A bank is a service provider under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, and a customer is a consumer. When a charge is levied without authority, a failed transaction is not reversed, or a locker is broken into, the customer has two remedies that run on parallel tracks: a complaint to the Reserve Bank's ombudsman, and a complaint before a consumer commission. Both are free of court fees at the first stage, and neither requires the customer to prove a loss beyond what the statement shows.
The four kinds of banking complaint
The first is the unauthorised charge: a fee for a service never taken, a penal charge for a minimum balance that was in fact maintained, an insurance premium deducted without consent, or interest computed on a reducing balance that never reduces. The statement is the evidence, and the bank's own circular or the RBI's directions are the standard.
The second is the failed electronic transaction: money debited at an ATM and not dispensed, a UPI transfer that failed but debited the account, a card transaction that was declined at the merchant but settled later. These are reversed routinely, and they become disputes when the bank's dispute resolution sits on the complaint.
The third is the unauthorised transaction: a card skimmed, an account accessed by someone who should not have had access, a net banking credential compromised. Here the question is not whether the bank was careless but who bears the loss under the RBI's customer protection framework.
The fourth is the locker. A locker is not a deposit; the bank does not know what is inside. But the bank does owe a duty of care over the premises, the vault and the access control, and the RBI's directions on lockers set out the agreement, the nomination facility and the bank's liability for loss caused by its own negligence.
Who bears the loss in an unauthorised transaction
The RBI's framework on customer protection divides liability by the customer's speed in reporting. Where the fraud is due to a third-party breach and the customer is not at fault, and the customer reports within three working days, the customer's liability is zero. Where the report comes after three but within seven working days, the liability is limited by the per-transaction caps in the framework. Beyond that, the bank's board-approved policy governs, and the customer's liability is determined under it.
Where the customer's own negligence contributed, such as sharing an OTP or writing the PIN on the card, the position is different and the bank will say so. The burden of showing negligence is on the bank, however, and a bare assertion that the customer must have shared the credentials is not enough.
Two practical steps decide most of these cases. Report at once, in writing, and keep the acknowledgement or the complaint reference number. The bank's call centre record and the email are the proof of the date of reporting, and the date is what fixes the liability.
Failed transactions and the turnaround
The RBI has prescribed a turnaround time for failed transactions, with a penalty payable by the bank to the customer for delay beyond it. The customer does not need to sue for the penalty; a complaint that cites the circular and asks for the reversal and the compensation usually produces it.
Where the bank refuses, the complaint to the ombudsman is the next step. Attach the statement showing the debit, the transaction reference, the merchant or ATM details, and the bank's reply. The ombudsman's office can direct the bank to reverse the debit and to pay the penalty, and its order is binding on the bank.
The consumer commission route is also available, and it can award compensation for the harassment and the cost. The commission will expect the customer to have complained to the bank first, because a complaint without a demand is difficult to frame as a deficiency.
Locker disputes
A locker agreement is a contract of bailment of the premises, not of the contents. The bank is not liable for the value of the jewellery unless the loss is caused by its negligence or by the fraud of its staff. The RBI's directions require the bank to enter into a standard agreement, to provide a nomination facility, and to fix its liability for loss due to fire, theft, burglary or a similar event at a multiple of the annual rent, with a different position for loss caused by an act of god.
The practical disputes are different. A locker is not opened because the rent was not paid and the bank has drilled it. A joint holder has died and the bank refuses access to the survivor. The customer's papers are inside and the bank will not allow access without a succession certificate. Each of these is a service question, and each has been litigated.
Where the bank has drilled a locker without the notice the directions require, or has refused access to a person entitled under the agreement, the deficiency is straightforward. Where the dispute is about the contents, the bank will say it never knew what was inside, and the customer must prove what was lost.
The ombudsman, and how it differs from the commission
The Reserve Bank's Integrated Ombudsman Scheme covers complaints against banks, non-banking financial companies and payment system operators. The complaint must first be made to the regulated entity, and the ombudsman can be approached after thirty days if there is no reply, or earlier if the entity rejects the complaint. The process is online, there is no fee, and the order is binding on the entity.
The ombudsman decides whether the bank followed the circulars and the fair practice code. It does not usually award damages for mental agony, and it does not decide contested questions of fact that need evidence. The consumer commission does both, and it can award compensation. The trade-off is time: an ombudsman complaint may be resolved in weeks, a commission complaint in months.
A customer should not pursue both for the same relief. Choose the forum, and if the ombudsman's award is inadequate, the commission remains open on the ground that the ombudsman's order does not bar it, though double recovery is not allowed.
Filing in Kolkata
The consumer complaint goes to the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission for the district where the branch is situate, or to the West Bengal State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission at Kolkata where the value exceeds the district limit. Filing is through e-Daakhil or in person, with the statement, the bank's reply, the account statement and an affidavit.
The limitation is two years from the cause of action, which for a wrong charge is the date of the charge and for a refusal is the date of the bank's final reply. Delay is condoned only on sufficient cause, so the complaint should follow the bank's reply closely. Our consumer protection practice handles both the ombudsman and the commission route, and the banking and finance practice covers the transactional side.
Common questions
Can the bank charge me for not maintaining a minimum balance?
It can charge what its schedule of charges permits, and the schedule must be disclosed. A charge outside the schedule, or a penal charge imposed in a manner the RBI's fair practice directions do not allow, is a deficiency.
Is the ombudsman's decision final?
It is binding on the bank, and the customer may accept it or pursue the consumer commission. What the customer cannot do is recover the same amount twice.
What if the fraud happened through my own phone?
The framework still applies, but the bank will examine whether the customer's credentials were compromised by the customer's own act. Reporting at once and filing the cyber crime complaint help, because the police record supports the account of a third-party fraud.
Whose locker is it after the holder dies?
The nominee or the legal heirs, depending on the agreement and the bank's practice. Banks often insist on a succession certificate or probate, and that insistence is itself a point that can be challenged where the nomination is clear.
Keep the statement, the complaint reference and the bank's reply. Those three documents carry a banking complaint through either forum. To discuss a specific charge or a refused reversal, contact our office; the fees are published.