14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Accident & Consumer

Builder delay before the consumer commission

Where a builder fails to hand over a flat on the date in the agreement, a consumer commission can order possession within a fixed time, or a refund with interest, or interest for the period of delay while the buyer keeps the flat. What it will not do is give both a refund and the flat. The choice of relief is the buyer's, and it should be made before the complaint is drafted.

Why the consumer forum is still available

The Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 gives a homebuyer a remedy for delay, and the Act is specific and quick. That does not take the buyer out of the consumer law. The Supreme Court has confirmed that a complaint before a consumer commission for deficiency in service against a promoter is maintainable even where the project is registered under the RERA, because the two statutes operate in different fields and the buyer may choose.

What the buyer cannot do is pursue both fora for the same relief at the same time. A buyer who has obtained an order for interest from the RERA authority cannot ask a consumer commission for interest on the same delay. The election should be recorded, and the complaint should state whether any other proceeding is pending.

The four orders that actually help

The first is possession with compensation. The commission directs the promoter to deliver possession of the flat within a stated period, and to pay compensation for the period of delay, usually calculated as interest on the amounts paid. This is the right order for a buyer who wants the flat and can wait a little longer.

The second is refund with interest. The commission directs the promoter to refund the entire amount received, with interest from the date of each payment to the date of refund. This is the right order for a buyer who has lost confidence in the project or whose circumstances have changed.

The third is interest as damages, where the buyer keeps the flat and wants the loss of use compensated. The commission fixes the rate and the period. The rate is ordinarily in the region of the rate the agreement itself stipulates for delayed payment by the buyer, on the reasoning that the promoter should not be in a better position than the buyer.

The fourth is compensation for the consequences of delay: rent paid for alternative accommodation, interest paid on a home loan for a flat not delivered, and the cost of shifting twice. These are allowed where the buyer has documents, though commissions often fold them into a composite figure.

Proving the delay

Delay is a documentary question. The documents are the allotment letter, the agreement for sale with its possession clause, the payment schedule and the receipts showing payment on time, the RERA registration details, and the promised date of completion as disclosed in the registration. Where the promoter has revised the completion date in the RERA portal, the revision is itself evidence, because it is an admission that the original date was missed.

The promoter's usual defences are force majeure, the buyer's default in payment, and the pendency of approvals. Each is answered with documents. Force majeure requires notice within the period the agreement fixes, and a general reference to the pandemic does not cover a delay that began before it. Buyer default is answered with the payment receipts and the demand letters. Approval delay is answered with the RERA-registered completion date, which the promoter set himself.

The grace period clause matters. Most agreements give the promoter a period of a few months beyond the stated date before delay begins to run. A buyer who counts from the stated date and ignores the grace period will find the commission cutting the claim by that period.

Pecuniary limits and the right commission

Where the consideration paid does not exceed fifty lakh rupees, the complaint goes to the District Commission. Between fifty lakh and two crore rupees, it goes to the State Commission, and above that to the National Commission. A flat in Kolkata priced at sixty or seventy lakh therefore goes to the West Bengal State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, and that is where most Kolkata flat delay complaints are filed.

Territorial jurisdiction lies where the promoter has its registered office or a branch, where the buyer resides, or where the cause of action arose. For a Kolkata project and a Kolkata buyer there is no difficulty. For an outstation buyer of a Kolkata flat, the complaint can still be filed in Kolkata. Buyers of projects in the eastern fringes should also see our Rajarhat page.

Filing and the timeline

The complaint is filed on the e-Daakhil portal or in the commission's filing section, with the complaint, the affidavit, the documents and the court fee. The commission admits it, issues notice to the promoter, and may refer the parties to mediation. Mediation succeeds in a fair number of these matters because the promoter wants to avoid a precedent, and a mediated settlement can be recorded as an order. A demand notice before filing often shortens the matter, and the form is on our legal notice drafting page.

The limitation is two years from the cause of action, which for a delay claim runs from the date possession should have been given. A buyer who waits three years after the promised date, and then pleads that the promise was repeated orally, will meet a limitation objection.

Where the promoter has already given part possession, or an occupancy certificate for part of the building, the buyer should say so precisely, because the commission's order will be shaped by what remains incomplete.

Enforcement when the promoter does not comply

A consumer commission can enforce its own orders. Where the promoter fails to pay, the buyer applies for execution, and the commission can attach property and take steps for recovery. Where the promoter fails to deliver possession, the buyer can seek the assistance of the commission in securing it, and in an appropriate case can ask for the order to be executed through the district machinery.

Delay in execution is the weak point of the system, and buyers should keep the certified copy of the order and the payment receipts in one file from the day the order is passed. Our page on consumer protection explains the execution stage and what documents the commission asks for.

RERA or the commission: how to choose

The RERA authority can order interest for delay under its own section, and its process is designed for exactly this complaint. The consumer commission can give a broader remedy, including compensation for consequential loss and, in a clear case, damages for unfair trade practice. The commission's orders are also enforceable as a decree, which is an advantage.

For a simple delay claim on a registered project, RERA is usually faster. For a claim that includes refund, consequential loss, and a promoter who has been misleading buyers about approvals, the consumer commission gives more room. A buyer should not file in both and hope one succeeds; the second will be met with an objection that the first is pending.

Where the flat is in a project that is not registered although it should have been, the RERA route is complicated by the promoter's own default, and the consumer commission becomes the practical forum. Our page on RERA and real estate sets out the registration obligations.

Common questions

Can a buyer get both the flat and interest for delay?

Yes. Possession with compensation for the period of delay is a standard order. What a buyer cannot have is a refund and the flat, because the two are inconsistent.

Is the delay counted from the agreement date or the RERA date?

From the date the agreement fixes, after allowing the grace period the agreement provides. Where the agreement is silent, the date disclosed at registration is the reference. The commission will read the two documents together.

Can a buyer who has already taken possession claim for delay?

Yes, for the period between the promised date and the actual date of possession, provided the claim is within limitation. Taking possession does not waive the right to compensation unless the buyer signed a document expressly giving it up, which some promoters now insist on.

What if the promoter has become insolvent?

The consumer order can still be passed, but recovery depends on the promoter's assets. Where the promoter is in insolvency proceedings, the buyer's claim is lodged with the resolution professional, and the consumer commission's order is evidence of the debt. Filing early protects the position.

A delay claim is won on dates. The agreement, the receipts, the RERA disclosure and the possession letter tell the whole story, and a buyer who puts those four documents in order before consulting an advocate saves months of argument about everything else.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422