A person who apprehends that a court may pass an order against him without hearing him can file a caveat. Section 148A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, requires the court to serve notice of any application for such an order on the caveator, and to give him a hearing before the order is made. It is a pre-emptive step, and it is the only provision in the Code that exists purely to prevent a surprise.
What Section 148A provides
Where an application is expected to be made, or has been made, in a suit or proceeding instituted or about to be instituted, the person who would be affected may lodge a caveat with the court. The court must then serve notice of the application on the caveator, and the caveator has a right to be heard. The section applies to proceedings in a court of civil jurisdiction and to proceedings under Article 227 in some cases.
The caveat is filed in the court where the application is expected, and it is entered in a register kept for the purpose. It states the nature of the proceedings anticipated, the applicant's interest, and his address for service. A caveat that says nothing about the expected application is of little use, because the court's office has to know what to watch for.
The caveat remains in force for ninety days from the date of filing, unless the court extends it. If the application is filed within that period, the caveat operates. If nothing is filed, the caveat lapses and a fresh one must be lodged.
What it does and does not achieve
It achieves an opportunity to be heard before the order. That is a great deal where the application seeks an interim injunction, an attachment before judgement, an appointment of a receiver, or an order of status quo. An order passed without hearing the affected party is vulnerable, but the vulnerability is not a remedy in itself; the party must apply to have it vacated. A caveat removes that step.
It does not prevent the order. A caveated application can still be allowed after both sides are heard. It does not create a right to notice of every step in the suit, and it does not make the caveator a party. It does not extend the time for filing a written statement, and it does not stay anything.
Nor does a caveat substitute for appearance. A caveator who is served and does not appear has been heard in the only sense the section requires, and the court may proceed. The value of the caveat is that it puts the caveator in the room; he must then be in the room.
When a caveat is worth filing
- A tenant who expects the landlord to apply for an injunction against his possession, or for an order under the tenancy law.
- A co-owner who expects a suit for partition with an interim application for a receiver over the joint property.
- A company that expects a former director to seek an interim order restraining a board resolution.
- A defendant to a money suit who learns that the plaintiff intends to seek attachment before judgement under Order 38 Rule 5.
- A party to an arbitration who expects an application for interim measures before the court.
It is not worth filing where the other side's application is bound to be served in the ordinary course anyway, or where the caveator has no real objection. Filing a caveat in every possible proceeding trains the court's office to ignore them.
How it is filed in Kolkata
- Draft the caveat petition stating the anticipated proceeding, the court, the nature of the order apprehended, and the caveator's interest.
- File it in the court where the proceeding is expected, with the court fee prescribed by the state court-fees law for a petition, and with an affidavit verifying the apprehension.
- Serve a copy on the person who is expected to make the application, with proof of service. Notice to that person is part of the section, not a courtesy.
- Keep the diary number and the caveat register entry, so the office can identify the caveat when the application is filed.
- Where the application is filed in another court, or in another district, file a fresh caveat there. A caveat has no cross-jurisdictional effect.
For a suit of a value within its jurisdiction, the caveat goes to the City Civil Court at Kolkata, or to the Calcutta High Court on its original side for a higher value. For a proceeding in the district, it goes to the district court at Alipore or Barasat or to the court that will hear the matter.
What to do when the caveat works
The court will serve notice, usually with a short returnable date. The caveator must appear on that date with his papers, his reply to the application and his evidence if any. An interim application is often decided on affidavits, so the caveator's affidavit should be ready. An appearance without an affidavit leaves the court with the applicant's version alone.
If the court passes an order after hearing both sides, the caveator's remedy is an appeal or a review, and the caveat has done its work by ensuring that the order was not passed behind his back. If the court passes an order without serving the caveator despite the caveat, that is a serious irregularity and the order can be challenged on that ground alone.
The closely related protections
Order 21 Rule 22 requires notice to the judgement debtor before execution in certain cases. Order 38 Rule 5 requires the applicant for attachment before judgement to satisfy the court that the defendant is about to dispose of his property, and the court must give the defendant an opportunity to show cause. Order 39 Rule 3 requires the applicant for an ex parte injunction to record the reasons for proceeding ex parte and to deliver the documents to the other side within a short time. These are the statutory protections that exist whether or not a caveat is filed; a caveat adds the requirement of prior notice.
For a matter going to arbitration, Section 9 of the arbitration law allows an application for interim measures, and the same logic applies: a caveat in the court where the application is expected ensures a hearing before the order.
A caveat is cheap, quick and narrow. It buys a hearing, which is often the difference between an order that can be answered and one that has already changed the position. Our civil litigation practice files caveats as part of an interim strategy, and the arbitration practice covers the Section 9 applications.
Common questions
How long does a caveat last?
Ninety days from filing, unless the court extends it. If the expected application is not filed within that time, a fresh caveat must be lodged.
Can a caveat be filed before the suit is instituted?
Yes, the section expressly covers a proceeding about to be instituted. That is the usual case, since the whole point is to be heard on the first application.
Is a caveat a substitute for a written statement?
No. It applies to an interim application, and it does not extend the time to file the written statement or excuse its late filing.
What if the other side files in a different court?
Then the caveat in the first court does not help. File in the court where the application is actually expected, and watch the filing to see where it lands.
A caveat is a small instrument with a single purpose: no orders behind your back. If you expect an application against you, contact us; our fees are published.