A challenge to a project's registration is brought by a complaint to the West Bengal Real Estate Regulatory Authority, and the standing to bring it is wider than most people assume. An allottee, an association of allottees, a buyer who has not yet booked, a resident affected by the project, and a competing promoter have all been treated as persons aggrieved in the practice that has grown around section 31 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016.
challenge rera registration cases usually turn on the application the promoter filed. The registration is granted on the promoter's declaration, and where the declaration was false — about the title, the approvals, the encumbrances or the timeline — the registration itself is vulnerable, and the Authority has power to revoke it.
The grounds
The first ground is title. The Act requires the promoter to have a clear title to the land, free from encumbrances, or to disclose the encumbrances. A project registered on land that is mortgaged, subject to a pending suit, or held under an agreement that has not been performed, has a title defect that was not disclosed.
The second is the approval. A project requires the sanctioned plan and the commencement certificate from the local authority, and the registration application must disclose them. A project registered and marketed without the sanction is a project that cannot be built as advertised.
The third is the timeline and the completion percentage. A promoter who declared a completion date already known to be impossible, or who understated the work already done, has made a false declaration.
The fourth is the land itself. Where the project is on land that the promoter does not own and has no lawful authority to develop, the registration is founded on a misrepresentation.
The fifth is the marketing. Advertising or booking without registration is a contravention in itself, and a project that was marketed before registration has already breached the Act before the Authority ever sees it.
Who may bring it, and in what form
The complaint is filed under section 31 in the prescribed form with the fee, and it should identify the project by its registration number. It should set out the specific declaration that is said to be false, with the document that contradicts it: the encumbrance certificate showing the mortgage, the suit number and the status, the municipal record showing that no sanction was issued, the sale deed showing a different owner.
A promoter complaining against a competitor has to show that he is aggrieved, and the Authority will examine whether the complaint is about a genuine contravention or about competition. A complaint that identifies a specific false declaration is more likely to be entertained than one that says the rival project has been marketed aggressively.
The Authority may also act on its own motion on information it receives, and a representation that is not in the form of a complaint can still trigger an inquiry.
The orders available
Where the Authority is satisfied that the registration was obtained on a false declaration, it can revoke the registration. It can also direct the promoter to comply with the Act, to file the missing documents, to correct the disclosures, and to deposit the amounts received into the project account. Penalties are provided for contravention, and the Act makes non-compliance with an order an offence.
Revocation does not by itself return the buyers' money. What it does is stop the project from being marketed and sold, and it opens the way for the allottees to claim refunds and interest under section 18 and for the Authority to direct the promoter to deposit the receipts.
The limits of the remedy
The Authority is not a civil court. It does not decide who owns the land, and a dispute about title between the promoter and a third party is left to the civil courts. A complaint that asks the Authority to declare the promoter's sale deed void is asking for a relief the Authority cannot grant.
The Authority also does not adjudicate the validity of the sanction plan; that is for the municipal authority, and a challenge to the sanction is a separate proceeding before the Kolkata Municipal Corporation's building department or by a writ petition.
Where the complaint fails, the remedy is an appeal to the West Bengal Real Estate Appellate Tribunal within sixty days, and then, on a substantial question of law, to the Calcutta High Court.
Due diligence before booking
The registration certificate on the Authority's portal is the starting point. Read the promoter's name, the project's registration number, the declared completion date, the number of units, the sanctioned plan reference, the land area and the encumbrances disclosed. Then check the sanction plan with the municipality, the record of rights for the land, and the encumbrance certificate for the last thirty years.
A project whose registration shows a completion date that has already passed, or whose declared land area does not match the record, is a project to avoid rather than to litigate about later.
What goes wrong
The first failure is a complaint that alleges fraud without identifying the false declaration, which the Authority reads as a dispute about quality.
The second is a complaint filed after the allottee has signed the agreement and taken possession, when the relief of revocation no longer helps him and the claim should have been framed as a refund or a defect claim.
The third is a challenge brought by a third party whose interest is speculative, which the Authority dismisses for want of standing and which then weakens a genuine complaint by an allottee.
Can a buyer cancel a booking because the project is unregistered?
Yes. Marketing or selling without registration is a contravention, and the buyer can complain to the Authority and claim a refund with interest. The agreement is not automatically void for the want of registration, but the promoter's conduct gives the buyer a ground to withdraw.
Can a competitor promoter object to a registration?
A promoter can complain where he is a person aggrieved, and the Authority examines the complaint on its substance. A complaint founded on a specific false declaration is entertained; one founded on competition is not.
What evidence is needed?
The registration certificate, the promoter's application and declaration, the sanctioned plan and the municipal record, the record of rights, the encumbrance certificate, and the marketing material that is said to be false. The stronger the documentary contradiction, the shorter the proceeding.
Does revocation get the buyers their money back?
Not automatically. Revocation stops the project and opens the way for refund claims under section 18. The recovery itself depends on the promoter's assets and on the enforcement of the Authority's orders.
A registration challenge is a documents case, and it should be built from the Authority's own record rather than from the buyer's experience. Our RERA practice brings these complaints and defends promoters against them, and the title team handles the underlying title questions. Writ proceedings are used where the Authority declines to act. Begin at our contact page.