must satisfy the court that the defendant is about to dispose of or remove his property to obstruct execution, and must usually offer security for the damage the order causes if the suit fails.
The provision and its two limbs
Order XXXVIII Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure gives the court power to direct the defendant, on the application of the plaintiff, to furnish security or to place property at the court's disposal, where the court is satisfied that the defendant is about to dispose of the whole or part of his property with intent to obstruct or delay the execution of any decree.
Rule 6 addresses the case where the defendant has absconded or left the local limits of the court's jurisdiction, or has disposed of his property with the same intent, and the court may direct the property to be attached. There are corresponding provisions in Rule 7 for the attachment of specific property.
The two limbs are to be read together. Rule 5 is about property about to be dealt with; Rule 6 covers the defendant who has already gone or already acted. A plaintiff who does not identify which limb applies will have the application dismissed.
What the court insists on
Satisfaction is the key word. The court must be satisfied, and that means material, not assertion. Four things are looked at:
- An intention to obstruct or delay execution. Not merely that the defendant owns property and might sell it. The allegation has to be about the state of mind, supported by facts — a sale deed already executed, an advertisement for sale, a transfer to a relative at an undervalue, a sudden application for a duplicate title document.
- The defendant's conduct. A letter saying the property will be sold, a step to remove goods from the premises, an attempt to withdraw the entire balance from a joint account, an imminent departure from the jurisdiction.
- Substantial cause of action. A plaintiff with an obviously weak claim will not get the order.
- The balance of convenience and the offer of security. The order is a serious intrusion, and the plaintiff must be willing to compensate the defendant if the suit fails.
The courts have repeatedly said that the power is drastic and must be exercised sparingly, on a strong prima facie case and objective material. A plaintiff who simply states that the defendant is a dishonest person will not succeed, however honest the plaintiff may be.
The application and the evidence
The application is filed with an affidavit, ordinarily at the time of the suit and, where urgency is shown, before notice to the defendant. It should set out:
- The claim and the amount, with the documents on which the claim rests.
- The property sought to be attached, described with enough particularity for the court and the bailiff — the plot or the flat, the municipal or the record-of-rights description, the address.
- The facts that show the defendant's intention, in narrative form with dates.
- The plaintiff's undertaking to compensate the defendant if the order turns out to have been wrongly obtained.
Documentary support is what decides these applications. A copy of an agreement for sale that the defendant has executed, an advertisement, a revenue record showing a recent mutation, a message in which the defendant says he will sell — each is worth more than a page of adjectives.
The order and its operation
If the court is satisfied, it may order the defendant to furnish security within a fixed time, failing which the property is attached. Attachment under the rule takes the property out of the defendant's power to alienate, and it is served through the bailiff.
Where the property is immovable, the order is publicised through the sub-registrar's record and, for revenue land in West Bengal, through the office that maintains the record of rights, which is why the description in the application has to match the official record. An attachment that does not identify the property correctly does not bind it, and a buyer who purchases without notice of a properly registered attachment can face the consequences of lis pendens regardless.
Security can be furnished in cash, by a bank guarantee or by a third-party surety. Once the security is accepted, the attachment is lifted. If it is not furnished, the attachment continues until the suit is decided.
When the suit succeeds or fails
On the decree, the attached property can be sold in execution, and the attachment already in place saves the plaintiff the time that a fresh attachment would take. That is the whole point of the remedy.
If the suit fails, the attachment is lifted and the defendant may claim compensation for the loss caused by the order, under the undertaking the plaintiff gave. That risk should be weighed before the application is made, and the undertaking should never be given casually.
A defendant who is aggrieved by an ex parte attachment applies for it to be set aside, and the court hears the application on merits. An appeal lies against an order under the order, and the appellate courts have been quick to interfere with orders that were passed on insufficient material.
Attachment before judgment is not a way to pressurise a defendant into settling. It is a protection against a defendant who is dismantling his assets while the suit runs.
Where the application is heard in Kolkata
For a suit on the original side of the Calcutta High Court, the application is heard by the judge in whose list the suit sits. For suits in the City Civil Court at Kolkata, the application is heard by the court seized of the suit, and for a district suit, by the civil judge at Alipore or Barasat or wherever the suit is filed. The valuation of the suit decides the forum, and an urgent application can be moved on the day of filing with an affidavit of urgency.
Where the relief is urgent, the practical route is to file the suit with the application and mention it for an early hearing, setting out precisely what will be lost if the order is delayed.
Common questions
Can the plaintiff attach a bank account?
A bank balance can be attached, though the account has to be identified and the court has to be satisfied about the account. Banks are served directly, and the order restricts the defendant's operation of the account up to the attached sum.
Is the order available against a third party holding the defendant's property?
It can operate against a person who holds the property on the defendant's behalf, where the court is satisfied of the arrangement. The application has to identify the holder and the property, and the holder is heard before the order is confirmed.
What if the defendant has already sold the property?
The attachment cannot bind a completed sale, but the sale itself is evidence of the intention to obstruct execution and supports the application in respect of other property. A sale at an undervalue to a relative can be challenged in separate proceedings.
Identify the property, document the defendant's conduct, and move early. Our civil litigation practice handles these applications in the Kolkata courts, recovery suits covers the underlying money claim, and property title disputes covers the case where the property itself is in dispute.